The Amazing Race > The Amazing Race Discussion
Returning Racers Part 4: All-Star Wishlist
gamerfan09:
Here's my honest opinion of the cast from TAR19 onwards for their chances of returning. (Not a Wishlist and is a possibility if TAR30 is returnees. No winners.)
Legend:
-People who got a montage at the end of their journey and/or a CBS YouTube Feature on them - Marked With Red
-Casual Faves - Marked With Blue
-Fan Favorites - Marked With Teal
-People with a Chance to Return (Unfinished Business, Nature of Boot) - Marked With Pink
-People with no Chance to Return - Marked With Grey
TAR19:
Amani & Marcus
Bill & Cathi
Andy & Tommy
Liz & Marie (Running out of money in a foreign land and getting a tear-filled elimination caused by aforementioned running out of money)
Jeremy & Sandy
Laurence & Zac
Justin & Jennifer
Kaylani & Lisa
Ethan & Jenna
Ron & Bill
TAR20:
Joey "Fitness" & Danny
Nary & Jamie (Eliminated after watching elephants on an NEL and being screwed the next leg :cmaslol :cmaslol :cmaslol <3)
Vanessa & Ralph (Received montage but are now broken up.)
Art & JJ
Bopper & Mark (Mark is technically a threepeater AKA No.)
Kerri & Stacy
Elliot & Andrew
Dave & Cherie
Misa & Maiya (Their mistake would put them at a chance for an early-boot season though!)
TAR21:
Trey & Lexi
Jaymes & James
James & Abba
Abbie & Ryan
Rob & Kelley
Gary & Will
Caitlin & Brittany
Amy & Daniel (They were pretty liked around for being second boots I guess *shrugs* and victims of bad taxi could make them early-boot season returnees)
Rob & Sheila
TAR22:
Max & Katie
Chuck & Wynona
Mona & Beth
Pam & Winnie (Pam working for ABC now kinda seals the deal because ABC is affliated with TAR production =( )
Idries & Jamil
Matt & Daniel
TAR23:
Nicky & Kim
Tim & Danny
Tim & Marie
Nicole & Travis (Pretty much locks until Indonesia happened lmao.)
Ally & Ashley
Brandon & Adam
Chester & Ephraim (Their major flight ****-up is enough to put them on early boots but pls god no)
Rowan & Shane (Could be considered for an early boot season TBH)
Hoskote & Naina (Same.)
TAR25:
Tim & Te Jay
Misti & Jim
Kym & Alli
Shelley & Nici
Adam & Bethany
Brooke & Robbie (Considering these two are wrestlers/entertainers, an Exes John-Vito & Jill style return wouldn't be surprising)
Keith & Whitney
Michael & Scott (The Ankle Incident duh yes for early boot season)
Dennis & Isabelle
Lisa & Michelle (They, however, could be considered for an early boot season too!)
TAR26:
Hayley & Blair
Mike & Rochelle
Matt & Ashley
Bergen & Kurt (Watch their boot ep to get what I mean + the two are kinda friends now IRL :cmaslol)
Aly & Steve
Jeff & Jackie (BB lmao)
Harley & Jonathan (He didn't really bring the ratings and I don't really remember people loving them too much so yeah)
Libby & CJ (#SelfieGate is definitely a memorable elimination but these two seem more suited for an early boot season.)
Jeff & Lyda (Ditto with U-Turned on the first leg)
TAR27: (Surprisingly no one got a montage (and I am going through people who got their own gallery on CBS so this is pretty 50/50)
Justin & Diana (*deep sighs*)
Logan & Chris ("We're not quite done yet" in their final confessional with a random OTTP kiss scene lmao they are at least getting asked)
Tiffany & Krista
Denise & James-Earl
Tanner & Josh
Cindy & Rick
Jazmine & Danielle
Ernest & Jin (Locks for first boots)
Alex & Adam
Kelly & Shevonne (These two would be definitely locks for a returnee season of early boots considering they were the first team to get their own "memorable moments" gallery since Jet & Cord on 24 lolpwnt but unfortunately not on a regular returnee season!)
TAR28:
Erin & Joslyn
Tyler & Korey (*deep sighs*)
Brodie & Kurt
Sheri & Cole
Burnie & Ashley
Scott & Blair (Bag-gate tbh)
Brittany & Jessica
Darius & Cameron
Zach & Rachel
Marty & Hagan (again, early boot season)
What do y'all think?
Platrium:
Jeff & Jackie joining BB "disqualifies" them from returning? ??? Everything else seems accurate. :)
Meanwhile, how about another color to mark the early boot candidates?
RaceUntilWeDie:
@gamerfan09:
TAR 19:
Weren't Amani & Marcus asked for TAR 24? That makes me sad. TAR 24 could have had an amazing cast (even better than what Returning Racers Part 4 might be, after I made some lists for Part 4, the cast seems only OK).
Where on Earth were Bill & Cathi?!? I'm kind of glad they didn't return so we didn't have to see them get eliminated on, like, Leg 2.
The fact that Andy & Tommy didn't return makes me question if they'll invite a dominant team like Justin & Diana. They were probably just (rightfully) overshadowed by better teams. I didn't like them anyway.
Liz & Marie had a memorable elimination but are too weak/forgettable (like TAR 19 :lol: :( ) to return imo.
TAR 20:
Joey "Fitness" & Danny have to be one of the most underrated M/M teams of all time. If they made it a little farther they would've returned. But memorable elimination for sure!
Nary & Jamie omg the way you summarize their downfall :lol: Sometimes I think: how would they have done on a different season? TAR 20 was super competitive (none of the Final 3 ever fell below 6th) and so dramatic I loved it. Definitely overshadowed like above team.
Honestly, if they didn't hesitate to bring THREE Threepeaters, they may not hesitate with Bopper & Mark, TAR/CBS were in love with them.
TAR 21:
I adored Trey & Lexi and their relationship, actually loved each other and never fought. However, they were forgettable unfortunately.
Why didn't Jaymes & James return?!? Another HUGE missed opportunity for TAR 24.
James & Abba deserved to return for an Unfinished Business type of season. All Stars... nah.
TAR 22:
Max & Katie are yet another missed opportunity. Enough said.
Chuck & Wynona were uncomfortable to watch by the end of their Race. Instead of an inspiring Sheri edit, it was just... uncomfortable.
TAR 23:
Nicky & Kim showed potential but never reached that potential. Unfortunately, they're forgettable.
Tim & Danny are actually one of my favorite M/M teams. So down-to-earth/normal. Also forgettable :/
Tim & Marie I can see why she turned it down but they should've returned!
I don't see TAR asking any of these teams back simply because they're from pre-TAR 24. Marie was told by a casting director that if she said no to TAR 24, she wouldn't be asked back again (maybe an empty threat? :lol: )
TAR 25:
Tim & Te Jay were sadly INV during their Race... just like Zach & Rachel of 28! Therefore, forgettable.
Misti & Jim were annoying. Jim's obsession with winning and only winning really turned me off.
Kym & Alli need to return. And TAR needs more F/F teams like this. Please.
Shelley & Nici probably won't return and will be overlooked like all 7th placers.
Adam & Bethany were boring but I definitely see them returning to please casuals.
Brooke & Robbie should return JV/J style! But the question is... are they mature enough??
TAR 26:
Hayley & Blair seem mature enough to return together but I just don't see it happening with Hayley's new relationship and their "conflicting schedules"
Mike & Rochelle were boring/forgettable, I loved the "meeting her son" story though.
Matt & Ashley were fun to watch, but they don't seem worthy ENOUGH to return. Maybe as alternates.
Bergen & Kurt are they actually friends? omg :lol: But I don't think they should return.
Jeff & Jackie seem well-liked by CBS or TAR or whatever. I can see them being that one RANDOM team in an All Stars cast.
TAR 27:
Justin & Diana are definitely returning :lol:
I can't see Logan & Chris returning. I think they were too disliked by casuals and I wouldn't want to see too much negativity in an All Stars season (I know, TAR 24 turned out like that :res: )
Tiffany & Krista are definitely top contenders for returning. However, I hope they train harder next time and don't end up as first boots :(
Denise & James Earl are like Chuck & Wynona. RFF/Fan favorites but they're... eh. If Sheri & Cole can't return, they can.
Tanner & Josh 100% deserve to return after that disgusting "Speed Bump."
TAR 28:
Erin & Joslyn were entertaining but too weak :/
Tyler & Korey are definitely top contenders. For some reason, I feel like they'll decline?
Brodie & Kurt can be Tanner & Josh's alternates :lol: Both really deserve to come back though.
Sheri & Cole are welcome to return but I feel like their story was kinda completed at the end? Like it would suck to see them come back to get eliminated in Leg 1.
Burnie & Ashley were kind of boring, not gonna lie. It was definitely their edit, because they seem like entertaining people! I think their elimination makes them worthy to return.
Scott & Blair I feel are too weak as racers to return. Like Gary & Mallory came in 2nd three times in a row in their first season.
Platrium:
--- Quote from: RaceUntilWeDie on May 14, 2016, 08:08:19 AM ---Misti & Jim need to return. And TAR needs more F/F teams like this. Please.
--- End quote ---
Perhaps Kym & Alli is being discussed here?
RaceUntilWeDie:
--- Quote from: Platrium on May 14, 2016, 08:19:49 AM ---
--- Quote from: RaceUntilWeDie on May 14, 2016, 08:08:19 AM ---Misti & Jim need to return. And TAR needs more F/F teams like this. Please.
--- End quote ---
Perhaps Kym & Alli is being discussed here?
--- End quote ---
Nope, I'm talking about Misti & Jim. :lol:
I was copying and pasting sry.
Navigation
[0] Message Index
[#] Next page
[*] Previous page
Go to full version