Topic: Survivor Wishlists **NO SPOILERS**

[coolio]

Post challenges, locations, casts, anything you would like to see on Survivor here!

Don't worry bwils, I'm looking into getting your post moved here. 

[Bwils927]

thanks. good idea!

[Bwils927]

Survivor: Heroes vs Villains 2

Heroes:
Brett Clouser - 5th, Survivor: Samoa
Ben "Benry" Henry - 7th, Survivor: Nicaragua
Matty Whitmore - 4th, Survivor: Gabon
Leif Manson - 9th, Survivor: One World
Carter Williams - 6th, Survivor: Philippines
Jane Bright - 6th, Survivor: Nicaragua
Lisa Whelchel - 3rd, Survivor: Philippines
Natalie White - Winner, Survivor: Samoa
Taj George - 4th, Survivor: Tocantins
RC Saint-Amour - 11th, Survivor: Philippines

Villains:
Marcus Lehman - 10th, Survivor: Gabon
Ken Hoang - 5th, Survivor: Gabon
Jim Rice - 12th, Survivor: South Pacific
Troyzan Robertson - 8th, Survivor: One World
Pete Yurkowski - 8th, Survivor: Philippines
Sierra Reed - 7th, Survivor: Tocantins
Kim Spradlin - Winner, Survivor: One World
Abi-Maria Gomes - 5th, Survivor: Philippines
Natalie Bolton - 4th, Survivor: Micronesia
Chelsea Meissner - 3rd, Survivor: One World

I'm hoping old rivalries will come out during this, Troyzan vs Kim & Chelsea, Kenny vs Marcus, RC vs Abi & Pete

[Bwils927]

Possible Locations:

Cape Verde
Ethiopian Highlands
Zambia
Madagascar
Bangladesh

[Leafsfan.]

Possible Locations:

Cape Verde
Ethiopian Highlands
Zambia
Madagascar
Bangladesh

Bangladesh where?

[Bwils927]

Along some river, maybe in the Northeast

[Air]

Possible Locations:

Ethiopian Highlands
Madagascar

Not ripping off Racer's or Joab's game at all.

And I would LOVE to see Vietnam, for some reason. Or Laos <33333

[Glamazon Racer]

Possible Locations:

Ethiopian Highlands
Madagascar

Not ripping off Racer's or Joab's game at all.

 

[Glamazon Racer]

Survivor: Heroes vs Villains 2

Heroes:
Brett Clouser - 5th, Survivor: Samoa
Ben "Benry" Henry - 7th, Survivor: Nicaragua
Matty Whitmore - 4th, Survivor: Gabon
Leif Manson - 9th, Survivor: One World
Carter Williams - 6th, Survivor: Philippines
Jane Bright - 6th, Survivor: Nicaragua
Lisa Whelchel - 3rd, Survivor: Philippines
Natalie White - Winner, Survivor: Samoa
Taj George - 4th, Survivor: Tocantins
RC Saint-Amour - 11th, Survivor: Philippines

Villains:
Marcus Lehman - 10th, Survivor: Gabon
Ken Hoang - 5th, Survivor: Gabon
Jim Rice - 12th, Survivor: South Pacific
Troyzan Robertson - 8th, Survivor: One World
Pete Yurkowski - 8th, Survivor: Philippines
Sierra Reed - 7th, Survivor: Tocantins
Kim Spradlin - Winner, Survivor: One World
Abi-Maria Gomes - 5th, Survivor: Philippines
Natalie Bolton - 4th, Survivor: Micronesia
Chelsea Meissner - 3rd, Survivor: One World

I'm hoping old rivalries will come out during this, Troyzan vs Kim & Chelsea, Kenny vs Marcus, RC vs Abi & Pete

That's quite interesting.

I don't really think Benry would be brought back. He was unmemorable for me. Leif barely got any screentime the first time round. :/ And I don't understand why RC would be classified as a Hero? Other than that, I quite like your Heroes tribe.

As for the Villains, I don't really see Marcus or Ken from Gabon as Villains, although I kinda understand why you might consider Ken this way. I REALLY don't want to see Jim again. Troyzan was meh, but all right. Kim is not a Villain, she's a Robot, as far as I'm concerned. She'd belong on the 'lack of personality' tribe, imo. I would absolutely LOVE to see all of your other Villains again, although I can't understand why Chelsea would be considered a Villain? She was a Hero from my viewpoint...

[Bwils927]

Kenny definitely was a villain, but Marcus maybe not as much. Chelsea and Kim are there just because Kim led the all girls alliance and Chelsea was a big help to her. I had to squeeze in Jim and RC because I really didn't want anyone before S16, and I had looked through all the seasons before putting them in. Jim was a douche to Cochran, but also loyal in a way, but his hatred of Cochran + Upolu makes him a villain, and he was good in challenges, so the tribe would like him. RC because she was smart and didn't do anything wrong in a villain way. I loved Benry and Leif so I had to have them. And by the way, the Heroes in this would destroy in the challenges. Brett, Benry, Matty, Leif, Carter were all dominant in their season. Not Leif so much at the merge, but he rocked in some early challenges.

[Bwils927]

This would make for an interesting season I think.

Survivor: Favorites vs Forgotten.

Favorites:
Malcolm Freberg - 4th, Survivor: Philippines
Ben "Benry" Henry - 7th, Survivor: Nicaragua
Jud "Fabio" Birza - Winner, Survivor: Nicaragua
Carter Williams - 6th, Survivor: Philippines
Stephen Fishbach, 2nd, Survivor: Tocantins
Lisa Whelchel - 3rd, Survivor: Philippines
Kim Spradlin - Winner, Survivor: One World
Taj George - 4th, Survivor: Tocantins
Natalie Bolton - 4th, Survivor: Micronesia
Brenda Lowe - 10th, Survivor: Nicaragua

Forgotten:
Zane Knight - 18th, Survivor: Philippines
Rick Nelson - 5th, Survivor: South Pacific
James "Rocky" Reid - 12th, Survivor: Fiji
Erik Cardona - 12th, Survivor: Samoa
Dan Kay - 11th, Survivor: Gabon
Allie Pohevitz - 19th, Survivor: Caramoan
Jill Behm - 13th, Survivor: Nicaragua
Marisa Calihan - 20th, Survivor: Samoa
Mary Sartain - 19th, Survivor: Micronesia
Roxy Morris - 17th, Survivor: Philippines

[MrDeerShank]

Survivor: Heroes vs Villains 2

Heroes:
Brett Clouser - 5th, Survivor: Samoa
Ben "Benry" Henry - 7th, Survivor: Nicaragua
Matty Whitmore - 4th, Survivor: Gabon
Leif Manson - 9th, Survivor: One World
Carter Williams - 6th, Survivor: Philippines
Jane Bright - 6th, Survivor: Nicaragua
Lisa Whelchel - 3rd, Survivor: Philippines
Natalie White - Winner, Survivor: Samoa
Taj George - 4th, Survivor: Tocantins
RC Saint-Amour - 11th, Survivor: Philippines

Villains:
Marcus Lehman - 10th, Survivor: Gabon
Ken Hoang - 5th, Survivor: Gabon
Jim Rice - 12th, Survivor: South Pacific
Troyzan Robertson - 8th, Survivor: One World
Pete Yurkowski - 8th, Survivor: Philippines
Sierra Reed - 7th, Survivor: Tocantins
Kim Spradlin - Winner, Survivor: One World
Abi-Maria Gomes - 5th, Survivor: Philippines
Natalie Bolton - 4th, Survivor: Micronesia
Chelsea Meissner - 3rd, Survivor: One World

I'm hoping old rivalries will come out during this, Troyzan vs Kim & Chelsea, Kenny vs Marcus, RC vs Abi & Pete

They probably won't have anyone who has played pre-HvV 1, otherwise, wouldn't they have just used them again? :p Also, where's Mike Chiesl from Survivor: Redemption Island? Surely he should be placed on the Heroes tribe after he basically let everyone spend time with their loved ones! Also, RC as a hero? Ew, no, so swap Mike with RC and we're good (but obviously, there'd probably need to be another female instead of of a male, so idk, remove Carter and replace him with either Laura Alexander from Caramoan (although she got voted out early) or Sherri Biethman (if she survives for quite a while))

[Bwils927]

I like Carter too much to take him out to listen to Laura's voice. But I also really liked Mike. Maybe him instead of Brett.

[MrDeerShank]

Survivor: The Winners Circle (16-20 previous winners all playing again)

And in no particular order...

Richard Hatch - Survivor: Borneo
JT Thomas - Survivor: Tocantins
Rob Mariano - Survivor: Redemption Island
Tom Westman - Survivor: Palau
Ethan Zohn - Survivor: Africa
Yul Kwon - Survivor: Cook Islands
Bob Crowley - Survivor: Gabon
Aras Baskauskas - Survivor: Panama
Tina Wesson - Survivor: The Australian Outback
Parvati Shallow - Survivor: Micronesia
Kim Spradlin - Survivor: One World
Sandra Diaz-Twine - Survivor: Pearl Islands, Survivor: Heroes vs Villains
Jenna Morasca - Survivor: The Amazon
Danni Boatwright - Survivor: Guatemala
Natalie White - Survivor: Samoa
Vecepia Towery - Survivor: Marquesas

(The other four are whether they want a bigger cast or not...

Todd Herzog - Survivor: China
Earl Cole - Survivor: Fiji
Denise Stapley - Survivor: Philippines
Sophie Clarke - Survivor: South Pacific)

[Bwils927]

Boston Rob has played too much, Hatch hasn't paid his taxes. That opens up windows for Todd and Earl

[Air]

I forgot, I also want a Survivor Sao Tome and Principe (though how they are going to fit that on a logo is beyond me )

[Air]

And bwils Brenda needs to be somewhere on your lists kthx.

[Jobby]

We obviously need Heroes VS Villians 2. I'll watch an Allstars Survivor anyday. These days the new players are just MEH. (except for Sherri)

[Alfwin]

I think the reason why we don't have a All All-Star season is because of the 'meh' contestant that we have been receiving.I mean look at this season.The 'Favorites' don't even look so favourite-ey.The pool of good Survivors are very limited this time round.

[Bwils927]

We obviously need Heroes VS Villians 2. I'll watch an Allstars Survivor anyday. These days the new players are just MEH. (except for Sherri)

She annoys me with the fact that she blows at most challenges and has come back and stated "muscle doesn't win challneges". she lost the tile challenge for them, and highly contributed to losing the coconut in the net challenge.

And bwils Brenda needs to be somewhere on your lists kthx.

trust me I love Brenda. But i'm very against people playing 3 times and tried to avoid it as much as possible

[coolio]

My Heroes vs Villains Two
~Heroes~
Lisa Whelchel- Philipines, 2nd place
Sabrina Thompson- One World, 2nd place
Kat Edorsson- One World, 7th place
Matt Elrod- Redemption Island, 6th place
Jane Bright- Nicaragua, 6th place
Brendan Synnott- Tocantins, 9th place
Frosti Zernow- China, 8th place
Adam Gentry- Cook Islands, 5th place
Rafe Judkins- Guatemala, 3rd place
Heidi Strobel- Amazon, 5th place


~Villains~
Abi-Maria Gomes- Philippines, 5th place
Pete Yurkowski- Philippines, 8th place
Marty Piombo- Nicaragua, 11th place
Alina Wilson- Nicaragua, 12th place
Laura Morett- Samoa, 10th place
Sierra Reed- Tocantins, 7th place
Natalie Bolton- Micronesia, 4th place
Todd Herzog- China, 1st place
Dreamz Herd- Fiji- 2nd place
Shane Powers- Panama, 5th place

[Bwils927]

That seems really good. Brendan Synnott would have been a great player if he was around longer. Matt Elrod was invited back for this season but said he didn't want survivor to define his life. I want him to come back though 

[Jobby]

We obviously need Heroes VS Villians 2. I'll watch an Allstars Survivor anyday. These days the new players are just MEH. (except for Sherri)

She annoys me with the fact that she blows at most challenges and has come back and stated "muscle doesn't win challneges". she lost the tile challenge for them, and highly contributed to losing the coconut in the net challenge.

You know what, it was their inability to plan who to pull the ropes as a tribe that failed that challenge. Why were strong guys Eddie and Reynold throwing when they obviously should be pulling? Food for thought? I mean, Brenda and all the other girls can throw just fine, why did they pick two weak and older guys to pull the coconuts?

It's a whole tribe's fault and honestly, Sherri was right. They did lose, was it her fault. Maybe? Was it entirely her fault? No.

To be honest the only two players I felt are worthy to watch on the Favourites tribe are Sherri and Reynold. And they dislike each other, hence their fans will most likely not root for one another too. I am on Sherri's camp, and you are on Reynold's camp. I know you hate Sherri, but you know what... I don't really care because Sherri's obviously a much better player in terms of strategic and moves.

[Bwils927]

We obviously need Heroes VS Villians 2. I'll watch an Allstars Survivor anyday. These days the new players are just MEH. (except for Sherri)

She annoys me with the fact that she blows at most challenges and has come back and stated "muscle doesn't win challneges". she lost the tile challenge for them, and highly contributed to losing the coconut in the net challenge.

You know what, it was their inability to plan who to pull the ropes as a tribe that failed that challenge. Why were strong guys Eddie and Reynold throwing when they obviously should be pulling? Food for thought? I mean, Brenda and all the other girls can throw just fine, why did they pick two weak and older guys to pull the coconuts?

It's a whole tribe's fault and honestly, Sherri was right. They did lose, was it her fault. Maybe? Was it entirely her fault? No.

To be honest the only two players I felt are worthy to watch on the Favourites tribe are Sherri and Reynold. And they dislike each other, hence their fans will most likely not root for one another too. I am on Sherri's camp, and you are on Reynold's camp. I know you hate Sherri, but you know what... I don't really care because Sherri's obviously a much better player in terms of strategic and moves.

That's a good point, and it's why she highly contributed to the loss, not 100% lost it for them

[Air]

Who would you bring back for another chance at Survivor?

Please presume that nobody has ever been asked back yet.

My ultimate list would be Brenda, Parvati, Penner <3

And Peih-Gee <3