Other Great Reality Shows > American Idol
Top 9 Discussion
Jobby:
Casey... i didn't like this performance this week. The inclusion of the instrument was great and unique. But i found the performance a tad too boring and lazy... i wished he could have stuck to crazy vocals with crazy personality.. that's the Casey we know.. right?
His vocals didn't seem to be as good as the previous weeks as well.. maybe it's just me.. but he couldn't hit some of the notes.
Jobby:
The moment i heard Lauren say she's singing "Natural Woman" i was like.. OMG, she's going to either have her moment... or totally ruin her chances. Because this song is such a great and very distinct song that has been sang throughout all these years on Idol.. she has to be really good to standout!
Okay, i've never commented about fashion.. but Lauren's outfit didn't suit her today!
I don't think Lauren did a good job with her performance. She should have gone up way much higher with her range.. i felt like she didn't hit the "Lauren moment" that she should have done so with such a powerful song like this.
But it was a decent performance.. she didn't blow me away.. but i'll take it for now.
Jobby:
As Randy put it.. she took a big song and did well.. didn't blow me away.. but good enough for Top 8!
Jobby:
When i heard James's song choice.. I thought he's really going to do very well with the song. It's like breaking himself away from a "Adam Lambert 2.0" Impression!
The song was very soulful... but i was wrong. I don't think James sang it well. It was so boring and i inevitably compared him to Adam again and I remembered how Adam slayed each and every song including the slow emotional songs..
The part that highlights James performance today was again when he went high pitch mode... and he can't just rely on that every week.
BAD PERFORMANCE FOR ME, IMO.
Jobby:
Okay.. Scotty's finally doing something DIFFERENT THIS WEEK! :hearts:
I thought from a female audience POV, they probably all went mad during + after the performance. :lol3:
TOO SEXY. :lol:
But from a male audience POV, good vocals, fun to watch, high entertainment value. Memorable performance, one of the best performance of the night. And that, will keep him even longer in the competition. :lol:
The thing that Scotty has... is a very good distinctive voice that no one else has. When he sings, we all know it's HIS SONG and HIS OWN PERFORMANCE.
Scotty's got some hot stuff going on there huh?!
Navigation
[0] Message Index
[#] Next page
[*] Previous page
Go to full version