Other Great Reality Shows > American Idol

march 13 2007 - two hours!

<< < (2/2)

tanbuns:
I take back what I said about the guys getting ready to start shining. They were more like a dim lightbulb.

Sanjaya should go but probably won't. It's not that he sings bad! But his voice is just so soft, and he doesn't have much stage presence.

Brandon hasn't had but maybe one good week since Hollywood. I had higher hopes for him.

My youngest daughter loves Chris Richardson. But I totally agree with Simon about his vocals. He is actually one of the weaker singers vocally.

The whole time Chris Sligh was singing, I was telling Mrs. Tanbuns that his arangement sucked. He sang it well though.

I love Blake, but didn't like him as much tonight for some reason.

I enjoyed Phil, and was glad he made up for last week. He really has only had the one bad week, and I feel is one of the top vocally!!!

As for the ladies, Melinda was awesome AGAIN!!!

Stephanie looked beautiful, and did a good job. Randy said she messed up her words, but I didn't notice.

Gina picked a good song, and sang it well. I am glad so see her doing so good.

LaKisha did a good job. But does anyone else think that all her songs sound the same?

Jordin sang OK, but I didn't like it as much as the judges did!!!

I am really pulling for Haley, but she forgot her words and was pitchy on some of the others.

I gave Phil, Blake, and Stephanie all one vote each. I never could get through for Melinda.

Bottom three are Sanjaya, Haley, and Brandon.

Going home ......... Haley!!!

CeeeJay:
So Many people forgot their words last night...Sanjaya...as soon as i heard what song he was singing i almost spat up my tea!! whats up with the Sligh hair he's sporting this week??

AMERICAN SMARTEN UP!!

Chris R and Blake dissapointed me

Gina's song...hahah I can't believe what Paula said that its a happy go lucky or what ever she said...HELLO ISNT IT ABOUT BEING LIKE A BASTARD CHILD OR SOMETHING??

Vernie:
I adore Blake, Chris S, and Phil. I will pull for them the whole way.  Sanjaya should not be there, and neither should Miss Haley, I know I will make someone mad for saying this, but one of them should go.   :yess:

BballKates:

--- Quote from: Vernie on March 14, 2007, 03:57:48 PM ---I adore Blake, Chris S, and Phil. I will pull for them the whole way.  Sanjaya should not be there, and neither should Miss Haley, I know I will make someone mad for saying this, but one of them should go.   :yess:

--- End quote ---

I don't think you will make anyone mad here, if people think either of them are good singers they need to get their ears checked.

CeeeJay:
simon's rooting for ms haley as she is the only good looking girl left in the competition!

Navigation

[0] Message Index

[*] Previous page