Other Great Reality Shows > American Idol

Top 9 (PART 2) 'Elvis Night' Discussion

<< < (2/4) > >>

TexasLady:

--- Quote from: Joab on April 13, 2010, 10:24:55 PM ---Okay, i'll finish up the rest of the videos on youtube tonight!! :lol:

--- End quote ---

Are you putting them up Joab? Let's see them! You can post them.

Unfortunately we had to miss their performances so have to catch up. I'm glad Crystal did well.  :hearts:

realshowfan:

--- Quote from: TexasLady on April 14, 2010, 07:53:47 AM ---
--- Quote from: Joab on April 13, 2010, 10:24:55 PM ---Okay, i'll finish up the rest of the videos on youtube tonight!! :lol:

--- End quote ---

Are you putting them up Joab? Let's see them! You can post them.

Unfortunately we had to miss their performances so have to catch up. I'm glad Crystal did well.  :hearts:

--- End quote ---

You can search them on Youtube. Unfortunately (well, long-term maybe), Tim Urban has received really good comments, it was actually good though. Dunno why he didn't do the high-pitched ending, as Adam said it would give more vulnerability (which means it gives better expression), that might have been able to make the judges liked him even more than they did.

And all I can say is that Siobhan's comments on Simon =  :tup: :tup: :tup: Yes! Exactly what I was thinking when he gave that comment to her! She's a multi-talented singer, just deal with her many capable voices, it just allows her more opportunities to do a lot of different things in the future = better potential! :tup:

Two people will be eliminated though, right? Well, leave it to Joab as he seems to be good at it, while I'm usually on the opposite.  :lol:

Jobby:
Andrew's performance was digging for his own grave. Andrew WILL be eliminated tomorrow and if he stays, there might be some uproar because that means somebody else really good might go.

I liked Michael's performance. It was heart felt and i think he did a good job to prove to the judges that they were not wrong in choosing to use the save on him. He had an expectation to meet, and he met the expectation.. way high above the expectation. Michael should and will be save tomorrow. However, what i do not like about the performance was that there wasn't much of any variations in the song and it might turn out to be boring for some viewers.

Tim had a really good performance, i like the performance. It reminded me of his Hallelujah performance. It was beautiful and sincere. But the problem here is Tim, you've overstayed and I believe your time is up.

Lee was good and i enjoyed his performance. Solid performance and I really agree with Kara, he should loosen himself up abit more!

Siobhan. is. in. great. danger. This girl here... have absolutely no idea what she's doing now. Each week, she's just being random.. singing a song with her first half personality and buthering her song, then changing it up and bringing up her second half personality and screaming/screeching through the song.. which I kinda still like. Like the judges.. i like her second half of her personality more.. but i missed the days she was awesome and just wanted to do some clean slate singing.

Katie and Aaron had 2 enjoyable performances and I really liked it alot!! :)

Ranking of performances for me:
1. Crystal
2. Lee
3. Aaron
4. Katie
5. Tim
6. Mike
7. Siobhan
8. Casey
9. Andrew

Definitely safe tonight: Lee, Crystal, Michael, Casey

Of the five remaining - Andrew, Tim, Siobhan, Katie and Aaron

Andrew and Tim have been in the bottom 2, while Katie and Aaron have been in the bottom 3.

I'm going with my HEART and make the following predictions:

Bottom 3: Andrew, Tim, Siobhan/Katie
Definitely going home: Andrew
Second person going home: Maybe.. Tim

I have a very bad bad bad feeling that Tim will not be going home and there might be a surprise elimination. But, i'll pray for America to vote for the best singers and hope that Tim and Andrew will go TOMORROW!!

Ruth:
I did think prior to the show that Tim and Andrew will go but seeing that Tim did relatively well tonight and with that massive fanbase of his... I guess he's safe and that increases the likelihood that one of the girls goes.

My favourite performance of the night is Lee's! Crystal being in second. I liked Tim and Michael's performances too.

I'm thinking Andrew, Aaron, Siobhan and Katie could be in danger. And probably Andrew and a girl leave. Oh man.

Now I feel that Crystal's the next Melinda Doolittle of Season 6, getting great comments every week until it gets a little predictable and she could just leave at third place. Tim reminds me of Anoop of last season, couple of good weeks but we know he won't go anywhere far. Siobhan's showing not to be the next Adam, she's kinda going downhill. So... I think a guy wins this season again.

Jobby:
I'm all for believing that Crystal WILL win this season. All and all a Crystal fan.

I am going with my heart that America will not vote out anymore girls. :'(

Navigation

[0] Message Index

[#] Next page

[*] Previous page