Other Great Reality Shows > American Idol
Top 9 (PART 2) 'Elvis Night' Discussion
Ruth:
I think the difference between Adam and Siobhan is their focal point. Adam aimed to perform and entertain, and he did just that with excellent showmanship and equally immaculate vocals. But I get the feeling that Siobhan just wants to be strange and different. She's overdoing it and causing more and more confusion each week just because she wants to do something weird. I hope she gets back on track and remembers that this is after all a singing competition. She has a great voice, I hope she'll put it to the correct use. I'm still a fan!
TexasLady:
A lot of excellent comments here. Just playing it back now before the show tonight, Andrew.. he is so gone. Horrible arrangement, horrible idea to sing it. Horrible performance. Aaron, another bad song choice. Ugh. Didn't like it.
Contrary to the judges, I liked the first part of Siobhan's song, hated the 2nd part. She seems to think she needs to do the screeching, big note moment that she had a few weeks ago. It was great then, not great since. I hope she gets back on track too, but I'm tired of the "strange" and "different" routine. Adam was always a performer. He knew his style, he dramatized the part that needed it and changed up his style for the song, but he was always Adam who blew everyone else away and he ALWAYS wore something dramatic and appropriate to add to the overall performance. I think she is in big trouble if not tonight, soon.
I believe Crystal will win. At the moment, I could see Mike, Crystal and Lee final three. (Hope I don't jinx them) LOL
One more thought, with only 3 girls left, I can't see one of the three going home tonight. I think it will be Andrew and Aaron. I sure hope I'm right though. Not Katie or Siobhan.
everbloom:
RESULT SPOILER!!!!!!!!
Oh my frickin' gosh! Seriously, Katie ELIMINATED!! :groan: What's America thinking?? Even though he has a great voice, Aaron so deserved to get the boot last night, and frankly so did Casey. Aaron was rather karaoke and was kinda like Lil Rounds from last season. Casey...yeah. They got Andrew right though.
Tim's stepping up his game. I wonder how much longer he can survive...
Aaron's doing the opposite- he's going downhill. I wonder how long until his time's up (I like his voice though)
Ruth:
Well Andrew was a goner this week. I did guess that Katie was going home but I still had some hope that some other guy would leave! And I knew when Ryan said that Aaron was safe, that the guys should be safe and Katie would be in danger and so she was. Really sad to see her go, she's got a great voice and is really blossoming but well, that's America's choice. Now Siobhan, please step up your game! Geez.
Jobby:
--- Quote ---Bottom 3: Andrew, Tim, Siobhan/Katie
Definitely going home: Andrew
Second person going home: Maybe.. Tim
--- End quote ---
"The other person isn't even in the bottom 3", that's Mike. Mike isn't in the bottom 3. That leaves the last 3 person to be announced from safety to be Andrew (first boot), Katie (second boot) and Tim. last person to be safe)
Okay, i'm sorry Katie, but i jinxed you terribly.
Girl, you're 8th place and you'll be missed.
Right now... 4 out of 6 girls gone.
That seriously sucks.
Even though Siobhan is getting irritating, i do hope she stays. Omg, please let Tim, Mike and Casey be eliminated next. :'(
Navigation
[0] Message Index
[#] Next page
[*] Previous page
Go to full version