Other Great Reality Shows > American Idol
American Idol 8 Wild Card
Aeboi2484:
So I really just wanted to say I really don't like how they are doing the Wild Card spot this year. Apparently The Judges are allowed to bring back ANYONE that has audition this year. If they made the Top 36 or not. So like if they wanted to they could even bring back the Osmen guy or anyone. and then They get to Pick who will make it in to the top 12 Not votes. Just wondering what you guys thought about this.
TexasLady:
--- Quote from: Aeboi2484 on March 04, 2009, 04:40:27 AM ---So I really just wanted to say I really don't like how they are doing the Wild Card spot this year. Apparently The Judges are allowed to bring back ANYONE that has audition this year. If they made the Top 36 or not. So like if they wanted to they could even bring back the Osmen guy or anyone. and then They get to Pick who will make it in to the top 12 Not votes. Just wondering what you guys thought about this.
--- End quote ---
Welcome to RFF Aeboi484! :welcome:
I'm not sure how they decide on the top 36, some of them were more memorable like Scott, Adam, Danny, TATIANA.. (We DO remember her.) I was surprised that Danny Osmund didn't make it through.
I remember that Clay Aiken was brought back for the wild card round and he made it to 2nd place. Who would you like to see have another chance?
BTW, there is a rumor making the rounds of the blogs and fan sites that Anoop Desai, Ricky Braddy and Matt Girard are back in town so they can have another chance on Thursday, wild card round. I really liked Anoop so I hope he gets a chance to join the top 12.
Source: http://www.joesplaceblog.com/2009/03/03/guess-whos-in-los-angeles-wildcard-spoiler/
Jobby:
--- Quote from: Aeboi2484 on March 04, 2009, 04:40:27 AM ---So I really just wanted to say I really don't like how they are doing the Wild Card spot this year. Apparently The Judges are allowed to bring back ANYONE that has audition this year. If they made the Top 36 or not. So like if they wanted to they could even bring back the Osmen guy or anyone. and then They get to Pick who will make it in to the top 12 Not votes. Just wondering what you guys thought about this.
--- End quote ---
I am sure, it's not just only anyone, but only the Top 36 who did not make the top 12 will be back. And wildcards are good, look at dear JENNIFER HUDSON. I bet the wildcard was back to make sure they don't slip through talent like her. She's probably the most successful idol now, with an Oscar, grammy and many other prominent awards to her name.
Anyway, i'm sure the judges get to pick 3, and they will pick the 3 most deserving as well. So why not? :D
By the way.. WELCOME!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! :hearts:
pledge:
I like the idea of the judges picking the Wild Card. Although the judges can make mistakes too, I think they are a better "judge" of true talent and who deserves a shot at the top 12. jmo :lol:
eragon:
Wild Card Contestants
1. Von Smith
2. Jasmine Murray
3. Ricky Braddy
4. Megan Corkrey
5. Tatiana Del Toro
6. Matt Giraud
7. Jesse...
8. Anoop Desai
I'm hope Anoop, Megan & Tatiana will make it through!
Navigation
[0] Message Index
[#] Next page
Go to full version