Other Great Reality Shows > American Idol

How I rank tonights performances

(1/3) > >>

mattus:
1 Phil-usually can't stand him but he did very well tonight
2 Lakisha
3 Melinda
4 Blake
5 Chris-the judges were way too kind to him,IMO
6 Jordin-At least she knew she sucked

TexasLady:

--- Quote from: mattus on May 01, 2007, 07:56:50 PM ---1 Phil-usually can't stand him but he did very well tonight
2 Lakisha
3 Melinda
4 Blake
5 Chris-the judges were way too kind to him,IMO
6 Jordin-At least she knew she sucked

--- End quote ---

I'd change the order.

1 Melinda
2 LaKisha
3 Blake
4 Phil
5 Jordin
6 Chris

Phil out did himself tonight. Jordin, it just isn't her style of music. Chris was horrible! Blake could record his song right now.

Two go home tomorrow. I just hope it isn't Jordin but I fear she could.

CeeeJay:
although last night was the firs time i liked lakisha this season..i hope either Her Chris or Phil go.....

melinda i dind' tlike at all last night actually.

ih8summer:

--- Quote from: mattus on May 01, 2007, 07:56:50 PM ---1 Phil-usually can't stand him but he did very well tonight
2 Lakisha
3 Melinda
4 Blake
5 Chris-the judges were way too kind to him,IMO
6 Jordin-At least she knew she sucked

--- End quote ---


I don't know, I agree with Chris and Jordin, mine:

1 Blake
2 Lakisha
3 Phil
3 Melinda
5 Chris
6 Jordin

It was great to see that side of Melinda.  I didn't think she had it in her. 
 

TexasLady:
Welcome to RFF ih8summer!  :waves: :welcome: :waves:

I forgot, they are combining the votes tonight. I wish we knew who was actually in the bottom 3 last week. Jordin was the last one to be told that she was safe.

I didn't like Melinda's song as much as usual either. I base my rankings by what Simon says to them. Last week he didn't like LaKisha, he said she was shouting and he didn't much like Phil. This week he gives her a kiss, go figger.

Navigation

[0] Message Index

[#] Next page