The Amazing Race > The Amazing Race Discussion

Returning Racers Part 4: All-Star Wishlist

<< < (29/56) > >>

Theo:
the lack of Shelley & Nici on returning racers list has made me sad :(

NMC:
OK, so I'm gonna do 2 Lists, a fun, who I want to see return list, and a more realistic, who-producers-will-more-than-likely-bring-back, list.

The Realistic List:
Kym & Alli (S25)
Misti & Jim (S25)
Adam & Bethany (S25)
Brooke & Robbie (S25)

Jeff & Jackie (S26)
Hayley & Blair (S26)

Justin & Diana (S27 - If they don't win)
Kelsey & Joey (S27 - If they don't win)
Tanner & Josh (S27)


Who I WANT to See Return List:
Mark & Bopper (S24)

Kym & Alli (S25)
Misti & Jim (S25)

Mike & Rochelle (S26)
Hayley & Blair (S26)

Ernest & Jin (S27)
Cindy & Rick (S27)
Tiffany & Krista (S27)

..Insert S28 Teams..

Andre:
Mine would be:
S25
-Misti & Jim
-Adam & Bethany
-Kym & Alli
S26
-Jelani & Jenny
-Hayley & Blair
-Matt & Ashley
S27
-Justin & Diana(if they don't win)
-Kelsey & Joey(if they don't win)
-Tiffany & Krista
-Tanner & Josh

Zack.:
How this cast stacks up:

- Kelly & Shevonne: the only way I see it is if they film TAR: Heroes vs Villains right after finishing 28 and none of the female teams from 28 are villainous AND they don't just bring Natalie and Nadiya back.

- Alex & Adam: they're fun and all but no sorry :/

- Ernest & Jin: actually pretty high lol. This show loves slotting in a token minority team and they have the benefit of being likable AND telegenic AND vaguely famous AND with an easily exploitable tragic backstory AND were unexpectedly eliminated early.

- Jazmine & Danielle: yeah, no.

- Cindy & Rick: were present for all of five minutes so nope.

- Tanner & Josh: while I feel the show might have an obligation to bring them back after that broken Speed Bump that disguised how cheap they were, they benefit from being a good M/M team that made it far without being dominant and actually had screen time. I'm hesitant to say yes for reasons that will become obvious but...yes.

- Denise & James Earl: we'll see what the future holds regarding casting but for now yes.

- Tiffany & Krista: wasted their time unpacking back home (also yes)

- Chris & Logan: yes HOWEVER as alternatives to Blair & Hayley or Brooke & Robbie (basically I would want two trainwreck "couples") cast and they're my least favorite of the three :(

- whatshisface & Diana: If they do another returning player season watch them be That One Team whose omissions glaring and yet, not really a big deal (c.f. BJ & Tyler not camera hogging, Toni & Dallas not boringly worsening UB, most of the speculated cast of That One Season dodging a bullet). If they do go back I suspect they'll be Romber of a new decade and get hosed in a "LEVEL FIIIIIIVE" style footrace with...probably Any & Maya or Brooke & Claire.

- Kelsey & Joey: while I would absolutely LOVE to see them being those hats with their names back...who are they? (Probably winning 27 lol)

In tiers:

Tiffany & Krista

Tanner & Josh
Justin & Diana

Denise & James Earl
Ernest & Jun
Chris & Logan

gamerfan09:
If they're bringing back "superfan" archetypes they should cast Shelley & Nici instead for the next one (:

Navigation

[0] Message Index

[#] Next page

[*] Previous page