Other Great Reality Shows > American Idol
Top 3 Discussion
Jobby:
Lauren
Hmmm, quick/fast first song choice for Lauren. Me thinks Lauren should stick with inspirational songs because she cliqued with me that way and i'm sure with America in the same way as well. It sounded like a gospel praise song so maybe the Christian population might like the performance. Great performance, great vocals but again similar to that of Haley, it was completely unmemorable. I felt there was 'no moment' there at all and didn't agree with JLo.
Okay, second song.. when Lauren started singing I felt that she instantly connected with me (as well as the audience) on the spot. I liked the song choice and after listening to the song, I would want to buy/listen to the song again and hear how the original song sounded like because Haley made the song so current and her vocals were so crystal clear throughout the performance. UNTIL, in the middle, where she destroyed the song by the technical fault. OH MY GOD. Lauren, you could have gotten a moment with your second song but WHY WHY WHY DID YOU MADE THE ERROR?! :meow: But overall, she's great with her song.. and now it's up for America to decide whether they want to vote less for her due to her mistake. I'm worried!
JLo's song choice for Lauren, HMMM. Okay, ballard. Oh dear, Lauren owns inspirational song than ballards. Oh oh oh dear. But great vocals. But there's 'no moment' created. Still a pretty much boring song choice, I don't think anybody's going to remember this song few years down the road. But it was really a great vocal performance, but not such an awesome song choice.
Hmmm, weird that i'm a Lauren and Haley fan but today Scotty's the one who BLEW IT for me!!! :lol3:
Jobby:
IMO, 2 cents worth (if you even care)
Round 1 Winner: Scotty
Round 1 Loser: Haley (more like chanting/yelling/whining than singing)
Round 2 Winner: Lauren (yes, even with the technical error, at least a moment was created there)
Round 2 Loser: Scotty (that was really boring, once again), Lauren (that mistake, could either make or break her)
Round 3 Winner: Scotty
Round 3 Loser: Lauren, Haley (Scotty smoked, the girls got smoked)
With that, i am certainly hoping for a Scotty and Lauren finale. I think Scotty deserved to be in the Final 2. See, i'm fair and not biased. Stop saying that Joab always supports the female contenders! :lol3:
Jobby:
And with this, great Joab predicts:
Haley is going home, Scotty is announced safe first and in the final 2 and down to two girls to fight it out. :meow:
:lol:
Prophet:
The Rhiannon performance was just really weird. I didn't get it at all.
Lauren's second could have been the best but she messed it up. Overall the arrangement wasn't that good though, it kind of skipped around in the song.
Scotty wasn't bad for his style and as much as he annoys me I will stick to predicting him to win. Based on crowd reaction alone he is the most popular.
Overall I have definitely seen better top threes, but this one is probably better than last year's. Who knows what the future holds for AI. I feel like the only reason they are still holding on to any popularity is because of the incredibly strong brand they built during their peak.
tea4me:
I want Lauren to win it all, but today I hope she is just safe.
Navigation
[0] Message Index
[#] Next page
[*] Previous page
Go to full version