Other Great Reality Shows > American Idol
American Idol 8: Second group of 12 Perform! Share your thoughts!
Jobby:
The only problem that i have with a voting system like this is that.. girls will always tend to lose out. Because female fans will vote crazily for guys and guys fans.. are just... less hyperactive. :duno:
I wouldn't be surprise if the top 9 consist of 6 male and 3 female. Maybe they should have advanced top 2 male and top 2 female from each group, form the top 12 and get another 4 back from wildcard, forming the top 16.
Then they will be splitted into two groups of 8 and perform on 2 nights, (like last year) and one from each night will then be eliminated.. we'll do this for 3 weeks until we have a top 10.. then start eliminating them one by one.
But that's just too trouble.
I hope it goes like this -
Idol reveals top 24. (no restriction of 12 guys and 12 girls)
3 groups of 8 perform, top guy and girl goes through.. making up the final 6. (3 rounds)
Then they have a wildcard round, and they choose anyone they feel deserves a second shot and the judges will pick 3 to move on, while America vote for the highest contestant to move on. (Or either, each judge make their individual pick)
We don't always have to stick to a top 12...
Jobby:
With that said, Megan will be a shoo in into the top 12 now. :funny: I would be surprise if she doesn't make it.
TexasLady:
--- Quote from: Joab on February 27, 2009, 01:10:40 AM ---With that said, Megan will be a shoo in into the top 12 now. :funny: I would be surprise if she doesn't make it.
--- End quote ---
Same here! :tup:
I'm with Pledge, so far so good. Kris was a surprise but I'm OK with him being in the top 12.
Jobby:
Kris was good, he just needs to pick the right song and gain some confidence..
Ruth:
I'm actually very pleased with the results. Adam and Allison were no surprises, and I'm actually glad that Kris made it. I kinda thought that he wouldn't have a chance, but I'd so much rather have him that Matt Giraud in the Top 12. For now at least, since I wasn't impressed with Matt last night. And also, Megan will probably have a better shot in the Wild Card round than Kris, so it's better that Kris gets in now, and Megan through the Wild Card. I'm pretty confident that if she picks the right song, she'd definitely be in the top 12. And with that, THANK GOD Nick Mitchell did not make it.
Who I hope to see in the Wild Card:
1. Megan Corkrey
2. Jasmine Murray
3. Matt Giraud
4. Jesse Langseth
Navigation
[0] Message Index
[#] Next page
[*] Previous page
Go to full version