Other Great Reality Shows > American Idol
8 men
tanbuns:
I agree with most of what you said Jeff, such as Kevin sounding very high schoolish. And I like Will, and think he has one of the better voices.
For me, Chris was the only one I thought gave an American Idol worthy effort. There was something about most of the others that I didn't like.
I love Taylor, but his dancing was laughable. I think he has been controlling himself up to this point, but last night it was almost as if he said, "the heck with it," and just did what he wants to do on stage. I just hope it doesn't lose him votes, because I want him in the F4.
I am starting to dislike Ace, and think he should not make F4. Unlike the judges, I hate his falsetto. Barry Gibb he is not!!! :lol:
And as for Elliott, I couldn't disagree with you more Jeff. If he doesn't make F4, it will be a disgrace!!! I have enjoyed him every week, and think he has the best voice of anyone in the competition!!! :tup:
Jeffrey Scott:
Tanbuns, I've always liked Elliott. I just don't think he gave a great performance for the song he sang last night. I've almost always given him high marks. But, with so many other "fan favorites" I think he may loose many votes. That is my biggest concern regarding Elliott. I guess we'll find out tonight.
Cole:
Yeah I think Kevin and hopefully Gedeon will be gone!!!
As much as I love him ... Ace needs to chill on the falcetta...LOL. It's impressive but not all the time.
Jeffrey Scott:
To be honest, I was tossed between Gedeon and Eliott, but I just have a gut feeling it will be Elliott.
Reality Junkee:
I didn't like Ace's performance the other night. He is constantly singing like he's in a boy band and I do not like it. I also think it's hoaky everytime he gives those puppy dog looking eyes at the end of the song....PUH-LEEZ :groan: I want to see a performance like he's on his own. I see him going far only because of his looks. I personally like Chris and Elliot...and Tyler.
My guess for who leaves tonight is Kevin & Will
Navigation
[0] Message Index
[#] Next page
[*] Previous page
Go to full version