Other Great Reality Shows > American Idol

Top 20 Semifinalists!

<< < (5/9) > >>

Jobby:
Top 5 girls I want to go through are obviously the five girls I gave the A and B+ grade above. But I believe America will vote in Kree, Amber, Angela, Aubrey and Zoanette.

Due to wildcard, I believe Candice will receive the spot and if Adriana is lucky (and the judges really want to push for a girl to win), she will receive the second/third wild card spot depending if there's a F12/F13.

Aussie:
ZOANETTE HASSSSSSSSSSSSS TO GO THROUGH

Jobby:
Elijah Liu: I really think he has a nice tone and he will be a great performing artise! Randy, you are wrong! If he didn't start off the nice, he could have had a really good night considering so many performances SUCKED. I honestly thought those vocals deserved an A.. but the arrangement of the song, towards the end... the drums were TOO LOUD!
Grade: A-

Devin Velez: Nice vocals, the first part of the song I did not like because it was obviously not meant to be sang in English. The second part of the song was obviously mad talent and singing. Deserves to get through to the next round.
Grade: A-

Lazaro Arbos: What a great tone and voice! THIS BOY CAN SING! #FAITHINLAZARORESTORED that was such a good improvement from last week, which was HORRIBLE.
Grade: A-

Curtis Finch Jr.: Too much gospel stance, with the wave-board like movements, little pinky. And the Youtube comments are WAYYYYY too funny. He just comes off as a really arrogant person and I think America is right. American Idol needs to be a person with a great personality and good representative. He sings like madddddd but his personality is way too cocky.
Grade: Vocals A+, Attitude: C+ therefore Overall: B+

Cortez Shaw: Good vocals, but a bad song choice. The background singers were distracting and the music was wayyyyyyy distracting. I think it's sad because it's an entertaining and memorable performance, but he blew it on the arrangements of the song.
Grade: B+

Burnell Taylor: Re-used a song from audition, minus a grade. Dress sense, minus a grade. Vocals, add a grade. It was honestly boring, though.
Grade: B+

Paul Jolley: Karaoke-ish, I can hear vocals like that anyway in a pub and continue on with my beer and food. But at least towards the end he managed to belt out all the notes he needed to.
Grade: B

Nick Boddington: I really think his vocals are mediocre and I can hear anyone with that voice anywhere on Youtube now. He went flat and off key on one note. At some point it felt as though he was breathless.
Grade: B-

Charlie Askew: Weird song choice, not a nice refreshing choice for me. Hard to watch his performance as it was just not great to see people squint their eyes and belt out notes. I thought that was a disappointing performance.
Grade: C+

Vincent Powell: Started the song on a flat note, off key and this song was sexy until he sang it. I couldn't watch his performance, it was worst than JDA's.
Grade: C

Jobby:
I want to see Cortez, Elijah, Devin and Lazaro go through. Can the last available spot go to the girls instead? I think I can do with a 9 girls 4 guys F13. :lol3:

TexasLady:
We were behind last night because of Survivor and fast forwarded through the last of Vincent Powell's song. His "look" with the glasses reminds me of a James Bond villian.  He should get some advice on styling.   :)

Navigation

[0] Message Index

[#] Next page

[*] Previous page