Other Great Reality Shows > American Idol
Who went home tonight???
RudyRules:
--- Quote from: TexasLady on March 01, 2007, 09:41:41 PM ---Tonight A. J. Talbaldo, Nicholas Pedro, Alaina Alexandra and Leslie Hunt. Sanjaya thought for sure he was a goner but the teenyboppers must have saved him yet again.
I was so hoping Barba would leave us. :groan:
--- End quote ---
Thanks TL. Like puddin and other diehard Survivor fans, I can't watch or tape AI on Thurs, b/c I tape Survivor commercial free! (have taped ALL seasons.)
Lucky I can watch AI on Tu/W!
Anyway, I cannot believe Barba is still there. :groan: Dial Idol predictions had her in 3rd place BEFORE the show! I nearly fainted this afternoon when I saw the chart. Same with Sanjay...it showed him in 2nd. How can these two be ranked so high when neither of them did good at all and Simon flat let them both know it!! Is this show rigged or something? ??? I'm beginning to think so. :(
http://www.dialidol.com/asp/predictions/Predictions.asp
BballKates:
--- Quote from: RudyRules on March 01, 2007, 11:56:34 PM ---
--- Quote from: TexasLady on March 01, 2007, 09:41:41 PM ---Tonight A. J. Talbaldo, Nicholas Pedro, Alaina Alexandra and Leslie Hunt. Sanjaya thought for sure he was a goner but the teenyboppers must have saved him yet again.
I was so hoping Barba would leave us. :groan:
--- End quote ---
Thanks TL. Like puddin and other diehard Survivor fans, I can't watch or tape AI on Thurs, b/c I tape Survivor commercial free! (have taped ALL seasons.)
Lucky I can watch AI on Tu/W!
Anyway, I cannot believe Barba is still there. :groan: Dial Idol predictions had her in 3rd place BEFORE the show! I nearly fainted this afternoon when I saw the chart. Same with Sanjay...it showed him in 2nd. How can these two be ranked so high when neither of them did good at all and Simon flat let them both know it!! Is this show rigged or something? ??? I'm beginning to think so. :(
http://www.dialidol.com/asp/predictions/Predictions.asp
--- End quote ---
Is this your first season of Idol, this is nothing new. Taylor Hicks won last year, anything is possible.
RudyRules:
Season 5 was my first season and I LOVE Taylor! He was my fav from the day he auditioned and I was elated he won. I know many people didn't like him or that he won, but I will forever be a fan of his. Each to his/her own taste.
But, had Kat, Kellie Pickler, Mandisa or Chris won, ok with me!! They are all great in their own ways. I just think Season 5 had more truly great talent than this season.
Right now, my favs are Melinda, Katisha, Sundance, Chris S, & Blake...in that order.
So, BBKates, are you saying the show is set up by the producers for certain ones to win?
TexasLady:
Ruday, I think last year was probably the best season with talented people. I loved Taylor and Kat, my favorite was Kellie but they just were not up to par with the others here in Austin. They probably were exhausted.
I was surprised that Simon hit Phil Stacy with the karaoke comment on Tuesday. I like his singing.
We taped Survivor to watch AI. It wasn't a big problem since Kellie was going to sing so the choice was easy. :tup:
BballKates:
--- Quote from: RudyRules on March 02, 2007, 02:02:08 AM ---Season 5 was my first season and I LOVE Taylor! He was my fav from the day he auditioned and I was elated he won. I know many people didn't like him or that he won, but I will forever be a fan of his. Each to his/her own taste.
But, had Kat, Kellie Pickler, Mandisa or Chris won, ok with me!! They are all great in their own ways. I just think Season 5 had more truly great talent than this season.
Right now, my favs are Melinda, Katisha, Sundance, Chris S, & Blake...in that order.
So, BBKates, are you saying the show is set up by the producers for certain ones to win?
--- End quote ---
Do they pick the winner? No
But do the tweak the results so certain people don't leave? YES!
At the end of the closing credits there is a disclaimer that says the producers have the rights to change the results.
I also know that last season the week Paris left that Katharine was suppose to leave.
Navigation
[0] Message Index
[#] Next page
[*] Previous page
Go to full version