Other Great Reality Shows > American Idol

Top 8 Discussion

<< < (2/7) > >>

Jobby:
I get what you mean TL. The beat was off by one beat for Scotty! It seemed a bit awkward and too slow.

TL, i think the judges must mix up their comments a little after Pia's elimination last week. They had to do it to help America identify those that the producers don't want to keep in the competition to ruin the show. (IMHO... take it with a pinch of salt) Just look at Lauren. Her comments were like she just had a standing ovation. :lol: They must be thinking they had better not have Lauren eliminated or the whole show might be destroyed.

I think Scotty sang a decent song. That's all. I don't know why the judges didn't like it that much. I thought it was nice on the ear and very soothing to listen to.

Jobby:
Casey was crap. He was flat for a big part at the beginning of his song.

BAD BAD PERFORMANCE. EWWW.

Judges wasted the SAFE!

What a weird performance... if Haley sounded like she's belting out a Karaoke song, then Casey sounded as if he was performing at a bar/lounge.

Jobby:
When i heard Haley's song choice... i was like.......... :groan: :groan: :groan:

She started SHARP!!!

But her uniqueness in the tone of her voice showed in the song. And if it helps, she sang a song that was current and which most of the people watching the show would have heard before!

I think it was an OKAY performance. Not the best, but i think she did decent. WAYYYY better than CASEY.

The ending part of her performance was the best, definitely!

Jobby:
Every week, i'll skip through Paul's performance... today.. he went off pitch and then he went on to put up a mediocre normal performance... and went off pitch again and again. :groan: :groan: :groan:

I fast forwarded his performance again. If I'm Simon Cowell, i'll probably say something like...

"Your performance was so bad and uninteresting that if I were to be on The Amazing Race, i would have fast forwarded to first place"... :lol3: :lol3: :lol3:

I think the best part about his performance was not his singing, but the awesome saxophone lady!

Jobby:
I think Jacob decided to take his mentors advice and stop over performing. He was so sweet, so mild and sang a beautiful ballard this week. But he went a tad bit flat with his high note in the middle of the song.

Not his best performance.. it was just decent, but i don't know if anyone will agree with me.. but the song sounded so boring and I don't think it's memorable.

Navigation

[0] Message Index

[#] Next page

[*] Previous page