Other Great Reality Shows > American Idol
Top 9 Discussion
Jobby:
Okay.. i wasn't a big Pia fan (more of Haley and Lauren) but i do agree she should have been in the Final 5 at least. Now at least we know the remaining 2 girls are going far, most probably.
I think Haley is amazing. She's still here despite being in the Bottom 2 for the first 2 weeks.
TexasLady:
I do think the wrong person went home, we can't have just the boys it will be too boring and I don't want to see Lauren or Hayley leave!
The weaker singers are Paul, Jacob, Stefano, Casey. I hate to say Casey but he hasn't stepped up and performed like he did in the auditions or else it is my perception of him because of his illness. The over reaction when he was eliminated then saved may have projected weakness to those who vote. I say this even though I like Casey.
Prophet:
Six boys and two girls left? :lol3: This is worse than last year. Not only has the show deteriorated over the past few years the voters get crazier every year.
TexasLady:
I think part of the problem is the judging and I love the new judges, they've brought expertise, encouragement and love to the kids but Simon would weed out the weak to save the stronger contestants. J Lo and Steven really don't slam their performances although J Lo did tell Pia that she needed to work on her performance. Randy tries but he's not Simon and he can't pull it off. :lol:
Prophet:
--- Quote from: TexasLady on April 08, 2011, 12:18:17 PM ---I think part of the problem is the judging and I love the new judges, they've brought expertise, encouragement and love to the kids but Simon would weed out the weak to save the stronger contestants. J Lo and Steven really don't slam their performances although J Lo did tell Pia that she needed to work on her performance. Randy tries but he's not Simon and he can't pull it off. :lol:
--- End quote ---
I wholeheartedly agree, TL! This is why I was weary about the show when Simon left.
Navigation
[0] Message Index
[#] Next page
[*] Previous page
Go to full version