Topic: All Stars Wish List

[dryedmangoez]

Post-UB I think the teams with the best chance of coming back (most memorable and/or deserving IMO) are

19
Andy & Tommy (they were robbed by the taxi alliance)
Bill & Cathi (super badass seniors)

20 (this could be the new S14)
Art & JJ (to stir the pot and be the designated villains)
Brenchel (drama drama drama)
Vanessa & Ralph (she was a trooper doing that RB in Japan)
Bopper & Mark (easily the fan faves of the season)
and to a lesser extent: Nary & Jamie and Joey Fitness & Dany

21
Chippendales (hot, funny and with a heartwarming story, definitely coming back)
Twinnies (bubbly, competitive, chaotic, and missed on their finale by a technicality almost sure they'll be back)
probably James & Abba and/or Abbie & Ryan

22
Joey & Meghan (lots of young fans)
Pam & Winnie (very competent and entertaining)
Dave & Connor (I think the most deserving team for a second chance, very competent even with a serious injury)

23
Based on the premiere, this could be the unrepresented cycle. Maybe Tim & Marie or the Doctors could be good candidates, but we'll see.

I'd really look forward to a feud between Art & JJ and the Twinnies

I am sure Art & JJ were just extreme trolls trying to stir the pot.  I don't like them, but they would have the oddest confessionals.  Like one time when they were actually complimenting Rachel and seemed very sincere.  It seemed like they were just playing up their sh-t stirring.

And OMGYES to the YouTube fans. I was a fan of Kevjumba before he went on TAR, but his fans (who weren't TAR fans) after he and Papa Jumba got eliminated were so annoying.  Multiply that by 100 for Joey & Meghan.  Ugh.

*sigh* Casuals. Which is one reason I fear a possible fan vote. They could do like BB All-Stars I think, wasn't it half fan voting and half producer's choice?  But they had a wish list you had to vote from. 

[stekay]

At least rating stayed up when Youtubers #2 went home. I loved Meghan <3

[nosyrabbit]

Here's my picks if season 24 would be another return for some contestants

19
Justin & Jennifer
Laurence & Zac

20
Vanessa & Ralph
Art & JJ
Joey Fitness & Danny

21
The Chippendales
Twinnies
Abbie & Ryan

22
JOEY AND MEGHAN
PAM & WINNIE
Max & Katie
jessica&john [maybe, because their memorable (re: stupid) elimination]

23.
Maybe the doctors or leo & jamal

[stekay]

Again if we can only pick post UB:

Season 19:
Bill & Cathi
Justin & Jennifer
Andy & Tommy

Season 20:
Brendon & Rachel
Bopper & Mark

Season 21:
Natalie & Nadiya
James & Abba
Art & JJ

Season 22:
Pam & Winnie
Joey & Meghan
Dave & Connor
Chuck & Wynona

Season 23 potentially:
Rowan & Shane
Brandon & Adam
Hoskote & Naina (For a First Elimination season)

If there was a team post UB:
Brooke & Claire
Carol & Brandi
Ken & Tina
Maria & Tiffany

[MrDeerShank]

Hoskote & Naina  as all stars?? 

[stekay]

 

Hoskote & Naina  as all stars?? 

It was my list for All Stars but I included them because I'd like to see them in a season of first elim. returnees. My mistake I'll correct it

[Theo]

NaNa are locked for All Stars. That's all I'm saying.

[dryedmangoez]

NaNa are locked for All Stars. That's all I'm saying.

I think so too.

[stekay]

They better be 

[RachelLeVega]

The Twinnies are 50/50 on going to be back since they entertained or annoyed the crap out of everyone that season, whether you love them or hate them. However, a setback would be that money taking incident in a Bangladesh travel agency which worked up some slightly controversial feedback.

Those are the most important reasons they should come back. Even if they're hated by some, that makes them more memorable (e.g. Romber in S11)

But many Survivor fans loved Rob and/or Amber and there wasn't much controversy that went towards TAR7 other than Uchenna & Joyce's Caribbean flight re-opening.

[dryedmangoez]

Can an All-Star season go back to Vietnam and have a Basket Boats/Basket Bikes Switchback please?   
With as many teams as possible too, so likely a Westward route.

[stekay]

Can an All-Star season go back to Vietnam and have a Basket Boats/Basket Bikes Switchback please?   
With as many teams as possible too, so likely a Westward route.

Omg that task was incredible. Another Flo-esque moment would be a definite!

[Vitoko]

I wonder what would happen if in a possible All-STAR we see Nadiya&Natalie in the same race as Leo&Jamal, I can only assume it would be a looooooud season...

Also, I'm the only one who wants a team made out of Billy&Carissa from the Gaghan family comeback when they get the right age? It would be such an amazing moment in TV.

[G.B.]

Also, I'm the only one who wants a team made out of Billy&Carissa from the Gaghan family comeback when they get the right age? It would be such an amazing moment in TV.

Billy's in the military now (I think), so that would make things definitely interesting, especially if he refers back to his earlier childish antics.

[georgiapeach]

Also, I'm the only one who wants a team made out of Billy&Carissa from the Gaghan family comeback when they get the right age? It would be such an amazing moment in TV.

Billy's in the military now (I think), so that would make things definitely interesting, especially if he refers back to his earlier childish antics.

Billy just got out of Afghanistan...

[Jobby]

Also, I'm the only one who wants a team made out of Billy&Carissa from the Gaghan family comeback when they get the right age? It would be such an amazing moment in TV.

Billy's in the military now (I think), so that would make things definitely interesting, especially if he refers back to his earlier childish antics.

Billy just got out of Afghanistan...

Yes... that would be epic for fans like us who watched them when they are young and now grown up. Great story from Billy.

I would love for Billy and Tammy though. Think Carissa is still too young. <3 Love the whole family!!!

[theamazingracer21]

Show content

Chester and Ephraim

have to come back. They must have unfinished business.

[Platrium]

Show content

Chester and Ephraim

have to come back. They must have unfinished business.

I completely agree.

[SamualDude]

I actually agree, That was in my opinion the worst luck with flights ever on The Amazing Race.

[stekay]

Idk, just seems like GT 2.0

[Air]

I disagree because A) they weren't any form of relevant characters whatsoever (ROWAN AND SHANE are more likely to be casted, they were eliminated TENTH) B) ninth isn't long enough for a good arc so no casuals will care about them a few seasons down the track. Also I don't see them as like omgsuchstarsmustcastforAS because if you're picking these guys out of all the people on the season then -_-

[Jimmer]

Their story is really sad, but tbh they aren't All Stars material, I think if they would have lasted longer, their character could have developed and they could evolve to be All Stars, but with their race cut short, there is very little chance.

[Vitoko]

I narrow my list to two per season + a third team that we are likely to get but I DON'T want them in All-Star.

TAR19
Andy&Tommy. pretty much the best team of S19, high chance of winning their season.
Laurence&Zac. Competent Father/Son, that we are still lacking this type of winner.
Bill&Cathi surprising team, oldest team ever maybe? not sure.

TAR20
Art&JJ. surprising team that was actually competent and agresive toward the rest of the teams.
Vanessa&Ralph. not really a great team in the rankings but they were really competitive and Vanessa's ankle ended up being too much for her if I remember correctly.
Bopper&Mark somehow made it far with sensitive story.

TAR21
Jaymes&James. Fun, competitive, strong but not so clever guys, quite likeable for some reason.
Natalie&Nadiya. Fun/Annoying to watch, competent and lucky team.
James&Abba. memorable but boring team

TAR22
Pam&Winnie. Competent/Memorable F/F team of the season, either them or
Caroline&Jennifer. I kind of want to see what they would do without Bates&Anthony
Dave&Connor. Father/Son with a great story with a decent chance if not quitting. We are lacking a Father/Son win.
Jessica&John. EP fiasco at the roadblock.

Pre-TAR18
Billy&Carissa TAR8

THIS means they are likely to comeback but I don't want them in All-Star
I reserve the rest of the spots for TAR23 and possible TAR24 because I think TAR25 will be All-Star or UB2 or something like that.

[stekay]

Peach this has made me super excited and the procrastination will begin lol

[Lutpay]

Okay, I never make wishlist of teams or something, but I'll try if Season 24 is really All-Stars.. (in case, they can't go as far back as Season 19)

M/M
Andy/Tommy (S19): this guys are locked, Phil loves them.. they were hated because somehow too strong.
Jaymes/James (S21): All-stars won't happen if they're not in it.
Dave/Connor (S22): They just had 5 episodes, but they're stars of the season, interviewed at the finish line and so on..
^ 3 alpha male teams already.. Yes, we need Bopper/Mark (S20)!

M/F
Brenchel (S20): obvious, boost the ratings
Youtubers (S22): boost the ratings (on Youtube  )
Max/Katie (S22): maybe?
Chuck/Wynona (S22): older couple team
From S23... I don't know. Maybe Nicole/Travis or Jason/Amy? Marie stated on Twitter will decline any 2nd chance.

F/F
Natalie/Nadiya (S21): villain team
The rest is confusing.. Nothing really stands out. Maybe Caroline/Jeniffer or Ice Girls (blonde team)? or Pam/Winnie? Misa/Maiya (poor them)? I wish they could bring Brook/Claire or Charla/Mirna (for every season  )
I think we just need 2 F/F team if F/F teams this season go far.