Other Great Reality Shows > American Idol
Final 24 - my thoughts
RudyRules:
Really, Tanny? Jory is from Canada? I heard about the others you mentioned, but not her. I had really HIGH hopes of her making it to the Finals...one of my favorite gals.
Well, that is sad, b/c she has fantastic talent. After she left the Auditioning room, Simon said, "why can't they all be like that...that was easy!" I bet all the judges were very sorry that it didn't work out for her.
I must watch my tape from Wednesday's show, and will comment more this weekend I hope!
Ruday ;D
CeeeJay:
Jory is from Canada...but she's living / working or school with visa in the states...therefore she's aloud to compete...there have been many in the past from foreign countries.
didn't Jory get cut the first group of girls first day in hollywood??
tanbuns:
Ruday ....... you may be thinking of Jordin Sparks from Arizona. I agree she is one of the females to beat!!!
Jorey Steinberg was the very first female auditioner on Tuesday's Hollywood show. She sounded great to me, but they let her whole group go, saying that it was a bad way to start off Hollywood week!!!
tanbuns:
I shoulda known you'd know CeeeJay!!! :lol:
I am just going by what the article said about her not being eligible. I figured that they had decided that the best way to handle it was to just cut her early, and not make a big deal out of it!!!
RudyRules:
--- Quote from: tanbuns on February 16, 2007, 01:17:37 PM ---Ruday ....... you may be thinking of Jordin Sparks from Arizona. I agree she is one of the females to beat!!!
Jorey Steinberg was the very first female auditioner on Tuesday's Hollywood show. She sounded great to me, but they let her whole group go, saying that it was a bad way to start off Hollywood week!!!
--- End quote ---
I rewatched Tues show to jog my memory. Yep Tanny, you're right about Jory. How could I forget that she was in the first group and was the first one to perform!? :groan: Anyway, I am so sorry she didn't make it to the top 24. Her chances would've been better had she NOT been the first one or in the first group. There's more pressure being first. The others have an advantage by seeing the mistakes the first ones make. Simom remarked to the first group that "there was no originality".
It would be fair for the first group to be given a 2nd try after several other groups have performed! Or, all judges should tell ALL of them exactly what they are looking for in the initial performance. Do they get any coaching at all to help them get started in Hollywood I wonder?
If not, they should! :umn:
Navigation
[0] Message Index
[*] Previous page
Go to full version