Other Great Reality Shows > American Idol

Top 4 Discussion

(1/6) > >>

Jobby:
Haley and James are IN IT to win. I loved both of Haley's performances and I also liked it that James is playing it "safe" by keeping to his own genre of music after a disastrous last week.

Lauren's first song gave me a Carrie Underwood moment and impression. That should keep her safe, HOPEFULLY.

Scotty, was gloriously boring.

I'm going to make a huge bet, that Scotty will be going home and both Scotty and Lauren will be in the bottom 2. Scotty's honestly sincere and everything, good vocals.. but the song choices... meh and BORING for this week! :(

bee1233:
I felt bad for Haley.  They were tough on her for the first song.  I think she did great for both of them.

Scotty sang a relative song for this week.  He has such a huge following I doubt he will be in the bottom 2.

Whoever ends up in the final two will make it a great show.  Each of the final 4 are so different. :hearts:

Jobby:
DialIdol predicted Scotty and Lauren to be safe and James and Haley to be in the Bottom 2. :duno:

Alfwin:

--- Quote from: Joab on May 12, 2011, 03:18:17 AM ---DialIdol predicted Scotty and Lauren to be safe and James and Haley to be in the Bottom 2. :duno:

--- End quote ---
Hopefully its not true...

Jobby:
Okay. The person who really will be safe will be Lauren.

Scotty... i think TOO BIG fan base. I will take back my comment that he will be going home.

That leaves James and Hayley. Which the obvious choice would be Hayley going home...

But i think as the singers get lesser and lesser, we have votes moving to different contestants. I actually feel that Scotty and James appeal to different masses and that their votes will always sort of remain the same. As for Hayley and Lauren, they're more current and will attract more votes.

In this case, i think Hayley and Lauren got most of Jacob's votes when he was voted off last week.

I think a guy will be leaving tomorrow. Have a feeling it's James, but at the same time, you have Hayley who has been struggling for weeks? :lol: I predicted her to be in F5... not F4..! :lol3:

Navigation

[0] Message Index

[#] Next page