Other Great Reality Shows > American Idol

Ellen DeGeneres to Join American Idol Judging Panel replacing Paula Abdul

<< < (2/3) > >>

ugot2bekidinmeny:
I think Idol has taken a turn for the worse with a  non musically - educated personality  as Ellen.. i love her but i don't think the contestants will  get the correct reviews that they need to further themselves  to win.

 again i love Ellen but i don't agree with the judging choice. there had to be soooo many other talented performers they could have put in there on a weekly basis..

Mandoli:
I think Ellen wasn't the best choice as a judge. I know, kind of vanilla for a statement.

ImANewUser:
On one hand, we get the viewpoint of someone who's not traditionally regarded as a "music expert" and maybe they can get comments on what music the people would truly want to hear (or most likely, buy). On the other, we get the viewpoint of someone who's not traditionally regarded as a "music expert" and maybe the singing advice will not help. We'll just wait & see, I suppose. :duno:

Jobby:
Ellen brings in the perspective of the fan. She has no singing/producing/song writing backround. She is like having us be the judge. Like she said she has been watching the show forever.

How many times have you sat in your couch yelling at the TV “Are you serious!!! Can’t you hear! He/She was great/terrible, on point/flat, What was she/he thinking!!"

I think Ellen will give that perspective and I think I’ll reserve judgement till I see what she has to offer. :tup:

Snooky:
I'm still discouraged that Paula left, but I have hope in this new judge.

Navigation

[0] Message Index

[#] Next page

[*] Previous page