Other Great Reality Shows > American Idol
Top 9 Discussion
Jobby:
I guess we all thought she will be safe. And it seems like i'm not alone thinking that this season rocks. I know Pia's eliminated and it sucks, but it's not AI's fault but America's fault. Some people just don't get it.
The show is still awesome with good singers in the Top 9. I remembered for all past 9 seasons, we still have staggering performers barely making through week after week and even staying all the way till the Final 6 or Final 5. Right now, all of them seemed to deserve their spot, even Paul... he sort of deserved to be there because he did perform decently last night.
And TL, how can you forget the ultimate train wreck, Tantiana?!??! :meow:
Ruth:
I love the current panel of judges, I think they bring a new dynamic to the show. There seems to be a whole new level of energy this season. Steven and JLo are nice but they give constructive comments on improvements when they're needed. Randy definitely can't pull off a Simon, but I find myself agreeing with his comments pretty often.
If I had one criticism, it might be that the judges seem too easily impressed. I'm not sure if Simon would have used the Save on Casey. Or rather, I think their decision to save Casey was not a far-sighted one.
But other than that, I love them. They've definitely put the right people on the show. I still remember how they did not put Chris Medina through; they clearly know that it's a talent show and not a sympathy show.
Enough about the judges though. Pia definitely deserved to go further but she wouldn't win anyway. So... Yeah, looking forward to see who will claim the title! Right now I feel that Lauren has a shot. She didn't come out outstanding at first but she was still good and slowly, we see her blossom. That's what AI is about! Wow, I'd be amazed if she won. But I shan't say too much about it. Lol.
Love this season of AI!
Jobby:
My next 3 elimination predictions are Paul and Jacob Casey.
I think my final 5 pick will be Lauren, Haley, Scotty, James and Stefano.
TexasLady:
ACK!!! Tatiana! :ascared I used bleach to get her out of my memory! :lol3:
AmazingRace:
:lol3: :lol3: I remember her! :lol:
Navigation
[0] Message Index
[#] Next page
[*] Previous page
Go to full version