Other Great Reality Shows > American Idol

Top 10 Performance Discussion

(1/3) > >>

TexasLady:
Usher was a terrific mentor. I enjoyed last night.

Who will go home? I just don't know, any ideas? Tim Urban was laughing but Simon said it didn't matter that he doesn't listen, he'll be back next week. (Probably true.)
It could be Andrew, even though he was praised by Simon last night. Or perhaps  Didi, she picked another bad song. She needs to find her own style and make it work. If she doesn't go tonight she better step it up because her time is running out.

For me the top guy was Lee, his best performance. I've not been a huge fan of his but he showed that he can sing and he fits the R&B, pop style. Loved Crystal. I was so glad she got up from the piano, it was killing her song. She had to concentrate so much on playing that she nearly forgot to sing. When she did stand up and just sing, she made me teary eyed. I don't want her to listen to Kara and Ellen, listen to Simon and stay true to herself.

Katie is getting better and better.

Most disappointing was Siobhan. Train wreck. If I could give her some advice, I'd tell her to just sing. When she just sings, her voice is clear and beautiful but then she starts the screaming. Stop screaming! Stop!

One other comment, I think they are all confused, Ellen tells them wrong song, Kara throws out advice right and left, they don't know what to do.

What say Y'all?

RudyRules:
Hey TL!  :waves:

I say Bring Paula baaakkk.  Kara goooo.  Ellen is better than I expected, but I prefer the original Three judges.  :jam:

Didn't get to watch my Fav Crystal, or Andrew due to a major 3 hour power outage...affecting most of Southern CO.  And of course, could not vote. (:;)

Poor Siobhan, she just doesn't get it.  Why scream when you have such a beautiful voice when used properly.  Sure wish she'd get it together.  Love Casey and hope he gets to the final 4 at least.

Think it'll be Didi or Andrew leaving tonite.

ugot2bekidinmeny:
Did anyone think it was odd that Simon  made a comment to one of the performers/Ryan  as " this is not STAR SEARCH"?  hmmmm  :duno: was that a plug for Paula? :lol:

 and i'm thinking that by the end of this season Simon and Ryan will be at each other's throats. Ryan is getting a bit  confrontational  with him don't  ya think?? :lol3:  go little man! go! :meow:

Jobby:
Best Performance: Lee
Other standouts: Crystal, Andrew

Worst Performace: Didi
Other bad performances: Siobhan, Tim

Who i think will be in the bottom 3: Tim, Didi & (Siobhan)?? Maybe Katie.
Who i think will be going home: If Tim stays, Didi is toast. :(

everbloom:
whoa! nice prediction on the bottom 3 Joab!  :tup:

WARNING SPOILER:

gosh, good-bye Didi. I'll miss your tears. :'(

Navigation

[0] Message Index

[#] Next page