Other Great Reality Shows > American Idol

How they did tonight--my rankings!

(1/3) > >>

mattus:
1 jordin
2 melinda
3 blake
4 Lakisha
5 Phil
6 Chris
7 Sanjaya...by far :groan:

TexasLady:

--- Quote from: mattus on April 17, 2007, 08:02:00 PM ---1 jordin
2 melinda
3 blake
4 Lakisha
5 Phil
6 Chris
7 Sanjaya...by far :groan:

--- End quote ---

I like your list. Phil was in his comfort zone, this is the type of music he should sing. He could go higher than LaKisha.

I particularly like #7! Heh heh heh! Sanfizzle got the royal, almighty, super-duper KOD tonight. *  :yess: :waves: :rat?: :crazy :killme: :boot: 

* (Of course he IS the entertainer at the Motel 6 lounge so he could survive yet again!)  :groan:

I personally loved LaKisha's song, and Melinda was great but I have to agree, Jordan was Da BOMB as Randy says.

Chris got a KOD as well, but nothing like the one Sanjaya received.

BballKates:
If any of you watch Idol regularly and have watched all the seasons than you know that Lakisha committed a mortal sin with her song choice. You never sing a song that is a former Idols. Not to mention butcher it! She sealed her fate.

tanbuns:
I have to agree about LaKisha. You never sing an Idolist's song, and especially not sing it as well. She sounded horrible on the chorus!!!

I have liked Jordin for several weeks now, but did not like her as well tonight.

Melinda is the one that was "da bomb"!!! And she looked great for a change, too. The hair extensions made her "finally" look younger, and the bared top showed us that she does indeed have a neck!!!

Phil did OK, but his real style of music, and the one he will probably choose after this is contempory gosple.

Chris picked a good song, but did not do it well.

Blake's song did not sound very Country to me, but was a Tim McGraw song. I didn't like it too much either.

Sanjaya looked and sang BAD!!! He was back to early competiton form tonight!!! But he will probably escape the bottom again!!!  :groan:

Bottom 3 will be Chris, Phil, and LaKisha.

Going home ......... Phil.

TexasLady:
ARGHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHH I forgot about singing an idol song, that really is true. I really do not want to watch "him" another week.  (:;)

Navigation

[0] Message Index

[#] Next page