Other Great Reality Shows > American Idol

Top 9 Performance Discussion

(1/5) > >>

Jobby:
The three girls were great!

I liked Katie's performance more than Crystal's this week! And i'm just so glad that Katie's proving herself to be an extremely good singer from the very beginning! Siobhan.. thank God she didn't shout again this week! Her song was slow.. abit boring.. but it showcased her vocals so well!

As for the guys.. Lee and Casey were great!! But then, i didn't love Casey's performance as much as Simon termed it as the best performance of the night. I don't know why but Aaron's performance was pretty much horrible. I think unlike Katie.. Aaron's going downhill and that's not a good sign.

I don't know if anyone of you agrees with me, but i realized that Andrew is not good with fast and upbeat tempo songs. I think he brings nothing special to the table when he does that. I think he's better when he changed up a song to a slow, butlight and contemporary tune. Like how he performed his best performance yet for Top 10. His performance this week was reall mediocre and unimpressive.

Michael, is again.. just singing and belting out a song. The tone and singing was really good.. but he's just doing another Lil' Rounds. Doomed for 7th place or worst? Okay, the song was really good all the way to the end from the middle.. but the starting was very boring. But Simon sums it well, i didn't like it as well as the other judges.

Tim Urban, is just crap.

Best performance(s) of the night:
Katie
Crystal
Casey
Lee

NEUTRAL:
Siobhan Magnus
Michael Lynch

Worst perofmance(s) of the night:
Tim Urban
Aaron Kelly
Andrew Garcia

I'm gonna go with my gut feeling and say Tim, Andrew and Aaron OR Michael in the bottom three. Yes, guys bottom three night!

Going home?? I believe Tim will stay another week? If he's staying, either Michael or Andrew is doomed.

Ruth:
I feel that this is the best night since the top 12 kicked off. Everyone showed improvement in one way or another. But now that Tim stepped it up tonight, it makes things all a little tougher. The three girls are great, Lee and Casey are great, that leaves us with Tim (who wasn't THAT bad tonight), Aaron, Mike, Andrew... I really hope it's a guy bottom-three this time! But I don't know, these 4 guys just seem really popular. Will we have a surprise tomorrow night? Geez.

TexasLady:
I'm like you Ruth, everyone improved and did better last night, I don't know who will go home. Katie continues to do better and better. Andrew did better although Kara wants to love him but said he could do more and Simon gave him the KOD with his wedding singer comment that he was not even the lead singer. His lighting was much better and he chose a better song but he still needs to step it up. (May be too late.) 

Aaron didn't get much encouragement, I thought he seemed nervous.

Lee and the bagpipe! I couldn't help but laugh when the guy started grooving with the song and holding his bagpipes.  :lol3:

Guessing at the bottom three: Aaron, Tim and Andrew. I think it will be a tie between Aaron or Andrew, either one leaving wouldn't surprise me.

TexasLady:
Joab, I do agree with you about Andrew. I think he's good, better probably than we've seen lately. I just wish he could find his niche. It's funny you mention Michael and Lil Rounds. I was thinking last night that most likely he will go the route of Melinda, he'll have some success but he will never be the winner of AI. That said, I like him. However, I just hated the first part of his song, if he hadn't changed it up, he would be going home tonight for certain.

I  was praying that Siobhan wouldn't scream... there was a moment when I thought she would go there but thankfully she didn't. Casey sang much better, I'm not sure he was the best performer of the night but for once he really let loose and sang with intensity and emotion, didn't play it safe.

Coutzy:
I really hope Andrew sticks around and gets a chance to show the mainstream media what he's capable of, like he's already shown his online fans.

Navigation

[0] Message Index

[#] Next page