Other Great Reality Shows > American Idol
TOP 8-Who's Out the Door?
puddin:
thanks for doing this Jeff :yaya:
--- Quote ---Elliott Yamin - Another great song, though the lighting effects were not very great. Are they trying to make Elliott look Blah? The song really wasn't bad, but again it didn't thrill me either
--- End quote ---
He didn't thrill me either but the song was a good choice for him.
RudyRules:
Jeff, thanks for the great reviews! :jumpy:
Chris, Paris and Kellie did the best, imo. They all really "got into" the songs and seemed the most relaxed of all. Katharine did good, but agree she needs to "pick up on her vocals" and get back to her previous performances. I wonder if the stress of it all is getting to her and hindering her from letting out all the stops! I still love her and hope like crazy that she makes it to the F4!
Same with Taylor. I am still a big fan and loved that he danced around tonite with his song!
Puddin, Chris gave me goose bumps too! :woohoo: He was the best performer tonite!
Vernie:
I think that Bucky will go tonight, but I really wish Kellie would go. She has offically become my "ROMBER" I cant stand her. Just my 2 cents.
Nuala:
Well tonight is the night. I am not sure who will go, but I thought Chris was terrible this week. This was his week to shine and he did not imo.
Kelly surprised me.
Bucky was good.
Taylor was good, but he is my favorite. He did not do well the two weeks before, so this was his come back.
Paris surprised me also.
I am thinking maybe Ace will go.
Jeffrey Scott:
Sure, the one week I don't mention my three, is the one week all thre are in the bottom three. I really called it this week. I knew that Elliott, Ace and Bucky would be bottom three and that Bucky would go home. Ace is still to well liked for him to go home, despite the fact that he did a bad song, and I hate his cokcyness.
Navigation
[0] Message Index
[#] Next page
[*] Previous page
Go to full version