Other Great Reality Shows > American Idol

Top 8 Discussion

<< < (3/7) > >>

Jobby:
James going against the mentors... :res:

James had enough energy. It was a good way to close the show. Really sounded good and his confidence was overflowing. Not my favourite genre of music, but really good performance.. undeniable... but i'll just be happy listening to it once.

Jobby:
BEST PERFORMANCE (AND MEMORABLE) OF THE NIGHT: Lauren
GOOD PERFORMANCE: James
OKAY PERFORMANCE: Scotty, Stefano, Hayley, Jacob
BAD PERFORMANCE: Casey, Paul

I think Scotty, Jacob, Lauren and James are confirmed SAFE.

Stefano, Hayley and Paul will be our BOTTOM 3. Paul and Hayley will be the BOTTOM 2. Paul will be going home.

Just a guess. I don't think Hayley will be heading home. Some of the female votes might have went to her. And of course most might have went to Lauren and maybe a little to Stefano.

TexasLady:
Simon would say Paul's performance wasn't even worthy of a cruise ship but maybe a Honky tonk bar.   :lol3:

Upon reflection, I think Casey is in danger tonight and he should be. My husband commented that if he thought he knew more than the mentors then why is he there. Over the years, the singers who act like they know more than the judges and now the mentors, usually find out that they are just plain WRONG as they find their way out the door.  

Joab, I felt Haley was in big trouble last night and voted like mad for her.. not that my puny number of votes will actually keep her there but might help a little bit. I also voted for Lauren. It will just not be interesting if the only girls left are picked off one after another.  :ascared

I also wondered why they let Stefano be dressed like a high school kid, it was off-putting and didn't help him.

Jobby:
I think Paul's time is up.

Ruth:
Wow, it's another night of not having a clear weakest link.

Paul - I must say it was an energetic opening to the show. But I forgot about it as the night progressed. I still can't understand why the judges have been giving him such awesome comments week after week. Come on...

Lauren - I was actually pretty worried when I heard she was gonna do a Miley Cyrus, 'cos in my impression, there doesn't seem to be much that can be done with her songs. But wow, she sang great! And I really felt her. Ahhhh I can really see Lauren winning this, will she survive all the way???

Stefano - I thought that he would almost be a goner this week but I feel that he really picked himself up. Yeah when I knew he was gonna do a ballad, I was like, "Oh no..." But then as he progressed, he really gave me chills. I think based on that performance, he MIGHT be safe tonight? 'Cos I really got the feeling that he's on a new start.

Scotty - It was just another Scotty performance, safe, nice, sincere... Definitely wasn't jumping out of my seat. I liked it though and needless to say... He's not going anywhere. Duh.

Casey - What was that standing ovation for? I give him credit for sticking to his beliefs but it was just an okay performance for me.

Haley - I am incredibly worried about her. I always feel that the most dangerous thing on Idol (especially when there're still quite a lot of people left) is not to give a bad performance but to give a forgettable performance. Which is kinda what she did. The good thing is that there're only 2 girls left and she might just get some of Pia's votes but looking at the fierce competition... I AM REALLY VERY worried.

Jacob - You know when he was singing the song I was totally imagining Pia singing that song lol. But back to him, it was another great vocal and performance from him. And since he was in the bottom three last week, he's safe for sure.

James - I liked it that he stuck to his beliefs as well. Maybe America will be moved by his sincerity. Great close to the show, great performance, but definitely not my favourite from him. But since he got the last spot and all, he'll most likely be safe.

So our bottom three... Paul, Haley, Casey? Maybe Stefano instead of Casey. Gosh I have this intense fear that Haley will go home and we'll be left with 1 girl. Crap, I don't even dare to imagine it. Okay, let's leave it at that.

Navigation

[0] Message Index

[#] Next page

[*] Previous page