Topic: Returning Racers Part 4: All-Star Wishlist

[gamerfan09]

Here's my honest opinion of the cast from TAR19 onwards for their chances of returning. (Not a Wishlist and is a possibility if TAR30 is returnees. No winners.)

Legend:
-People who got a montage at the end of their journey and/or a CBS YouTube Feature on them - Marked With Red
-Casual Faves - Marked With Blue
-Fan Favorites - Marked With Teal
-People with a Chance to Return (Unfinished Business, Nature of Boot) - Marked With Pink
-People with no Chance to Return - Marked With Grey

TAR19:
Amani & Marcus
Bill & Cathi

Andy & Tommy

Liz & Marie (Running out of money in a foreign land and getting a tear-filled elimination caused by aforementioned running out of money)

Jeremy & Sandy
Laurence & Zac
Justin & Jennifer
Kaylani & Lisa
Ethan & Jenna
Ron & Bill

TAR20:

Joey "Fitness" & Danny

Nary & Jamie (Eliminated after watching elephants on an NEL and being screwed the next leg  <3)

Vanessa & Ralph (Received montage but are now broken up.)
Art & JJ
Bopper & Mark (Mark is technically a threepeater AKA No.)
Kerri & Stacy
Elliot & Andrew
Dave & Cherie
Misa & Maiya (Their mistake would put them at a chance for an early-boot season though!)

TAR21:

Trey & Lexi
Jaymes & James

James & Abba

Abbie & Ryan
Rob & Kelley
Gary & Will
Caitlin & Brittany
Amy & Daniel (They were pretty liked around for being second boots I guess *shrugs* and victims of bad taxi could make them early-boot season returnees)
Rob & Sheila

TAR22:

Max & Katie
Chuck & Wynona

Mona & Beth
Pam & Winnie (Pam working for ABC now kinda seals the deal because ABC is affliated with TAR production =( )
Idries & Jamil
Matt & Daniel

TAR23:

Nicky & Kim
Tim & Danny

Tim & Marie

Nicole & Travis (Pretty much locks until Indonesia happened lmao.)
Ally & Ashley
Brandon & Adam
Chester & Ephraim (Their major flight ****-up is enough to put them on early boots but pls god no)
Rowan & Shane (Could be considered for an early boot season TBH)
Hoskote & Naina (Same.)

TAR25:

Tim & Te Jay
Misti & Jim
Kym & Alli

Shelley & Nici

Adam & Bethany

Brooke & Robbie (Considering these two are wrestlers/entertainers, an Exes John-Vito & Jill style return wouldn't be surprising)

Keith & Whitney
Michael & Scott (The Ankle Incident duh yes for early boot season)
Dennis & Isabelle
Lisa & Michelle (They, however, could be considered for an early boot season too!)

TAR26:

Hayley & Blair
Mike & Rochelle
Matt & Ashley

Bergen & Kurt (Watch their boot ep to get what I mean + the two are kinda friends now IRL  )

Aly & Steve
Jeff & Jackie (BB lmao)
Harley & Jonathan (He didn't really bring the ratings and I don't really remember people loving them too much so yeah)
Libby & CJ (#SelfieGate is definitely a memorable elimination but these two seem more suited for an early boot season.)
Jeff & Lyda (Ditto with U-Turned on the first leg)

TAR27: (Surprisingly no one got a montage (and I am going through people who got their own gallery on CBS so this is pretty 50/50)

Justin & Diana (*deep sighs*)
Logan & Chris ("We're not quite done yet" in their final confessional with a random OTTP kiss scene lmao they are at least getting asked)
Tiffany & Krista
Denise & James-Earl
Tanner & Josh

Cindy & Rick
Jazmine & Danielle
Ernest & Jin (Locks for first boots)
Alex & Adam
Kelly & Shevonne (These two would be definitely locks for a returnee season of early boots considering they were the first team to get their own "memorable moments" gallery since Jet & Cord on 24 lolpwnt but unfortunately not on a regular returnee season!)

What do y'all think?

[ovalorange]

Lol @ gamer forgetting the most memorable FF team since season 24

[gamerfan09]

Lol @ gamer forgetting the most memorable FF team since season 24

wtf typo awk edited in they're red

[gamerfan09]

And IRT my list, an early-boot season would cast:

M/M:
Chester & Ephraim
Rowan & Shane
Michael & Scott
Ernest & Jin

F/F:
Lisa & Michelle
Kelly & Shevonne
Misa & Maiya

M/F:
Amy & Daniel
Hoskote & Naina
Libby & CJ
Jeff & Lyda

 

[JohnYiu]

My wish list:

Andy & Tommy (S19)
Bopper & Mark (S20)
Max & Katie (S22)
Tim & Marie (S23)
Kym & Alli (S25)
Hayley & Blair (S26)
Justin & Diana (S27)
Tanner & Josh (S27)
Ernest & Jin (S27)
Erin & Joslyn (S28)
One from S29

[Platrium]

My wish list:

Andy & Tommy (S19)
Bopper & Mark (S20)
Tim & Marie (S23)
Max & Katie (S24)
Kym & Alli (S25)
Hayley & Blair (S26)
Justin & Diana (S27)
Tanner & Josh (S27)
Ernest & Jin (S27)
Erin & Joslyn (S28)
One from S29

Max & Katie were from TAR22, not TAR24.

[JohnYiu]

My wish list:

Andy & Tommy (S19)
Bopper & Mark (S20)
Tim & Marie (S23)
Max & Katie (S24)
Kym & Alli (S25)
Hayley & Blair (S26)
Justin & Diana (S27)
Tanner & Josh (S27)
Ernest & Jin (S27)
Erin & Joslyn (S28)
One from S29

Max & Katie were from TAR22, not TAR24.

my bad , fixed it

[doctor.nguyencaonhan]

My Wishlist for next All-stars season
Natalie and Nadiya (S21,24)
Jet and Cord (S16,18,24)
Caroline and Jennifer (S22,24)
Max and Katie (S22)
Adam and Bethany (S25)
Kym and Alli (S25)
Misti and Jim (S25)
Jeff and Jackie (S26)
Jelani and Jenny (S26)
Tiffany and Krista (S27)
Tanner and Josh (S27)

[Platrium]

Even though TAR28 is not yet done, I think I've seen enough to update this list of mine.

Before TAR28:
Kym & Alli!!! (still my main wish)

Others I would want to include: (TAR25-27 only)
Amy & Maya (if they could get another chance)
Misti & Jim
Adam & Bethany
Brooke & Robbie
Hayley & Blair
Matt & Ashley
Jeff & Jackie
Tiffany & Krista
Cindy & Rick
Ernest & Jin

Almost after TAR28:

Kym & Alli!!! (main wish)
Burnie & Ashley!!! (2nd main wish)

Misti & Jim
Brooke & Robbie
Matt & Ashley
Jeff & Jackie
Cindy & Rick
Ernest & Jin
Marty & Hagan
Erin & Joslyn
Scott & Blair

[RaceUntilWeDie]

Notes:
I made these lists using the following factors/restraints:
-run for at least four legs? compelling exception would be Bopper & Mark
-is it realistic? I don't see Hayley & Blair doing the Race again due to Hayley's relationship and they always use "scheduling" as their reason for not doing things together
-did CBS/TAR like them even tho nobody did?

So yeah, instead of making WISHlists I made realistic ones that suck :/

ALL STARS
-Brooke & Robbie, Wrestler Exes, Season 25
-Kym & Alli, Cyclists, Season 25
-Jeff & Jackie, Friends, Season 26
-Justin & Diana, Married, Season 27
-Tiffany & Krista, Former Cheerleaders, Season 27
-Tanner & Josh, Best Friends, Season 27
-Tyler & Korey, Best Friends, Season 28, if they don't win
-Sheri & Cole, Mother/Son, Season 28, if they don't win
-Scott & Blair, Father/Daughter, Season 28
-
-

UNFINISHED BUSINESS
-Brooke & Robbie, Wrestler Exes, Season 25, eliminated in 4th after getting lost *in the final leg*
-Kym & Alli, Season 25, came in 5th after Fast Forward battle!
-Justin & Diana, Season 27, came in 2nd after taxi troubles
-Tiffany & Krista, Season 27, came in 4th after Krista couldn't find fish
-Tanner & Josh, Season 27, came in 6th after the worst Speed Bump ever
-Tyler & Korey, Season 28, if they don't win they would be locks imo bc fanbase
-Burnie & Ashley, Season 28, came in 4th after wrong Detour pick and five 2nd's in a row
-Brodie & Kurt, Season 28, came in 5th after getting Twinnie U-Turned
-Scott & Blair, Season 28, came in 7th after picking up Tyler's bag by accident
-
-

ALTERNATES & WTF/CBS PICKS
-Leo & Jamal, Season 24,
-Bopper & Mark, Season 24
-Misti & Jim, Season 25
-Adam & Bethany, Season 25
-Matt & Ashley, Season 26
-Aly & Steve, Season 26
-Denise & James Earl, Season 27
-Jazmine & Danielle, Season 27 TAR needs more poc...
-Erin & Joslyn, Season 28

Final note:
-Brooke & Robbie are really bothering me They're such big characters and perfect for reality TV and an all stars season, but now that they've broken up and got eliminated in such a rough way, would they really do it again?
-Looking at the slight overload of Season 28 teams, it kind of makes me feel sick to my stomach even though I like all but Tyler & Korey. I guess it's because that season has felt like one big all star season. Unfortunately, I think a lot of these teams will be asked back.

[tennis33]

24- Bopper and Mark
    - Caroline and Jennifer

25 - Kim and Ali
    - Tim and Te Jay
    - misti and Jim

26 - Hayley & Blair   
     - Matt and Ashley

27 - Tiffany & Krista
   
28 - Scott and Blair
     - Berrnie and Ashley
     - Zachary and Rachel

Replacements

- Adam and Bethany
- Shelly and Nici
- Denise & James Earl
-Tanner and Josh
- Erin and Joslen

[TARUSAFan]

I wonder how a composite team would work around this time. How about Marie (of Tim & Marie) & Katie (of Max & Katie)? Marie wants Katie if she gets the chance to Race again. Or Brodie (of Brodie & Kurt) & Blair (of Scott & Blair).

[claude_24hrs]

I wonder how a composite team would work around this time. How about Marie (of Tim & Marie) & Katie (of Max & Katie)? Marie wants Katie if she gets the chance to Race again. Or Brodie (of Brodie & Kurt) & Blair (of Scott & Blair).

The 27 past teams would be chosen by an online public vote just like Big Brother All-Stars several years ago and last year's Survivor Second Chance. They had played once before and not yet won in their original TAR season. The candidates will consist of 9 F/F, 9 M/F and 9 M/M, which applies in all seasons. Once the public vote would close, the 27 candidate teams would be picked for 11 or 12 teams to be selected on TAR 30.

For all, either a team could make a composite team shown as above (ala Eric/Danielle and Mark/Mallory).

THE RULES

This applies for TAR 30 only, there will be no former winners, three-peats and four-timers.

Bopper & Mark are ineligible to give another shot, Mark has done in TAR 24 that could not compete for TAR 30. For Bopper, he can't make a backup partner as well.

Not include past teams are no longer in their relationship (Joseph & Monica, Brooke & Robbie).

LIST OF CANDIDATE TEAMS WOULD BE SELECTED FOR TAR 30:

ALL-FEMALE (F/F)

Lena & Kristy, Sisters, Season 6
Lyn & Karlyn, Single Moms, Season 10
Brook & Claire, Home Shopping Hosts/Best Friends, Season 17
Caitlin & Brittany, Best Friends, Season 21
Nicky & Kim, Baseball Wives, Season 23
Kym & Alli, Pro Cyclists, Season 25
Tiffany & Krista, Former Cheerleaders, Season 27
Jessica & Brittany, Instagram Models, Season 28
Katie (of Max & Katie, Season 22) & Marie (of Tim & Marie, Season 23), Composite team

ALL-MALE (M/M)

Derek & Drew, Twin Brothers, Season 3
David & Jeff, Best Friends, Season 4
Andrew & Dan, Frat Boys, Season 13
Sam & Dan, Brothers, Season 15
Andy & Tommy, Professional Snow Boarders, Season 19
Joey "Fitness" & Danny, Best Friends, Season 20
Jaymes & James, Chippendales, Season 21
Bergen & Kurt, Friends, Season 26
Tanner & Josh, Best Friends, Season 27

CO-ED (M/F)

Blake & Paige, Brother-Sister, Season 2
Hayden & Aaron, Married, Season 6
Toni & Dallas, Mother-Son, Season 13
Chad & Stephanie, Married, Season 17
Misti & Jim, Married, Season 25
Jeff & Jackie, Friends, Season 26
Aly & Steve, Dating, Season 26
Justin & Diana, Married, Season 27
Brodie (of Brodie & Kurt) & Blair (of Scott & Blair), Newly Dating, Season 28

[Platrium]

I wonder how a composite team would work around this time. How about Marie (of Tim & Marie) & Katie (of Max & Katie)? Marie wants Katie if she gets the chance to Race again. Or Brodie (of Brodie & Kurt) & Blair (of Scott & Blair).

I'm imagining Denise & Sheri from TAR27 and TAR28.

[TARUSAFan]

I wonder how a composite team would work around this time. How about Marie (of Tim & Marie) & Katie (of Max & Katie)? Marie wants Katie if she gets the chance to Race again. Or Brodie (of Brodie & Kurt) & Blair (of Scott & Blair).

I'm imagining Denise & Sheri from TAR27 and TAR28.

That possibility though, both are from Alabama.

[gamerfan09]

Can everyone let Brodie & Blair go they were never a thing despite the show rubbing it constantly in our face

Poor Blair and Brodie!

[Platrium]

I wonder how a composite team would work around this time. How about Marie (of Tim & Marie) & Katie (of Max & Katie)? Marie wants Katie if she gets the chance to Race again. Or Brodie (of Brodie & Kurt) & Blair (of Scott & Blair).

I'm imagining Denise & Sheri from TAR27 and TAR28.

That possibility though, both are from Alabama.

Oh, I didn't notice.
#Alabamoms

[gamerfan09]

Post-25?

Here are people I would pick for UB. (With an Intro!)

<a href="https://www.youtube.com/v/nJt7ueevJN4&amp;feature=youtu.be" target="_blank" class="new_win">https://www.youtube.com/v/nJt7ueevJN4&amp;feature=youtu.be</a>

Notable Alternates:
-Denise & James-Earl
-Sheri & Cole (if they don't win cut Burnie and put them there lol).
-Tanner & Josh
-Tim & Te Jay
-Bergen & Kurt

Aaaaand that's about it. I sure hope it's not till 30 though so we have a much bigger pool to choose from.

[TARJr.]

Post-25?

Here are people I would pick for UB. (With an Intro!)

<a href="https://www.youtube.com/v/nJt7ueevJN4&amp;feature=youtu.be" target="_blank" class="new_win">https://www.youtube.com/v/nJt7ueevJN4&amp;feature=youtu.be</a>

Notable Alternates:
-Denise & James-Earl
-Sheri & Cole (if they don't win cut Burnie and put them there lol).
-Tanner & Josh
-Tim & Te Jay
-Bergen & Kurt

Aaaaand that's about it. I sure hope it's not till 30 though so we have a much bigger pool to choose from.

I agree with this. However if Brooke and Robbie choose not to race again, I want to see Matt and Dana (if they don't win) take their place.

Imagine Logan & Chris + Matt & Dana + Hayley & Blair in one season. 

[cbacbacba1]

I would like to see the following teams to come back

Hayley & blair (season 26)
They are the focus of the season, it is a shame if they cannot return

Tiffany & Krista (season 27)
The typical fun and hyper all female teams

Sheri & Cole (season 28) / Denise & James Earl (season 27)
The typical under-dog type team, we need some parent-child team too

Max & Katie (season 22) / Tim & Marie (season 23)
We need teams that are clever and sneaky enough to create tensions between teams

Kym & Ali (season 25)
Powerful all-female teams to show a contrast with the cheerleaders

Justin & Diana (season 27) / Misti & Jim (season 25)
Strong teams that are proud of their leg wins but lose in finale

Scott & Blair (season 28) / Mike & Rochelle (season 26)
Weak teams that are served to be under-dogs

Matt & Ashley (season 26) / Aly & Steve (season 26) / Zach & Rachel (season 28)
Couples that are truly in love

Adam & Bethany (season 25)
Inspirational role-modal

Tanner & Josh (season 27) / Brodie & Kurt (season 28) / Jaymes & Jaymes (season 21)
Powerful male teams

Burnie & Ashley (season 28)
Strong team that never touch first place

Logan & Chris (season 27) / Dana & Matt (season 28)
Bickering couples

[Marionete]

I'm pretty sure Dana would pull a Marie and decline

[Jobby]

UB2 - Season 30 I'm assuming (who I really really want to see):
1. Kym and Allie
2. Misti and Jim
3. Adam and Bethany
4. Hayley and Blair
5. Denise and Earl James
6. Scott and Blair
7. Zach and Rachel
8. Burnie and Ashley
9. Sheri and Cole (if they don't win)
10. TAR 29 team
11. TAR 29 team

Alternates:
1. Tiffany and Krista
2. Tanner and Josh
3. Aly and Steve
4. Mike and Rochelle

Please don't ever return:
1. JUSTIN AND DIANA

[gamerfan09]

Please don't ever return:
1. JUSTIN AND DIANA

Amen to this!   

[Platrium]

Early Boots Season:

Marty & Hagan
Ernest & Jin
Lena & Kristy
Amy & Daniel
Caitlin & Brittany
Misa & Maiya
Amanda & Kris
Connor & Jonathan
Jody & Shannon
Matt & Daniel
Eric & Lisa
Bilal & Sa'eed
Duke & Lauren
Brad & Victoria
Mark & Bill
Mariana & Julia
Lorena & Jason

11 or 12 of these.

[RaceUntilWeDie]

Notes:
I made these lists using the following factors/restraints:
-run for at least four legs? compelling exception would be Bopper & Mark
-is it realistic? I don't see Hayley & Blair doing the Race again due to Hayley's relationship and they always use "scheduling" as their reason for not doing things together
-did CBS/TAR like them even tho nobody did?

So yeah, instead of making WISHlists I made realistic ones that suck :/

ALL STARS
-Brooke & Robbie, Wrestler Exes, Season 25
-Kym & Alli, Cyclists, Season 25
-Jeff & Jackie, Friends, Season 26
-Justin & Diana, Married, Season 27
-Tiffany & Krista, Former Cheerleaders, Season 27
-Tanner & Josh, Best Friends, Season 27
-Sheri & Cole, Mother/Son, Season 28
-Tyler & Korey, Best Friends, Season 28
-Burnie & Ashley, Engaged/Married Gamers, Season 28
-
-

UNFINISHED BUSINESS
-Brooke & Robbie, Wrestler Exes, Season 25, eliminated in 4th after getting lost *in the final leg*
-Kym & Alli, Season 25, came in 5th after Fast Forward battle!
-Justin & Diana, Season 27, came in 2nd after taxi troubles
-Tiffany & Krista, Season 27, came in 4th after Krista couldn't find fish
-Tanner & Josh, Season 27, came in 6th after the worst Speed Bump ever
-Tyler & Korey, Season 28, came in 3rd after running past the first clue and falling to last
-Burnie & Ashley, Season 28, came in 4th after wrong Detour pick and five 2nd's in a row
-Brodie & Kurt, Season 28, came in 5th after getting Twinnie U-Turned
-
-
-

ALTERNATES & WTF/CBS PICKS
-Leo & Jamal, Season 24,
-Bopper & Mark, Season 24
-Misti & Jim, Season 25
-Adam & Bethany, Season 25
-Matt & Ashley, Season 26
-Aly & Steve, Season 26
-Denise & James Earl, Season 27
-Jazmine & Danielle, Season 27 TAR needs more poc...
-Scott & Blair, Season 28
-Erin & Joslyn, Season 28

Final note:
-Brooke & Robbie are really bothering me They're such big characters and perfect for reality TV and an all stars season, but now that they've broken up and got eliminated in such a rough way, would they really do it again?
-Looking at the slight overload of Season 28 teams, it kind of makes me feel sick to my stomach even though I like all but Tyler & Korey. I guess it's because that season has felt like one big all star season. Unfortunately, I think a lot of these teams will be asked back.