Other Great Reality Shows > American Idol
American Idol Season 8
tory:
oh for sure they r compeating to b the best..i still don't like the way they put ppl into thease groups?/ if only 3 out of12 go trew based on our votes than the judges / producers have way more power than even the best singers, what if they had put those 3 u mention in the same group?? it would not have been fare i don't think it was a good idea to put all those same stly girl in one group except alex's what if she had been in the sceond group with , the 16 yr old who went trew, they both sang great but what if one did not make the cut, and allsoi realy don't think the oil riging guy should b in a spot he was not good at all i love him and his story but...out of the last 2 groups i can name 4 guys who should b in that seat enstead of him, jmo :duno: :duno: :knuckles: :knuckles:
Jobby:
I know tory, but if you're good you'll move on. As with Adam, Allison, Alexis and Danny.
Kris and Michael moving on.. i didn't really like it as i thought there should have been more deserving singers like Ricky and Megan moving on from both groups.. but you can't deny that as much as this is a singing contest (greatest one ever too!).. this is a popularity contest as well. If not, Melinda would have won Season 6 hands down.
So i guess this voting is actually good, as the most popular (guy and girl) moves on.. and not only that.. the next popular guy/girl has to be able to sing well and make an impression.. for them to be able to move the audience and make them vote for them. And to make up for this shortcoming that good singers are missed, they have a wildcard too! So all in all.. if you sing good.. you'll make it to the top 12 without a doubt. This is even better than the Season 4 to Season 7 voting style.. IMO. :tup:
Because we're all actually voting for just a few memorable singers to move on.. for Season 4 to Season 7.. the people in the top 12 were really unmemorable due to the voting method. Nobody remembered what song they sang to deserve/put them in the top 12. But till now, i still can remember people from past seasons with this similar voting method.. (Amy Adams, Jon Peter Lewis, Josh Gracin and a whole load of others.. which is amazing now that anyone can still remember their names!)
I'm actually with this voting style. That makes VFTW.com very pissed as it makes it so much difficult to put their pick through each week. :funny:
TexasLady:
--- Quote ---I'm actually with this voting style. That makes VFTW.com very pissed as it makes it so much difficult to put their pick through each week.
--- End quote ---
If they are against it, then I'm for it!!! :lol:
Two hour show tonight! Whoohoo!!! :hearts:
Jobby:
--- Quote from: TexasLady on March 03, 2009, 09:25:47 AM ---
--- Quote ---I'm actually with this voting style. That makes VFTW.com very pissed as it makes it so much difficult to put their pick through each week.
--- End quote ---
If they are against it, then I'm for it!!! :lol:
Two hour show tonight! Whoohoo!!! :hearts:
--- End quote ---
They know the fact that they can't beat America to get the top guy/girl.. so they just had to hell get their pick to have the third highest vote, which is IMPOSSIBLE. :neener:
tory:
you r right if it gets vftw to come to a hault it is defff worth it... they have screwed this contste up for to many years, way over it.. i realy like the way they do the voteing on dwts. it gives the judges some power and we only get to vote a certin amount of time from one phone. i love AI but i realy think they trive or get something off of how many votes r generated each week. that is y they don't change it..my guy chris richardson got to 5th on seasom 6 and i voted one ng for 4 hrs stright.. huuuu and he still got voted off with phill stacy 2 weeks later rember idol gives bk omg, jmo a lot of hyp and it took away from the contestants those weeks and i voted 8 hrs 2 weeks in a row just to have chris voted off .. sry i ranted..
Navigation
[0] Message Index
[#] Next page
[*] Previous page
Go to full version