Other Great Reality Shows > American Idol
Top 11 Discussion
Ruth:
--- Quote from: Joab on March 25, 2011, 11:22:27 PM ---I honestly think, that ultimately this is American Idol. The judges should save the SAVE for someone whom everyone will/can respect many years down the road. I think Carrie Underwood, Kelly Clarkson are great examples of Idol winners.
I know Casey is a HUGE talent. But he's quirky and his personality is WEIRD and it just turns me off. I have to admit that i'm biased here as i was EXTREMELY disappointed to see the SAVE use on someone whom i see had ZERO chances of winning this competition. Just like last season, when the SAVE was used on Big Mike, i was like....... WHAT?
I thought that the judges should be saving it for people like Lauren and Pia or even Stefano whom i define them as people who have the huge qualities to make a good idol. Lauren may not be the hottest girl out there but she's REAL and she's sincere to win this competition as well.
Now i just hope that Paul just get the hell out of this competition because i had no idea and didn't approve him to be in the Top 13 after all. Paul and someone... someone random needs to go home. As of now, i'm just glad Naima and Haley are not in the Bottom 3 this week. But... but.... it's dangerous. Sigh.
--- End quote ---
I'm 100% with you! I don't deny that Casey is a HUGE talent, but how many people would actually buy his record at the end? People like Carrie Underwood and Kelly Clarkson cater to everyone. I feel that Casey can only cater to a selected group of people. It's just like Adam Lambert with his mad, mad talent ending up not winning the competition because he's not "mainstream" enough.
The only redeeming factor for me is that Casey deserves the Save more than Big Mike. Other than that... Part of me actually wishes that they do away with the Save from now on because in my highly personal opinion, they haven't been using it that accurately if I may say so. Matt Giraud was alright. Big Mike had no chance of winning. Casey... Well, reasons stated above.
Sigh, please don't let my favourites go home because of the Save!!!
Jobby:
As of now, i just want Lauren, Stefano and Haley to stay. Pia, James, Scotty deserve to go further... i don't care about the rest.
ugot2bekidinmeny:
Casey Abrams's Unexpected Moment
Navigation
[0] Message Index
[*] Previous page
Go to full version