Other Great Reality Shows > American Idol

AI Women Top 12

<< < (6/8) > >>

Reality Junkee:
Great write up/re-cap Jeffrey. :tup:    I found myself agreeing with you on everything.  I was a Kelly Pickler fan and was disappointed with how she did.  I know she can do better.  But it was the first night so I suppose we can give a little leeway for nerves.

Overall, I was disappointed with the girls.  I only liked Mandesa, Paris, Katherine and Lisa (not necessarily in that order).  But last year at the beginning, Vonzel wasn't that impressive (IMO), but as time went on, her confidence grew and she just kept getting better and better.  So we'll have to see what the others can do as time goes on. ;D

Jeffrey Scott:
Glad to see we agree on something. ;)
Let's see if we agree next week now.

Reality Junkee:
Gee, I thought we agreed on a few other things.  ;)   I can't wait til tonight to see who goes.

I need to rewatch the guys last night.  Wasn't feeling so hot so wasn't focusing on it too much.  I'll let you know what I think of them before I read your write up.  Don't want it to bias me. ;D

Jeffrey Scott:
OH yea, I forgot it was on tonight. ;)

Cole:
 :ele:

Navigation

[0] Message Index

[#] Next page

[*] Previous page