They are trying to figure out what they can ask for they would actually give them.
Cards, a game, blah blah. Jessica said "quarter"
Eric: Does anyone have the feeling that Zach would try to do magic tricks with a deck of cards.
Dick: I don't know but if I hear another meow song im gonna kick him in the nuts

Eric talking about how they played his favorite song, Another One Bites the Dust on his eviction day and he did not find it funny.