Other Great Reality Shows > American Idol

Top 10 Performance Discussion

<< < (2/3) > >>

TexasLady:
Kara annoys me. Didn't like her last year, don't like her this year. I think she's trying to be Simon but she isn't and never will be.  :jam:  I wish Paula had been kept on the panel. Ellen is growing on me and she'd be just as good with Paula there, perhaps better.

Joab nailed it. I didn't think Didi would go but I knew it was really close for her. Why did she sing a song that she knew made her super emotional and not pick one that would have been better for her. She's honoring her friend but she still would be honoring her memory by staying in the competition. I hope she finds her style on tour.  

Ah well. Tim Urban won't be around much longer, that's my prediction. He should be in a series on the Disney or Family channel.  :tup:  (I'm being serious!)

Hopefully Siobhan will get back on track. Just sing next week, give the scream a rest.

Jobby:
My early prediction on next 3 eliminations:
Tim Urban, Michael Lynch, Andrew Garcia

Tim's time is overdue.
Michael doesn't impress us as the other guys will do once in a while.
Andrew just doesn't have the X-factor.

Maybe Katie might go.. but she's getting the Diana DeGarmo vibes for me... since most of the girls are gone.. the voters who like the girls better can consolidate their votes on the girls more now and not spread it among the guys..

Didi's voters will IMO jump ship to another female contestant.. same with Lacey. :tup:

TexasLady:
I can't disagree with you Joab. Tim Urban and, Andrew gone soon.  Andrew has no fire or excitement, Michael is good but not what they want for AI. They were right the first time with Tim, too bad they had to bring him back.

Jobby:

--- Quote from: TexasLady on April 05, 2010, 11:44:41 AM ---I can't disagree with you Joab. Tim Urban and, Andrew gone soon.  Andrew has no fire or excitement, Michael is good but not what they want for AI. They were right the first time with Tim, too bad they had to bring him back.



--- End quote ---

Here are each inidividual remaining top 12 facebook fans stats as of now -

Crystal - 42,215
Andrew - 40,108
Casey - 28,670
Aaron - 24,770
Katie - 19,250
Lee - 18,240
Siobhan - 16,116
Tim - 10,085
Lacey - 8,772
Didi - 5,019
Michael - 4,100
Paige - 2,802

Arranged from most to least. How much of an impact will this stats do?

Will Big Mike be the next to go? Since this is afterall a popularity contest.. and the people who doesn't have the top 4 most fans have never been in the bottom 3.. this somehow shows how popular each Idol is.

Jobby:
According to DialIdol, here's each week top vote receiving idol -

TOP 24
Male: Andrew Garcia
Female: Katie Stevens

TOP 20
Male: Lee Dewyze
Female: Paige Miles

TOP 16
Male: Michael Lynch
Female: Crystal Bowersox

TOP 12
Lee Dewyze

TOP 11
Crystal Bowersox

TOP 10
Crystal Bowersox

So doing some comparison between the 2 sets of statistics i've shown..

We can conclude that:

1. Crystal is getting tonnes of votes, maybe that's where all the eliminated girls votes went to..
2. Top vote getters from Top 24 to Top 16 will be in the Top 12.. that means Lee and Crystal who were top voters since the Top 12.. might make it quite far.. top 5 at least.
3. Siobhan's not getting as many votes as i've expected. Same with Andrew.
4. Casey's getting a really fair amount of vote.
5. Aaron is not as popular as he seems to be.
6. Katie might be in the bottom 3 frequently but she's got a solid fan base.. who might do the magic when need be. (Allison was in the bottom 3 frequent times.. until at the final 5 when she was the top 2 vote getters)

The most important conclusion:
Tim and Michael might be the next 2 boots.. they seemed to be the least popular as of now.

Navigation

[0] Message Index

[#] Next page

[*] Previous page