Other Great Reality Shows > American Idol

Top 12 Discussion

(1/6) > >>

Jobby:
I just heard Paul McDonald.. i thought it was ridiculously weird and i HATED IT as usual.

OMG. It was so horrendously off pitch and weird. I'M GOING WITH RANDY. GO RANDY!

He's so bad i think our local idol contestants can beat him.. what's America DOING? :groan: :groan: :groan:

Jobby:
Thia... i agree with Randy.. too safe.

And she couldn't hit that highest note going into the Chorus. Colours of the wind is a great song.. but it's too boring.. to sing on Idol.

But Thia owns Paul and i hope she stays around!

Jobby:
James... started off quite pitchy but in the end he picked himself up okay. The high notes were good and the song was OKAY. But as i've said before, if he don't lose his "Adam Lambert" style.. he'll never "outperform" him. I always compared him to Adam Lambert and although he sing good.. Adam blew us away everytime. However, James was just OKAY every week..

Hopefully he'll start to impress me.. maybe he's already doing it for all of you. But we already have an Adam Lambert and we don't need another one!

Jobby:
Haley with the lipstick = More exciting/interesting than us wanting to hear her sing = No Good.

This week Haley disappointed me. And this is after she was in the Bottom 2 last week. I am very worried for her right now.

I really hope she stays.. i think she has got the talent just that she doesn't get what she wanted to do yet.

Her song was a mess and i didn't know why she picked that! :'( :'( :'(

Jobby:
Stefano was amazing! Wow... my favourite male idol contestant in a long long time!! He made the song as if it was his own and slayyyyyyed it. Randy was right for most of the time for his comments tonight! :tup:

Navigation

[0] Message Index

[#] Next page