Reality Fan Forum - The Amazing Race Spoilers - Big Brother Live Feed Updates - Survivor Spoilers - Reality TV Spoilers - Big Brother Spoilers
Archive => RFF Archived Boards => Survivor Samoa => Topic started by: puddin on October 08, 2009, 10:51:12 AM
Title: S19 EP5: "Walking on Thin Ice"
Post by: puddin on October 08, 2009, 10:51:12 AM
10/15 Survivor: Samoa - Walking on Thin Ice
Title: Re: S19 EP5: "Walking on Thin Ice"
Post by: puddin on October 08, 2009, 10:57:03 PM
JP: Next time on Survivor ..maybe the worst thing out here Natalie to Ashley: these black clouds scare me Liz: it's been raining for 48 hours Jaison conf: I have never in my life been this cold. Kelly: All our blankets are wet... there's nowhere around here to sort of hide Liz to Evil Russ: you were lying to me! Russ: Let me tell you, you're walking on thin ice! JP: Liz struggling to hang on!
Title: Re: S19 EP5: "Walking on Thin Ice"
Post by: puddin on October 09, 2009, 11:25:46 AM
video!
Title: Re: S19 EP5: "Walking on Thin Ice"
Post by: Ruth on October 09, 2009, 12:57:30 PM
Uh oh, doesn't bode too well for Liz, or is it too obvious that she might be voted? Maybe Foa Foa loses YET another challenge. Surprise, surprise.
Title: Re: S19 EP5: "Walking on Thin Ice"
Post by: puddin on October 09, 2009, 02:32:11 PM
If the spoilers hold true, Ashely should be the boot with Liz being the misdirection.
Title: Re: S19 EP5: "Walking on Thin Ice"
Post by: puddin on October 09, 2009, 04:32:13 PM
THE ELEMENTS TAKE A HEFTY TOLL ON BOTH TRIBES AS HEAVY RAINSTORMS POUND AWAY AT THE ISLAND AND AT THE SPIRITS OF THE CASTAWAYS, ON "SURVIVOR: SAMOA" THURSDAY, OCT. 15 "Walking On Thin Ice" — When a new power player emerges at Foa Foa, Russell desperately scrambles to regain control of the tribe, on SURVIVOR: SAMOA, Thursday, Oct. 15 (8:00-9:00 PM ET/PT) on the CBS Television Network.
Title: Re: S19 EP5: "Walking on Thin Ice"
Post by: Belle Book on October 10, 2009, 10:27:00 AM
I think (or at least hope) Liz is misdirection. Ashley's probably the boot, most likely because Liz proves herself in the Immunity Challenge and Ashley doesn't.
Belle Book
Title: Re: S19 EP5: "Walking on Thin Ice"
Post by: s1 on October 10, 2009, 02:23:28 PM
Russ H. has wanted Ashley out for a couple weeks now. Went with Jaison their last vote to get out Ben and smooth things over with the understanding Ashley was next. CBS is probably planting a seed of doubt with Liz to make it not so obvious that Ashley is going.
Title: Re: S19 EP5: "Walking on Thin Ice"
Post by: Jobby on October 11, 2009, 08:28:52 AM
And Foa Foa will be down to 5 VS 9? o_O
Or maybe it will be a double TC. Ought to even things up abit by Survivor Producers.
Title: Re: S19 EP5: "Walking on Thin Ice"
Post by: puddin on October 11, 2009, 12:05:24 PM
Looks like FoaFoa wins reward as Shambo is with them in the march to IC
Videos thanks to SurvivorPhoenix
Title: Re: S19 EP5: "Walking on Thin Ice"
Post by: Ruth on October 12, 2009, 12:27:03 PM
Yeah, it's too obvious if Liz is the boot. So I guess we say goodbye to Ashley. =(
Title: Re: S19 EP5: "Walking on Thin Ice"
Post by: puddin on October 12, 2009, 06:16:44 PM
press images
Title: Re: S19 EP5: "Walking on Thin Ice"
Post by: puddin on October 12, 2009, 06:20:08 PM
immunity challenge "Sack Attack"
Title: Re: S19 EP5: "Walking on Thin Ice"
Post by: puddin on October 12, 2009, 06:21:09 PM
reward challenge "Samoa Smoothies"
Title: Re: S19 EP5: "Walking on Thin Ice"
Post by: puddin on October 12, 2009, 06:23:25 PM
and one more
Title: Re: S19 EP5: "Walking on Thin Ice"
Post by: puddin on October 12, 2009, 07:53:01 PM
Survivor: Samoa - A Samoa Smoothie!
Title: Re: S19 EP5: "Walking on Thin Ice"
Post by: puddin on October 14, 2009, 02:47:23 PM
Take a behind the scenes look at this week's immunity challenge 'Sack Attack'. Watch Thursday at 8pm to see which team wins and is safe from Tribal Council.
Title: Re: S19 EP5: "Walking on Thin Ice"
Post by: puddin on October 14, 2009, 02:50:57 PM
TDT
REWARD CHALLENGE: "Samoa Smoothies" (gross food) - Galu wins? IMMUNITY CHALLENGE: "Sack Attack" - Galu wins HIDDEN IMMUNITY IDOLS: Shambo visits Foa Foa, for no obvious reason BOOT: Ashley? Jaison? Survivor: Samoa episode 5 detailed boot spoilers/ speculation Setting aside any alleged spoilers floating around, the focus in the post-Ep4 preview was pretty much all Foa Foa again, suggesting they're returning to their tribal council home-away-from-home this week.
Who's most at risk? Half the tribe: Jaison, Liz and Ashley.
Jaison has been on Russell H's new hit list ever since the Ben boot, and has complained about the conditions for two episodes straight. He thought about quitting before the Ben vote, and said in Ep4 that coming on the show was the worst decision he's made in his life... how will 48 straight hours of rain make him feel? Liz also gets a soggy treatment in the Ep5 preview: Arguing with Russell H (didn't work out so well for Marisa or Betsy), complaining about the rain (fire is life, so water is the opposite), and "struggling to hang on" in what looks like the IC (in Probst's own words). Not good portents. And finally there's Ashley, who was Russell's first choice for a target in the previous Foa Foa tribal council visit. Compared to Jaison and Liz, she gets a relatively positive treatment in the preview (listening to Natalie worry about the looming dark clouds).
Of these, Jaison has proven his worth in the challenges, as has Liz to some extent. Ashley hasn't done much of anything. But it comes down to who Russell wants out the most. In Russell's negative energy strategy, forcing Jaison to stick around when he clearly doesn't want to be there works to Russell's advantage, plus he's relatively loyal. But it's hard to tell who Russell would want out between Russell and Ashley.
With respect to alleged spoilers, missyae has two, possibly three, stories: (1) missyae 10/4/09 12:45 a.m. "The next player that will be booted from Foa Foa when they go back to Tribal will be Ashley Trianer." (2) missyae 10/8/09 2:43 a.m. (see also the reply, three posts down) "Okay the way I am told the events happen is after Yasmin is voted out this week - Russell Swan goes down during a challenge - then Ashley is voted out for Foa Foa."
Clearly, both can't be true. When we pointed out that the second story doesn't make sense, since EW (reasonably) explicitly states that the next (and last) medical evacuation takes place in Ep6, not Ep5, he responded with: (3) missyae 10/8/09 4:01 p.m. "When Russell goes down in the challenge - Foa Foa had a lead and thought they had it won. BOTH tribes go to Tribal Council and sit and talk with Jeff and NOBODY is voted out." This actually makes even less sense - unless they do something crazy and do double boots in the jury phase (which has never been done, and would require two votes at tribal council, and so is highly unlikely), the show needs to shed three people in the next two episodes, not just one (or two), in order to have the final five in the finale on Sunday, December 13 (as the CBS Fantasy rules state).
So something is still amiss. A fourth story emerged later (just prior to Ep4): (4) missyae 10/8/09 5:28 p.m. "Yasmin is tonight. After that the next person to be voted out when Foa Foa goes to Tribal is Ashley. Russell S is the player to go down in the challenge everyone is talking about. He is the medivac. After he leaves they have both tribes meet at Tribal and I was told it was very boring and they knew nobody was leaving so it was a waste of time. But anyway - when that happens - nobody is voted out at that Tribal. They merge at 8 Galu and 4 Foa Foa." Note that there's now a mystery Foa Foa person disappearing somewhere in the next two episodes (Alien abduction? The Rapture?), since Ashley is the only one mentioned being booted, and Foa Foa currently has six members. Although at least the Ashley-Russell S. order now makes sense. Small victories.
But there are also some (admittedly vague) contradictory notes concerning Ashley's allegedly imminent departure, Redmond at Sucks reports a rumor that both alternates (Ashley and Erik) "went far." True, two weeks into the show might be construed as reasonably far. Hard to say.
Title: Re: S19 EP5: "Walking on Thin Ice"
Post by: puddin on October 14, 2009, 02:57:11 PM
missyae is now posting at survivorskills and blows, DanieuBleu has done a nice job summing up missyae spoilers .. I guess we'll see if the spoilers hold true or not? this week will be very telling.
and many thanks to anyone who can jump in and help update tonight's show here! :jumpy:
Title: Re: S19 EP5: "Walking on Thin Ice"
Post by: puddin on October 15, 2009, 07:00:49 PM
hey peach I'm sort of here :lol: :waves:
Title: Re: S19 EP5: "Walking on Thin Ice"
Post by: puddin on October 15, 2009, 07:03:22 PM
Galu, night time after TC
(I still dont know whos who on Galu :lol:)
Monica knows that Shambo is the one that voted against her
credits run
Title: Re: S19 EP5: "Walking on Thin Ice"
Post by: ZBC Company on October 15, 2009, 07:04:29 PM
Comrical break
Title: Re: S19 EP5: "Walking on Thin Ice"
Post by: puddin on October 15, 2009, 07:05:23 PM
JP was sure building Shambo up as the underdog on Galu, lost the fishing gear, let the chicken run loose, voted against Monica ... FoaFoa is her friend
Title: Re: S19 EP5: "Walking on Thin Ice"
Post by: georgiapeach on October 15, 2009, 07:07:12 PM
I have to get it in one take tonight as I have no way to rewatch...so I won't be updating tonight...hope some of y'all can help out please? :waves:
Title: Re: S19 EP5: "Walking on Thin Ice"
Post by: puddin on October 15, 2009, 07:10:30 PM
Galu day 12, Erik in the tides .. angry ocean
Foa camp ..crazy ocean treemail food reward challenge -- stuff from the ocean Ashley excited hopes shes strong
Liz to Russ worried about Ashely in the food challenge
Russ tells the boys that Liz is spreading seeds
Russ tells us shes a huge thread, he controls the mind games not Liz
RC
time to eat slugs and junk
Title: Re: S19 EP5: "Walking on Thin Ice"
Post by: puddin on October 15, 2009, 07:16:47 PM
tribes playing for food, BBQ and send one of their own to the other tribe
kelly laura john sit out
shambo vs jaison
tie 1-1
battle of the russells
tie 2-2
mick vs brett
tie 3-3
monica vs liz
tie 4-4
Title: Re: S19 EP5: "Walking on Thin Ice"
Post by: puddin on October 15, 2009, 07:17:14 PM
dave vs ashely
seas slugssssssssssssss
ewwwwwww
Title: Re: S19 EP5: "Walking on Thin Ice"
Post by: puddin on October 15, 2009, 07:20:22 PM
ash cant do it
Galu wins sends Shambo to Foa
Shambo not happy at all "can you spread the love?" .. had to pay for that chicken
Shambo in conf is pissed she missing out on the protein her body needs
Title: Re: S19 EP5: "Walking on Thin Ice"
Post by: georgiapeach on October 15, 2009, 07:21:32 PM
Not the show to be eating dinner while watching! barrrrrrf! :lol:
Title: Re: S19 EP5: "Walking on Thin Ice"
Post by: puddin on October 15, 2009, 07:27:21 PM
Foa day 12
Shambo gets a group hug
Mick was surprised that Ash sucked in the challenge
Ash mad at hersel
Nat in conf: were like sisters wanted to make her feel better
Galu camp .. putting the food on
Russ justifies sending Shambo because of the chicken
Dave conf --Russ screwing up the fire
Dave and Russ argue about the fire
Title: Re: S19 EP5: "Walking on Thin Ice"
Post by: puddin on October 15, 2009, 07:28:01 PM
Not the show to be eating dinner while watching! barrrrrrf! :lol:
How disgusting was that? NEVEREEEERRRRRRRRRR!! Not ME!
Title: Re: S19 EP5: "Walking on Thin Ice"
Post by: puddin on October 15, 2009, 07:30:16 PM
Shambo sharing the clue to the HII with the Foas Russ conf .. its in my pocket haha They speculate that Ben had it Liz in conf -- maybe Russell Liz confronts Russ he lies Russ is pissed that shes threatening him
commercial
Title: Re: S19 EP5: "Walking on Thin Ice"
Post by: puddin on October 15, 2009, 07:32:45 PM
Amazing RAce commercial, CBS loves us! (same as the web promo)
Title: Re: S19 EP5: "Walking on Thin Ice"
Post by: georgiapeach on October 15, 2009, 07:33:15 PM
I'll post the preview screencaps in EP6 thanks for the help peach :waves:, go sit on the beach or something :meow:
But but...It is DARK outside and there are crazy flying frogs here! :lol3:
It is so nice to have the pics along with the commentary puddin! :thankyou:
See y'all next week! :waves:
Title: Re: S19 EP5: "Walking on Thin Ice"
Post by: Jobby on October 16, 2009, 07:11:02 AM
Firstly, the part where Russell bitched with Liz, was very rude and extremely chauvinistic for me. I was very disturbed by it and hated Russell 958345798457845 times more now.
You go girl Liz, loved how well you did at the IC. You saved your own ass, if you did badly.. you would have been the one to go!
Ashley, time for you to go.. you probably whine too much. Natalie hasn't been on the target and she looks hell lot more weaker than you. I guessed she played a better social game.
On the other Russell. He's no much better than Russell H. Both Russells are probably chauvinistic, irritating and dominating. I hate guys who think they're everything in this world. Pathetic.
On the rain - Raining really dampens mood. My mood was very much affected and saddened by the rain in this episode.
We're down to 13 players! Nearly halfway there..
Title: Re: S19 EP5: "Walking on Thin Ice"
Post by: realshowfan on October 16, 2009, 11:57:16 PM
Weekly Love-Neutral-Hate! :hearts: Luckily the rain happened or else Liz had a greater chance to go! And what's with all the Russell epsiode titles? o_O
LOVE: Dave (HNNL): You are vocal yet smart! I have a feeling he'll be a juror, to be specific, Juror 4-6. Just a guess! Erik (LLLL): Doing okay. Please don't give a deja vu (instead of a Joe scenario, a Brendan scenario!)! Jaison (NLLL): Might go down again if what I think will happen to him will happen next ep. Please don't go Osten on us! Kelly (NNNL): I think she will be a late juror or finalist! I'm liking her more! Liz (LLLN): Woo! Great job on that challenge!! You rocked it! And looks like mother nature wants you to stay as well!! Mick (LLLL): I am still liking him more! Though I wish we would start seeing more of him. Natalie (LNLL): I wonder why she voted for Ashley when she said she is like her sister. But her being the only person not targeted by Russell H in Foa Foa other than Mick is a very good thing!! Russell H. (LLLL): I don't know why it's hard for me to put him down. XD
NEUTRAL: Ashley (NHNN): Well between you and Liz, I prefer Liz stay. Laura (NNLL): I'm losing interest on the Galu tribe, seriously. Monica (NNNN): I am kinda losing interest in her though, but I like her personality and the way she used her hands at the RC to eat/drink. Shambo (LNNN): Went up a little but still in the middle.
HATE: Brett (NNNN): Your neutral record's gone. :P Like what I said last week, you still have no now confessionals. Well I think I heard you speak this ep. But seriously, he's getting more invisible to me. John (HHNN): Same as Brett! Russell S. (LLNH): Ugh, I am hating him now. He's becoming more dominant, he really thinks he's the leader of the tribe (well yeah that's true, but he's going overboard).
Title: Re: S19 EP5: "Walking on Thin Ice"
Post by: Jobby on October 17, 2009, 06:25:30 AM
Anyway, i don't know if it's the fact that Natalie is stronger than the other girls such that she does not have a target on her back. But one thing for sure is that it has not been shown yet. She's either sitting out of challenges or being a less important part of a challenge... hmm, what do all of you think?
Title: Re: S19 EP5: "Walking on Thin Ice"
Post by: realshowfan on October 17, 2009, 08:11:00 AM
Anyway, i don't know if it's the fact that Natalie is stronger than the other girls such that she does not have a target on her back. But one thing for sure is that it has not been shown yet. She's either sitting out of challenges or being a less important part of a challenge... hmm, what do all of you think?
Yeah those invisibles in challenges usually go far (Courtney, Natalie, and now this other Natalie and more...).
Title: Re: S19 EP5: "Walking on Thin Ice"
Post by: Jobby on October 17, 2009, 09:13:37 PM
Courtney and Natalie weren't really invisible.. they were portrayed as annoying IMO? Those who were really invisibles and made it to the top 10 were mostly guys most of the time and usually the first jury boot. :funny:
Title: Re: S19 EP5: "Walking on Thin Ice"
Post by: Ruth on October 22, 2009, 10:48:04 AM
I thought that the Reward Challenge was really GROSS. But as much as Ashley's weak and lost the challenge for Foa Foa, my heart still goes out to her. Yeah, she could have sucked it up and endure it like the rest but well... I don't know, ha.
And I felt really, really bad for Shambo when Russell S. sent her to Foa Foa. Like, hello? If he'd said that it was strategy, that he didn't want too many people looking for the HII, it's understandable. But his reason? "She has to pay for the chicken." Who does he think he is, some commander-in-camp? It kinda sucked that she played so hard for the challenge too. And she was clearly so upset about it, poor Shambo. =(
Liz rocked during the Immunity Challenge! I thought that she really gave it her all. It just sucked that the people on Foa Foa weren't too good at throwing, lol.