Survivor > Survivor: General Discussion

Survivor Legends Season vs. All-Winners Season

(1/5) > >>

Ryan:
Hey guys, so I thought this topic would be fun to speculate around. I was thinking last week about how Danni kept saying she'd only return in an All-Winners season, but often people whisper about a "Legends" concept.

What do you think about these two parallel season concepts? Does Legends = All Winners? Separate seasons? What defines a legend? How is someone a legend in Survivor if they've never won the game, e.g. is it just determined by screen time, charm, intense gameplay, but people who have fallen short 2-3 times?

Certainly I believe Legends has to include some if not mostly a cast of winners, but I do think there are some exceptions (Cirie stands out in my mind as one of the early tricky ladies of the game.) And in an All-Winners season, I think it's obvious to us viewers that they all get paid in some form just for showing up, but perhaps their "placement winnings" could each go straight to a charity they care about.

I'd also love to see, if either cast was 20 people, who you'd all select!

stekay:
As much as everyone hates him Russell Hantz is a legend. Would he play again?

Cirie IMO is the best player never to win the game. She was robbed in EI but especially in Micronesia.

Ryan:
Agreed, I think she and Russell both (and no doubt Russ would play again, maybe with a better social game) qualify as legends.

In an all-winners, I'd really like to see Danni, Kim S, Tony, Natalie A, and Chris D play again and see how they do with champs around them.

David:
I just love Parvati's moves over and over again. But really, is there not enough for watchers of these players? I mean, Parvati played Cook Islands. Great. Then she was invited back to Micronesia <333333 she then went again on HvV <3333333333333. Don't you think she has enough? This is just one of the cases I want to state: Parvati is a legend in Survivor, but isn't there a time where you want to stop watching the same people again and again?

If there is another season with Returnees, I would LOVE to see no castaways from same seasons, I mean, I would just like to see one player from twenty different seasons. Or maybe 10 pairs from 10 different seasons in a BvW way <3

gamerfan09:
Cirie Fields please! <3

Navigation

[0] Message Index

[#] Next page