Anyone could call themselves the "best player in Survivor history" going up against the majority of the Redemption Island cast, though.
You seem forget, Rob mariano basically won S07 All Star
had a very solid gameplay, controlling his alliance and his power couple amber, make super cute young amber fall for him, thats why i hate him btw, ruining amber cuteness
make one of the most memorable move on lex, betraying him cold-bloodedly, make lex cry like a boy who lost his playboy magazine, which is never happen to me ofcourse
turn Rup and Tom against each others, make Tom who usually a funny guy turn into an angry redneck
and dont forget how strong he is, he slam Ethan who is a soccer player and Colby who is captain america so hard that they have residence permit in Slam town
Redemption island castaway are not that stupid and weak ya know, matt is super tough in redemption island can redeem himself and comeback just to be sent back by B rob for second time, broken spirit broken heart in tears lost to andrea who also can comeback from redemption island and again just to be vote off for good, thats how good mariano is
and last but not least anybody who can control half naked phillip in pink underwear hands down is the best player in survivor history
i dont know if ur really survivor fans but if u need me to break it down to u why Boston rob is the best, it must be ur not survivor fan, only a casual viewer
so basically Boston rob won survivor twice with super solid cut-throat strategy and strong performance on challenges, not like so called queen sandra who won twice solely based on super lucky and coat-tail strategy