Other Great Reality Shows > American Idol

Top 11's Bottom 3...

<< < (3/9) > >>

bellick:
Sanjaya deserves to go. His singing was bad. But having said that, his performance was slightly better than in the previous 3 rounds. So looks like it'll be another week, only one week I hope. Anyway, he's still young and needs time for his voice to develop and for him to mature. Only time will tell but I'm sure he'll be successful in the near future.

tanbuns:

--- Quote ---BTW, I'm glad Simon told him to wear his glasses.  We got used to his specs and they, along w/ his bushy hairdoo, are his trademarks!
--- End quote ---


I'm glad you brought that up Ruday, because I meant to comment on it.

I do agree that Chris S. should go back to wearing his glasses. He is never gonna win a beauty contest anyway, but the glasses and hair make him cute in a geeky sort of way.

But I hate it when Simon make comments on the contestant's physical appearance like that, and he does it a lot. If he feels like he needs to say something, say it in private for heaven's sake. I thought he was suppose to be judging the contestants on their "singing" ability!!!  B:)

CeeeJay:
someone needs to remind paula its a singing contest....her copout is telling someone how nice they look!! of course...they get stylists and makeup and stuff backstage!!

RudyRules:
Well, I agree that Simon is sometimes too nervy especially with negative critiques.  However, the contestants' appearance is very important and Simon's advice usually helps.  For instance, look at Lakisha!  She took Simon seriously instead of being offended and has greatly improved her appearance!  She looked stunning in the flowing white, floor length dress last week.  When one knows they're wearing clothes that compliment them, it helps their self-esteem, thus their performance. (in most cases) 

But, the outfit also must be comfortable! 

 

RudyRules:

--- Quote from: CeeeJay on March 16, 2007, 06:28:03 AM ---someone needs to remind paula its a singing contest....her copout is telling someone how nice they look!! of course...they get stylists and makeup and stuff backstage!!

--- End quote ---
I think Paula's purpose for complimenting how nice they look is just because she senses it would give them a little boost after knowing themselves they didn't perform well. So why not give them a positive?  She still critiques on their performance as well.

Sure, it's a singing contest, but the attire is also a factor...

Navigation

[0] Message Index

[#] Next page

[*] Previous page