Other Great Reality Shows > American Idol
American Idol Season 7
sunshine26:
i too wish AI wouldnt be so long, stop showing all the auditions with the ones that didnt make it to hollywood, i think AI should start its season with the auditions of those who made it to hollywood, than show MORE of hollywood, than show MORE of ALL the top 24...than start the top 24 singing for our votes... than when it gets to the top 12...have the result show for 30 mintues, STOP the hour crap..and PLEASE STOP bringing special guest singers......focus more on the top 24. top 12. top 10. top 5. etc etc....and PLEASE PLEASE STOP!!!!!!!!! having musical show week! [broadway] that is so awful....this is NOT a show to find the next big broadway star! plus it is the most boring week IMO!..and Simon says things like that sounded to broadway, to musical,....than STOP IT! ok rant over [for now :funny:]
vanillalatte:
I'm probably one of the few that actually enjoys Broadway week, but I'm a huge fan of musicals. ALW is my favorite modern composer, so I enjoyed it. One thing that we really get out of Broadway week is to see who can really SING. I think that's why Jason did so poorly and David Cook did so well. Broadway week left Jason completely exposed, he didn't have his little vibe to fall back on, but rather he just had to sing. Jason doesn't have the chops for that. David C, on the other hand, finally got to show us just what kind of voice he has...no cool arrangements, no schtik, just singing...and it was glorious!
sunshine26:
--- Quote from: vanillalatte on May 05, 2008, 12:50:05 PM ---I'm probably one of the few that actually enjoys Broadway week, but I'm a huge fan of musicals. ALW is my favorite modern composer, so I enjoyed it. One thing that we really get out of Broadway week is to see who can really SING. I think that's why Jason did so poorly and David Cook did so well. Broadway week left Jason completely exposed, he didn't have his little vibe to fall back on, but rather he just had to sing. Jason doesn't have the chops for that. David C, on the other hand, finally got to show us just what kind of voice he has...no cool arrangements, no schtik, just singing...and it was glorious!
--- End quote ---
hi ya! vanillalatte :waves: yep! cook did a GREAT job on broadway week, [he studyed musical T. [broadway] at a very young age] i have a friend, that knew cook was going to be on AI..she has seen cook alot, she has even been to LA..and seen him on the stage there, i have a cousin that lives in LA she is a big time stock broker, and i prob could go to one of the AI shows, BUT i just got back from 2 weeks in new mexico, my hubby would freak out if i went on another hoilday!
my cousin could get tickets for the show in a heartbeat! i too LOVE broadway i go to plays all the time i love it!...and i love ALW..the guy is just WOW!..i love everything ALW has done....the only reason i said to not have one, is b/cuz of simon..with all that crap he gives about the idols sounding broadway...BUT if you are going to have a BW week than some are going to sound BW! simon needs to get over it! i loved that David Cook, did the song just the way it is, [the org] it really showed he is in control of his voice, and you are right on! jason WOW! awful..when i first saw the top 24 and saw jason, i would have never thought he was like a folk singer..
jason as david A sound the same everyweek to me! jason lives not far from me, about a hour drive!..BUT there is no way i would vote for jason , i never have and never will, which brings me to my point, as to why do some vote for idols based on looks, puppy love. and being from the voters hometown, i just cant do that, i vote on who i think is deserving, and Cook is![plus on the Texas message boards for AI, Texas LOVES COOK :jumpy:] i cant believe anyone could say cook is not the best singer on this show! again JMO. [i love, love chatting with ya! :hugs:]
rosesrred:
--- Quote from: sunshine26 on May 05, 2008, 01:36:14 PM ---
--- Quote from: vanillalatte on May 05, 2008, 12:50:05 PM ---I'm probably one of the few that actually enjoys Broadway week, but I'm a huge fan of musicals. ALW is my favorite modern composer, so I enjoyed it. One thing that we really get out of Broadway week is to see who can really SING. I think that's why Jason did so poorly and David Cook did so well. Broadway week left Jason completely exposed, he didn't have his little vibe to fall back on, but rather he just had to sing. Jason doesn't have the chops for that. David C, on the other hand, finally got to show us just what kind of voice he has...no cool arrangements, no schtik, just singing...and it was glorious!
--- End quote ---
hi ya! vanillalatte :waves: yep! cook did a GREAT job on broadway week, [he studyed musical T. [broadway] at a very young age] i have a friend, that knew cook was going to be on AI..she has seen cook alot, she has even been to LA..and seen him on the stage there, i have a cousin that lives in LA she is a big time stock broker, and i prob could go to one of the AI shows, BUT i just got back from 2 weeks in new mexico, my hubby would freak out if i went on another hoilday!
my cousin could get tickets for the show in a heartbeat! i too LOVE broadway i go to plays all the time i love it!...and i love ALW..the guy is just WOW!..i love everything ALW has done....the only reason i said to not have one, is b/cuz of simon..with all that crap he gives about the idols sounding broadway...BUT if you are going to have a BW week than some are going to sound BW! simon needs to get over it! i loved that David Cook, did the song just the way it is, [the org] it really showed he is in control of his voice, and you are right on! jason WOW! awful..when i first saw the top 24 and saw jason, i would have never thought he was like a folk singer..
jason as david A sound the same everyweek to me! jason lives not far from me, about a hour drive!..BUT there is no way i would vote for jason , i never have and never will, which brings me to my point, as to why do some vote for idols based on looks, puppy love. and being from the voters hometown, i just cant do that, i vote on who i think is deserving, and Cook is![plus on the Texas message boards for AI, Texas LOVES COOK :jumpy:] i cant believe anyone could say cook is not the best singer on this show! again JMO. [i love, love chatting with ya! :hugs:]
--- End quote ---
Ok Sunshine I'm a hop, skip and a jump away from the AI show I would love to go in your place :yess: :jumpy: :funny: Just a thought! :funny:
vanillalatte:
Here's a thought....
Bring back BIG BAND WEEK!!! I don't understand why they got rid of that one! I'd go for getting rid of Broadway week, if it meant the return of Big Band. How could anyone forget the week that Kelli Clarkson finally emerged as a true threat to Tamyra Gray and Justin Guarinin? It was just that week that began her surge to the forefront and ultimate win! And Big Band is another style that doesn't allow the vocalist to hide in a niche...they have to show true vocal skill!
Navigation
[0] Message Index
[#] Next page
[*] Previous page
Go to full version