The Amazing Race > The Amazing Race Discussion
RFF TAR 17 pick-em game
Caelestor:
--- Quote ---5 Points – Does any team fail to complete a task?
Yes
No
OK I want input. We don't see Ron & Tony complete the general task or perform the RB. BUt that doesn't mean they failed to complete the task. The question isn't if they were shown doing task, but were they shown not being able to complete a task? I am leaning No. But I am willing to hear opinion.
--- End quote ---
According to the CBS recap, Ron completed it, so I say all teams completed their tasks.
Coutzy:
--- Quote ---5 Points – Does any team fail to complete a task?
Yes
No
OK I want input. We don't see Ron & Tony complete the general task or perform the RB. BUt that doesn't mean they failed to complete the task. The question isn't if they were shown doing task, but were they shown not being able to complete a task? I am leaning No. But I am willing to hear opinion.
--- End quote ---
What about the boat task? While they appear to be swimming across, the larger of the two (Ron? Tony?) Can be clearly heard saying "We tried"
Given that the only context of the statement is that they are swimming (In what (to me) appears to be the direction of the next route marker) it appears to me that they failed to complete the boat task as per instructions, which would mean that a team did fail to complete a task.
For the record, I picked no for my answer.
mswood:
Peach and caelestor
We can't use info outside of the episodes so I can't use the clips as proof. Yes Ron is on the horse, but we don't see him but we don't see them complete either task.
jerseydude:
I believe that we should either
a) give all the people points
or
b) give no points at all.
From the episode, we cannot prove that either they did or did not finish, so personally I think that we should give no points at all since they weren't proven to either finish or not finishing all tasks.
Snooky:
Nvm delete please.
Navigation
[0] Message Index
[#] Next page
[*] Previous page
Go to full version