Archive > American Idol

Diana or Fantasia ?

(1/3) > >>

puddin:
I had to vote for Fantasia tonight .. I still have chills from her singing tonight..she was right on  :;>)

drumstyx47:
heck ya, puddin!!!!
fantasia knocked my socks off!!!

puddin:
Yay drumstyx I can't wait for tonight..

pittgirl:
OMG.....I am sooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooo upset to hear that you guys voted for Fantasia.

When Diana sang the song written especially for the AI, I got goosebumps.  If Fantasia releases that song the way she sang it last night, I dont think I will ever watch another episode of AI.  (thats probobly a lie)  I just dont understand what everyone sees in Fantasia...I think she sounds like a Duck or Macy Grey...either way I never was a fan of Macy Grey.  I dont think Fantasia can sing a slow song and have the same impact on the audience the way that Diana does.  WHen she sings a fast song she just yells into the mic and bouces around like a chicken with her head cut off!!

Sorry for venting but I just dont like her so much!
Hopefully I am not alone in my opinion!!!

What does everyone else think?

puddin:
Don't be mad Pittgirl..Diana has a beautiful voice..and I won't be upset if she wins..I just think that Fantasia sings effortlessly, a natural.. thats just my opinion  :-*

Navigation

[0] Message Index

[#] Next page