Reality Fan Forum - The Amazing Race Spoilers - Big Brother Live Feed Updates - Survivor Spoilers - Reality TV Spoilers - Big Brother Spoilers

Archive => RFF Archived Boards => American Idol => Topic started by: PapaBear on April 20, 2004, 11:55:19 AM

Title: So who do you like?
Post by: PapaBear on April 20, 2004, 11:55:19 AM

How do you feel about the contestants that are left?  Has your favorite already gone home?  How do you think this season compares to previous?

Personally, I am pulling for George, Diana and Latoya - in that order.  I think that Fantasia has a good voice, but just not my style (although she did very well last week).  I wish that I could pull for John but I think that Simon was right on the money when he said that he has no charisma.  I also think that he is pretty limited in what he can sing.  I wish that Aime (sp?) had made it further than she did.

As far as this season, I do not have any one contestant in particular that I am pulling for like I was with Clay last season.  I seem to like the singers who bring something a little different to the table, but this season the ones that fit that description just do not have strong enough voices.

What do y'all think?

Title: Re: So who do you like?
Post by: pittgirl on April 20, 2004, 03:16:51 PM

Papa
I do like your top 3.  I think George is great because he seems to have such a great personality and it shows when he sings.  I always smile when he is singing!!!!  I like Diana, she just seems really young to me but I think she will do well in the competition.  Not one of my favorites.  I love Jasmine.  I think she is adorable and I am rooting for her too.  They are my favorites, but who I think deserves to win is LaToya.  She has shined for every genre of music, even the country week which was out of her element!  I do not like John and I knew why when my grandparents told me how he was the best! HAHA!  He has a nice voice but bores the heck out of me.  And I do not like Fantasia.  Something about her rubs me the wrong way.  I dont like her attitude!
So......My top three are LaToya, Jasmine and George.  I still dont know what order though!!!!!

Title: Re: So who do you like?
Post by: PapaBear on April 20, 2004, 03:24:31 PM

I like Jasmine too.  I think she had a couple of off weeks, but I sincerely hope that she does well from this point on.  She would definately be my #4 choice.

Title: Re: So who do you like?
Post by: puddin on April 20, 2004, 07:34:07 PM

George Huff  ;D ;D He gives me GooseBumps....then Latoya..... :D
Jasmine was just on..she had her best night!! ;D

Title: Re: So who do you like?
Post by: CindiLou on April 20, 2004, 08:29:49 PM

Jennifer has improved the most so I like her. Fantasia, LaToya and Jasmine are also good.

My bottom three:

George
Diana
Jon

Title: Re: So who do you like?
Post by: puddin on April 20, 2004, 08:52:40 PM

Oh for God Sakes ..I hope that red head John is gone tomorrow night  :P He Sucks :P
Why don't you like George CindiLou? Just curious??

Title: Re: So who do you like?
Post by: pittgirl on April 21, 2004, 08:06:48 AM

I agree with your bottom 3 Cindilou.  I really like George but I think he had a really off night.  He may be in the bottom 3 but I dont think he will go tonight.  I really hope to see John go tonight.  He is just horrible.  I cannot beleive he has hung in there this long.

I do not like Fantasia though.  I know everyone likes her but she sounds like she is screaming when she sings.  Just not a fan.

Bottom 3
George
Jon ------- hope he goes tonight
Diana

Title: Re: So who do you like?
Post by: PapaBear on April 21, 2004, 08:47:05 AM

As much as the judges raved about her, I think that the type of performance that Fantasia gave last night is an example of what many people do not like about her.  I think she has a very "Aretha Franklin" kind of voice and is very strong and a great performer, but not a style that many people like to listen to these days.  I think that she is going to be surprised when she finds herself in the bottom 3 in the next few weeks.

Title: Re: So who do you like?
Post by: pittgirl on April 21, 2004, 10:43:14 AM

I agree papa!

I am glad that I am not the only one that feels that way about Fantasia.  I would like to see her on the 3 tonight.  Maybe we will be pleasantly surprised!  cant Wait!

Title: Re: So who do you like?
Post by: CindiLou on April 21, 2004, 12:32:25 PM

Puddin, I like George and his personality but I don't care for the way he sings. To me, the AI needs the "whole package" and he doesn't seem to have it. At least, not yet. Perhaps he will improve?

Title: Re: So who do you like?
Post by: puddin on April 21, 2004, 01:47:05 PM

PapaBear..I agree..Fantasia sounds soooooo much like Aretha Franklin. :D
You don't have to like George CindiLou.. ;) I understand..he has picked bad songs the last two weeks..but,there is something about his voice that gives me chills..I really hope that he doesn't leave tonight..I want John GONE :(..I have no idea why he's got this far?? Anyway ..I never was never hooked on AM before this time around..I think that its a tight competition..they are all excellent singers (Except John) I don't want any of them to go.. :D
Jasmine looked so relaxed last night..for the the first time ..I'm glad that she finally had a Great performance..as well as Diana ..but, it may have been to late for either of them?

My bottom 3
John
Diana
Jasmine..

Title: Re: So who do you like?
Post by: CindiLou on April 22, 2004, 12:44:51 AM

I am never watching this show again. Obviously the people who phone in their vote care nothing about talent!