Not a surprise that Carmen was voted off American Idol tonight. She should have been voted off last week. I sure enjoyed the group song that Diane Warren wrote just for them. I think the two battling out for the title of American Idol looks to be Ruben and Clay. I know Kimberly Locke has been improving each week and although the judges thought she did a fantastic performance last night, I didn't enjoy it and her voice was kind of shaky in the first part of the song.