Other Great Reality Shows > American Idol
Top 5 Discussion
Ruth:
Wow! I never did expect Lauren to EVER be in the bottom two this season, was definitely shocked to see her there. But was it just me, or was there not much shock in the Idol atmosphere? I remember there were lots of boos when Pia was in the bottom two, but not with Lauren and that kinda worries me. I did think she was gonna win this whole thing, but now I'm thinking that Scotty might very well lead the votes all the way to the end. He's unstoppable and so are his voters!
THANK GOD Jacob left tonight, it was high time he went. And wow, who'd think that after all the gender bias in the first 5 episodes, we now have an even number of girls and guys left? I'm amazed! America does get it right after all. =)
Next week, I think Haley leaves. She wasn't in the bottom two tonight (wow!) and her voters might not feel the sense of urgency to vote for her. Lauren's fans will probably vote madly, Scotty has an indestructible fanbase. The only other hope I can hold on to is James getting eliminated but he's never been in the bottom three, which says something about his fanbase. So I guess that leaves us with Haley... Then again, who'd have expected her making the Final 4 after consistently being in the bottom three? I'm impressed and I'm proud of her!
I kinda think Scotty will win this season. It's already down to the Final 4 and his votes are still unbeatable. So... We'll see.
But Lauren, Haley all the way!!!!
ugot2bekidinmeny:
I agree with both Joab and Ruth that Lauren's fans will vote like crazy next week.. :tup: I also think they (production) did that to her because they want to market HER so scaring the crapola outa her and her fans should make a change in how she places next week. that is of course unless she BOMBS a complete song!
I would lve to see Lauren Haley and Scotty as the F3. I think james has a lot of followers and a life after idol but i dont see him winning this at all. if he does.. give me some paper so i can eat my words!! :lol3:
Not once have these kids sung well in group performances! They all sound outa sync each time. It's like a bad Christening party where the kids got the mic! Talk about PITCHY!! :doh:
Ramsey.. poor poor Ramsey.. he has to keep doing all these little stunts to keep the fans of hells kitchen and master chef on his good side!! I believe him as a "filler" for American Idol was a waste!! the man isnt even AMERICAN... :ugot
I'm sure they coulda had some Service Corps groups come in and sing and get a larger rating(considering the happenings of the week)!
Ramsey.. you were FLAT!! :hellkitchen
Ruth:
What I think is cool about this season's Final 4 is that IMO, none of them were really, really strong at the beginning of the competition. I recall when it was still the Top 12 guys and girls week, I was thinking in my mind that if Scotty and James didn't make it to the Top 12, it wouldn't be a pity. Same thing for Lauren and Haley, whether they made it to the Top 12 or not, it didn't matter to me 'cos they were good but not THAT impressive. At least in my opinion. They weren't clear standouts like Pia, Jacob and Casey.
But look at them now! They made it all the way, maybe some of us didn't even see it coming. I didn't expect Haley and James to last so long. I didn't expect Scotty to be more than a one-trick pony. I didn't expect Lauren to grow so much over the season. I think that's what Idol is all about. It's not about us watching early favourites like Pia, Jacob and Casey plateau on stage. But it's about seeing raw talents whom we didn't think much of initially grow and bloom into stars on stage. I think that it's really a beautiful thing!
I think James, Lauren or Scotty could win it. (I can't say the same for Haley but there's no denying she has mad talent and potential.) It's going to be a tough fight for the crown! This makes it so exciting. Last season, it was so obvious that Crystal and Lee were the only ones standing out. Man I can't wait to see what happens next week!
Jobby:
I am praying for a Lauren win. Hallelujah.
Navigation
[0] Message Index
[*] Previous page
Go to full version