Other Great Reality Shows > American Idol
Confusing American Idol (Top 10 Girls)
TexasLady:
I haven't found a favorite yet a lot of distractions here last week and I need to review them all again. One thing I have noticed is how much alike some of the girls are in voice and presentation. (Verging on boring almost.) They are good singers, have stage presence but lacking that one thing that screams, I'm the best!
I will listen to MK for you Joab, to see how she performs.
Overall I am really enjoying the judge changes this year. I wasn't sure if they would be an improvement or a disaster. They are all great, and work together which is a nice change from last year. H. C. Jr is a super addition to the judging. He brings a certain maturity to the process but he's not mean and cutting.
Jobby:
I think it's a guy's year to lose this year. They are all so good and strong?
MK isn't the best, but she's got something going on there. A story to tell, a song to sing. I'm pretty sure she won't win, but she will be successful in her own area. She gives me the Pink / Christina Perri vibes.
WinTar:
--- Quote from: gamerfan09 on February 19, 2014, 07:20:25 AM ---^
Still better than last season tho
--- End quote ---
Last season was great, to be honest! :)
Marrialle though :groan:
Polaroid:
I don't know why you would have a top 30, only to cut it to 20 without giving them a chance...? I haven't watched most of the performances and I don't plan to, but I think Majesty Rose is fantastic. I love her style and her voice draws me in.
Jobby:
Precisely. Why do a Top 30, then cut it down to Top 20 without letting the audience know what was the rationale behind their decision? I'm VERY WILLING to watch another round of ten perform on one more night and WON'T be complaining. And I'm sure many won't complain about the voting either (having to vote for another round of 10).
American Idol just killed a great season opening in 1 week. Kudos to them. Honestly, they need to have another component of using Youtube video likes and dislikes or views as a measure and gauge of the popularity of their contestants.
Navigation
[0] Message Index
[#] Next page
[*] Previous page
Go to full version