Other Great Reality Shows > American Idol

American Idol Final 5 Performance Discussion

(1/5) > >>

Snooky:
Since no one else is starting the topic, why not?
I liked tonight!
Matt Giraud did pretty good!

TexasLady:
Thanks for starting the thread Snooky!  :tup:

I thought everyone did well tonight. I loved that Allison just sang her song and liked that they finally did something new with her hair and it was nice to see. Danny had his best night yet.

Jill_:
I guess it's just my taste (or nontaste) for some music, but I really hope that they will never have rat pack music as a theme again!

I've never fast forwarded my TiVo before while watching a perfomance on Idol, but I did several times tonight.

Jill

ImANewUser:
I honestly loved the performances this time around. Although I was saddened that they only sang one song.

Performance Ranking:
1. Danny
2. Matt
3. Kris
4. Allison
5. Adam

Overall Ranking:
1. Kris
2. Allison
3. Matt
4. Adam
5. Danny

Ruth:
Yeah, whatever happened to the start of singing two songs? Was quite disappointed that we don't get to see more from them at this stage but well, it was a good night overall. I'm not a fan of the Rat Pack, but all five of them did really well and it's so hard to predict who's leaving this week.

Kris Allen - I didn't think he was spectacular tonight, so I was pretty surprised when Randy praised him to the skies. So I must say that I concur with Simon's opinions. It was good, but not great. A little safe and boring for me.

Allison Iraheta - I agree about the lack of confidence, but I loved her performance tonight. I thought it was heartfelt and it was great seeing a less edgy, more vulnerable side of her. I see her in the bottom two but will she really be in trouble? Please vote for her!

Matt Giraud - Thought it was a cool performance, splendid vocals but I didn't think it was stellar. He could be in trouble tonight as well, JMO.

Danny Gokey - Previous weeks, I thought he's been totally losing his spark but this week, he totally blew. On top of the brilliant vocals, it was a really intense performance, his best yet. My hope of him being eliminated in a surprise elimination is gone, once again I guess we'll see him in the finale.

Adam Lambert - Yeah, awesome start to the performance. It's just wonderful seeing what he'll do each week and he's by far one of the most original and daring contestants on the show. I have to say it again that I really love his vocal range but I wish he'd not yell every week, lol.

My ranking:
1. Adam Lambert
2. Danny Gokey
3. Allison Iraheta
4. Matt Giraud
5. Kris Allen

I hope Kris leaves but my gut tells me either Matt or Allison, so I think that the latter two will be our bottom two this week. Ahh all five of them did great tonight, it's gonna be hard to see any one of them go. =(

Sidenote, but I realised that out of the five remaining, the top three of the second group are still intact, and four of them are from group two. Lol.

Navigation

[0] Message Index

[#] Next page