The Amazing Race > RFF's Amazing Race: Design Challenge
The Amazing Race: Design Challenge VIII - Final Round Design Show on Page 50!
MikeDodgers:
I also do want to reveal that I did have an alternate finale leg planned that would've sent teams to Atlantic City in my home state of New Jersey, which would've entailed a Monopoly-themed memory task. But it didn't get much farther than the task planning phase because I wasn't sure if the location would fly in this round.
betheactress:
What is TARLA? Los Angeles? I never watched TAR Los Angeles or TAR19, I only see a few seasons. So immediately dismissing my tasks right away for not viewing every season seems like a real cheap shot, nor did it seem constructive. Wasn't the whole debate over you offering comments was the need to not be for lack of better word, mean, but instead focus on giving constructive comments, which hardly any of us received. I think if your comments have to be condensed and filtered down this much that you can't offer anybody constructive criticism as to what you would do to make our submissions better, maybe it's not worth it to receive feedback from you.
--- Quote from: georgiapeach on July 14, 2020, 04:06:25 PM ---
What works or doesn't, WHY it worked, how it could have been better is crucial.
WHAT I do want to see and have asked ALL our judges past/present to try is to be a bit sensitive in the process.
Saying this was a lousy leg and here is why this worked or didn't is great!!
Say this was crap and you are a lousy designer/failure/ is not.
--- End quote ---
MikeDodgers:
--- Quote from: betheactress on July 16, 2020, 01:21:34 PM ---What is TARLA? Los Angeles? I never watched TAR Los Angeles or TAR19, I only see a few seasons. So immediately dismissing my tasks right away for not viewing every season seems like a real cheap shot, nor did it seem constructive. Wasn't the whole debate over you offering comments was the need to not be for lack of better word, mean, but instead focus on giving constructive comments, which hardly any of us received. I think if your comments have to be condensed down this much maybe it's not worth it to receive feedback from you.
--- Quote from: georgiapeach on July 14, 2020, 04:06:25 PM ---
What works or doesn't, WHY it worked, how it could have been better is crucial.
WHAT I do want to see and have asked ALL our judges past/present to try is to be a bit sensitive in the process.
Saying this was a lousy leg and here is why this worked or didn't is great!!
Say this was crap and you are a lousy designer/failure/ is not.
--- End quote ---
--- End quote ---
Amazing Race Latin America....
Bookworm:
Alen, thank you for your comments! I'm glad that you liked the Detour!
I interpreted flow slightly differently; it made more sense for the overall theme of my Leg to include the memory challenge last- I would rather that be the final task of the Race than the sculpture. The drama of the memory task, especially a well-thought one, is one of the reasons we all love them so much. Plus, since the islands are pretty small, it wouldn't make too much of a difference for teams to circle back. But the idea of keeping the RB closer to the Finish Line, in conjunction with gamer's antipathy of the location I chose, does make me reconsider the Finish Line location. So, thank you.
NELs:
I have been practicing making the fantasy game graphics on my free time. Thank you all for the feedback.
Navigation
[0] Message Index
[#] Next page
[*] Previous page
Go to full version