Other Great Reality Shows > American Idol

Top 5 Discussion

<< < (3/4) > >>

Jobby:
BEST 3 PERFORMACES:
1. Haley (The house of the rising sun) :jam:
2. Lauren (Unchained Melody)
3. Scotty (Gone)

Clearly, Jacob's toast. If he doesn't leave tomorrow. Expect loads of boos.

I won't be surprise if James belong to the Bottom 2 (if there's any).

And i'm going to be daring and say that Haley, Lauren and Scotty won't be in the BOTTOM 2 at all. :lol3:

Jobby:

--- Quote from: TexasLady on May 05, 2011, 12:31:56 PM ---
--- Quote from: Joab on May 05, 2011, 12:13:47 PM ---Jacob -

First song: No Air...? Wow. That sounded as if like he had no more air to get into the Top 4. If there's one thing James can be happy about, it's that Jacob's song choice was weirder than his. :lol:

Second song: Oh my god, after so many rounds... there's absolutely no breakthrough to his performances at all.

Let's just put it this way, alot of Americans are going to be really unhappy if he stays tomorrow.


--- End quote ---

Joab, did you get the feeling that Jacob was trying to be like James last night? He should just sing, he doesn't need all that drama. He tries too hard. I wish someone would mentor him, just tell him to sing the song, it isn't life or death. He's got the voice. He won't win, he'll be gone tonight or next week.

LOL at your James comments, I so agree with you. And it is good for Hayley! I hope he does this next week to, he'll be out for sure.

--- End quote ---

I really thought James screwed himself big time by trying to "not be himself". What was he THINKING?

As for Jacob... it became a drama moment for him again. I had no idea why but maybe that's just him? Drama and singing = EWWW. (When you're watching a singing competition and not a play)

I don't think Jacob was trying to be James... rather i thought that he has simply run out of his steam. Perhaps he was limited by the song choice or what, but i felt that he was trying too hard. :(

Ruth:
Based on tonight, Scotty might very well replace James in the Final 2. I did think that Scotty would be gone in the Final 4 but come to think of it, it's almost impossible to imagine his MEGA fanbase dying all of a sudden. Maybe we WILL get a Lauren-Scotty Final 2 after all, and Scotty might very well win it. Geez.

Yes, Jacob had better be gone tomorrow. He was clearly desperate in his performances, all that shrieking. James may or may not end up in the bottom 2, I think his fans still love him. What more, he bore his heart, that might just win them over even more. Of course I won't be surprised if he does end up there. But I THINK the bottom two might still be Jacob and Haley.

But... *Prays super hard that Jacob goes home*

ugot2bekidinmeny:
Haley brought the house down!! ♫♫♫ :jumpy:

 Lauren finally got some attitude with her singing. nice to see what she brought to the first  audition back to the fore-front of the show! She does seems like a deer in the headlights  from time to  time in her performances! :lol3:

Scotty did soo well he almost has me changing my mind! :iok

James did awesome as well.

Jacob's time is up if you ask me.. it's always the same  for me with him.. :helpme

Jobby:
WTF. LAUREN IN BOTTOM 2 :meow: :meow: :meow: :meow: :meow:

IF THERE'S ANYTHING I'M HAPPY ABOUT. IT WOULD BE THIS WILL KEEP HER SAFE NEXT WEEK! :tup:

The Final 5 bottom few has produced a few shocker in the past 10 seasons.

In season 8, Kris Allen and Adam Lambert was the Bottom 2 and 3 and both went all the way to the Final 2.

In season 2, Ruben was clearly a front-runner and when he was announced to be the Bottom 2. Everyone was enraged.

In other seasons, the bottom 2/3 which consisted of other inconsistent performer will result in his/her elimination immediately for the next week. But for the case of Lauren, i believe it shocked many and this Bottom 2 placement literally just gave her a one way ticket to the F2. Lauren's supporters will vote crazily for her next week and she won't be in trouble. If i were Hayley's, Jame's or Scotty's fan.. i'll be worried.

I'll say definitely that Scotty is the clear front-runner but you really never know. F4 eliminations has produced shocking results over the years. The most famous being the elimination of Chris Daughtry.

Next week, i really don't know who's going. I think I feel it's Haley. But i'm keeping my fingers cross that it's James. I like James the least out of the 4. But to be truthful, the 4 of them are actually most deserving to be in this position. :tup:

Navigation

[0] Message Index

[#] Next page

[*] Previous page