Reality Fan Forum - The Amazing Race Spoilers - Big Brother Live Feed Updates - Survivor Spoilers - Reality TV Spoilers - Big Brother Spoilers

Other Great Reality Shows => American Idol => Topic started by: RudyRules on April 25, 2006, 04:05:38 AM

Title: Top Six: Who's voted out?
Post by: RudyRules on April 25, 2006, 04:05:38 AM
  Here we go...with the Top Six!  Wow, I bet these finalists are more excited now than ever and will pull off their best performances yet.   

I pick Elliott :yes: to be voted off the stage. 
(Puhleazzz...don't let it be Taylor!!  :nono:)






 


Title: Re: Top Six: Who's voted out?
Post by: Jeffrey Scott on April 25, 2006, 07:28:40 AM
Paris has really good weeks, then really bad weeks. I predict this will be a really bad week, and in light of all the other singes, she'll be the one going home.
Title: Re: Top Six: Who's voted out?
Post by: PenguinsDance on April 25, 2006, 01:03:09 PM
I think it will be Paris too.  Maybe Elliott will acquire ACE's votes.   :nods:

Of course my wish each week is that it will be Taylor or Kellie.   )-**   Sorry, Ruday!
Title: Re: Top Six: Who's voted out?
Post by: Jeffrey Scott on April 25, 2006, 01:22:31 PM
I like Kellie to much to let her go. And not necessarily because of her voice, more in a VFTW sort of way.
Title: Re: Top Six: Who's voted out?
Post by: Reality Junkee on April 25, 2006, 01:28:21 PM
I think it will be Paris also.  I don't see Kelly going yet.  Even though I don't like the site, I have seen her in the past on "Vote for the worst" website.  Like I said, they pick someone and they vote for that person.  If she is still on their list, then I see her getting lots of votes.

BTW, I like her also and would like to see her stay around awhile longer.  I predict Paris, Elliot and then Kelly in that order to leave.
Title: Re: Top Six: Who's voted out?
Post by: puddin on April 25, 2006, 07:09:38 PM
Katherine , goosebump factor 100% , my bf gives the cleavage factor 100x100  ;D
Title: Re: Top Six: Who's voted out?
Post by: Cole on April 25, 2006, 07:20:37 PM
katherine will win.

 :jumpy:
Title: Re: Top Six: Who's voted out?
Post by: puddin on April 25, 2006, 07:23:23 PM
I wouldnt mind if she won Cole  :hearts:

Elliot was really good too !

Hey is Paula like really far out there tonight ?  Paula " GET TAKE A PILL "   :meow:
Title: Re: Top Six: Who's voted out?
Post by: puddin on April 25, 2006, 07:32:48 PM
Kelly = the neverending song  :bedbug:
Title: Re: Top Six: Who's voted out?
Post by: Cole on April 25, 2006, 07:37:51 PM
i read on People.com Paula and Ryan are in a cat fight... :meow:

wonder if its true or not  ???

it apparently started when Ryan appeared on Jay Leno and made a comment insinuating that Paula drinks on the show  :lol3:
Title: Re: Top Six: Who's voted out?
Post by: puddin on April 25, 2006, 07:44:20 PM
that aint coke in that cup   ;)

I didnt think that much of Paris , Kat was better no matter what Paula said  :meow:
Title: Re: Top Six: Who's voted out?
Post by: puddin on April 25, 2006, 07:47:46 PM
I happen to love this song Taylor is going to sing , old Bo & Hope days  :'( , remember when she ice skated to this !?
Title: Re: Top Six: Who's voted out?
Post by: puddin on April 25, 2006, 07:49:44 PM
I thought it was half and half ..good ending started bad  middle sucked .
Title: Re: Top Six: Who's voted out?
Post by: Cole on April 25, 2006, 07:50:48 PM
awww....puddin i remember that  :-*

the judges are on crack.....taylor did a good job and i'm not a taylor fan

okay that was akward...paula simon....did anyone notice that....trouble in paradise
Title: Re: Top Six: Who's voted out?
Post by: puddin on April 25, 2006, 07:57:11 PM
Chris is sooooooo off key  :ignore: , ok getting better .........
Title: Re: Top Six: Who's voted out?
Post by: Cole on April 25, 2006, 07:58:43 PM
 :ignore: puddin is off her rocker

her Chris rocker ....  :lol3:
Title: Re: Top Six: Who's voted out?
Post by: Reality Junkee on April 25, 2006, 08:29:44 PM
This is my pick of how well (IMO) the singers did:

1 - Chris
2 - Elliot
3 - Katharine
4 - Taylor
5 - Paris
6 - Kelly

I would normally have put Paris last, but Kelly WAS so robotic when she sang and it didn't sound good IMO.  But I still believe she will somehow slide by and Paris will go home.  We'll see
Title: Re: Top Six: Who's voted out?
Post by: puddin on April 25, 2006, 08:50:20 PM
when Kelly hit that high note with her country twang I burst out  :lol3:
Title: Re: Top Six: Who's voted out?
Post by: Cole on April 25, 2006, 09:42:43 PM
i think Kelly's charm has worn off and she is going to pack her bags.
Title: Re: Top Six: Who's voted out?
Post by: puddin on April 25, 2006, 09:45:28 PM
she was pretty bad , good less stress for KAT :cheer:
Title: Re: Top Six: Who's voted out?
Post by: Jeffrey Scott on April 25, 2006, 09:50:15 PM
I agree with Cole. After tonight, I can no longer say I support Kellie.
Anyway, my column is posted if you want to read my thoughts.
www.realityfanforum.com
Title: Re: Top Six: Who's voted out?
Post by: Mo on April 25, 2006, 10:53:26 PM
This is my pick of how well (IMO) the singers did:

1 - Chris
2 - Elliot
3 - Katharine
4 - Taylor
5 - Paris
6 - Kelly

I would normally have put Paris last, but Kelly WAS so robotic when she sang and it didn't sound good IMO.  But I still believe she will somehow slide by and Paris will go home.  We'll see

Totally agree with your list -- It is SOOOOO time for Kellie to go, but I don't see it happening.  Bet she isn't even in the bottom three.  As for Chris, he can lay on the floor and sing to me any day!   :hearts:
Title: Re: Top Six: Who's voted out?
Post by: Reality Junkee on April 25, 2006, 11:12:15 PM
This is my pick of how well (IMO) the singers did:

1 - Chris
2 - Elliot
3 - Katharine
4 - Taylor
5 - Paris
6 - Kelly

I would normally have put Paris last, but Kelly WAS so robotic when she sang and it didn't sound good IMO.  But I still believe she will somehow slide by and Paris will go home.  We'll see

Totally agree with your list -- It is SOOOOO time for Kellie to go, but I don't see it happening.  Bet she isn't even in the bottom three.  As for Chris, he can lay on the floor and sing to me any day!   :hearts:

I laughed when I saw Chris sing on the floor like that.  I thought what if he were to perform like that??   :lol3:   

I think Kelly will be in bottom 3 but I have a bad feeling Katharine will also.  She's already been there twice and after the critizism she got tonight....well I think she's headed back.   So a possible bottom three could go :

Paris
Kelly
Katharine

Again, I think Paris will go.  Katharines too good and Kelly has the voting power from VFTW group (which I do not like). 

Again, we'll see.  Good to have you around Mo.  :-*
Title: Re: Top Six: Who's voted out?
Post by: Jeffrey Scott on April 25, 2006, 11:14:42 PM
Complete agreement with you RJ. All the women will be in bottom three. Tomorrow Ryan will seperate everyone into three groups I think though. Maybe only show bottom two?
Title: Re: Top Six: Who's voted out?
Post by: Bashful on April 26, 2006, 12:21:49 AM

Again, I think Paris will go.  Katharines too good and Kelly has the voting power from VFTW group (which I do not like). 


OK, I hate to sound ignorant, but I actually am....so, what is VFTW?   :-[ ???
Title: Re: Top Six: Who's voted out?
Post by: RudyRules on April 26, 2006, 03:29:56 AM
Bashful
Quote
what is VFTW?
  Vote For The Worst group.
RJ
Quote
Again, I think Paris will go.  Katharines too good and Kelly has the voting power from VFTW group (which I do not like).
 
RJ, I think I recall you saying VFTW is a site that picks who they think is the worst, then they call in votes FOR the worst, in this case Kellie.  Right?  If so, sucks that such a group exists.  Well, that means we must give our Favs even more votes!!  :jam:
---------------------
Gosh, I thought Kat was awesome and disagree with Paula that the song was "too big" for her.  Kat has done better, but geee...she is such a great performer...no matter what she sings!     

Taylor didn't seem as good tonite, but don't think he'll be in the bottom 2 or 3.   
I voted that Elliott would be gone this week, but after his performance tonite, don't think so!

I hope Kellie gets voted out.  This was 2 weeks in a row that she did poorly.

 
 
Title: Re: Top Six: Who's voted out?
Post by: TexasLady on April 26, 2006, 08:14:10 AM
I thought everyone sang well, even Kellie. It isn't her type of music and I think she was trying to go with the advice she was given. One thing I credit her with, she doesn't trash Simon, she admits when she sings badly. (Unlike some of the twerps who sound awful and think they are better than... (insert name)  :meow:

I would love to hear a duet with Kat and Bocelli!

Paris did a great job, it must be that in the theater they hear it differently than we do. She didn't seem to oversing to me. Her voice is powerful and I think it is hard for her to tone it down.

Taylor never does as well with the judges when he doesn't do his own thing. Loved his hint of color with the red in the pocket.

And my gripe... big one!  (:;) (:;) (:;) TWO guitarists?? SUPER good lighting? LAST singer?? PULEEEZEEEEE! Chris sang and did well because he sang instead of yelling as he has tended to do from time to time.
Title: Re: Top Six: Who's voted out?
Post by: Reality Junkee on April 26, 2006, 11:28:31 AM
Bashful
Quote
what is VFTW?
  Vote For The Worst group.
RJ
Quote
Again, I think Paris will go.  Katharines too good and Kelly has the voting power from VFTW group (which I do not like).
 
RJ, I think I recall you saying VFTW is a site that picks who they think is the worst, then they call in votes FOR the worst, in this case Kellie.  Right?  If so, sucks that such a group exists.  Well, that means we must give our Favs even more votes!!  :jam:
---------------------
Gosh, I thought Kat was awesome and disagree with Paula that the song was "too big" for her.  Kat has done better, but geee...she is such a great performer...no matter what she sings!     

Taylor didn't seem as good tonite, but don't think he'll be in the bottom 2 or 3.   
I voted that Elliott would be gone this week, but after his performance tonite, don't think so!

I hope Kellie gets voted out.  This was 2 weeks in a row that she did poorly.

 
 

Rudy (or should I say Vuday again :lol: ), yes, that is right about VFTW thread.  It DOES suck and wish they wouldn't do things like that.  That's why I think Kelly will be safe again....but who knows. :groan:
Title: Re: Top Six: Who's voted out?
Post by: x_kicks on April 26, 2006, 11:30:42 AM
For me, I want Kellie to go, but I think Elliot will be the one being sent home.
Title: Re: Top Six: Who's voted out?
Post by: PenguinsDance on April 26, 2006, 11:34:38 AM
I don't know if you all caught this or not ... http://dialidol.com/asp/predictions/Predictions.asp

but it does look like ALL GIRL bottom 3. 

I voted lots and lots for Katharine too.   (:;) 
Title: Re: Top Six: Who's voted out?
Post by: Cole on April 26, 2006, 12:57:10 PM
OK, I hate to sound ignorant, but I actually am....so, what is VFTW?   :-[ ???


cuz we know that you could never be ignorant...just sound like it.

 :lol3: :rotf:  :lol3:  :rotf:  :neener:
Title: Re: Top Six: Who's voted out?
Post by: TexasLady on April 26, 2006, 01:01:52 PM
I don't know if you all caught this or not ... http://dialidol.com/asp/predictions/Predictions.asp

but it does look like ALL GIRL bottom 3. 

I voted lots and lots for Katharine too.   (:;) 

 :'( I kinda think my gal is gone tonight. I don't know if this poll is accurate or not, I did call to vote starting with Kat and got through first try, 45 mins into voting. Then I voted for Kellie, got right through. Just to see how it was going, I also was able to vote for Paris and Elliott without encountering too many redials. Wish I had kept track. (HMMM am I voting for the losers?? Don't answer that!) :-* :-* :-*

 :angel: I did get busy signals though.... even after I voted a time or two.  I could see Elliott going tonight, Bucky went after Simon praised him..... ???

So much to do, so little time....
Title: Re: Top Six: Who's voted out?
Post by: Jeffrey Scott on April 26, 2006, 01:29:34 PM
If Kellie doesn't go home tonight she's going home next week. As much as they think they do, VFTW has it's limitations. I'd love to see how many active members they really have and of those, who actively votes and how many times.
Title: Re: Top Six: Who's voted out?
Post by: Rob on April 26, 2006, 03:28:03 PM
that dialidol is very interesting!! Never heard of it before

Rob
Title: Re: Top Six: Who's voted out?
Post by: Bashful on April 26, 2006, 08:09:55 PM
OK, I hate to sound ignorant, but I actually am....so, what is VFTW?   :-[ ???


cuz we know that you could never be ignorant...just sound like it.

 :lol3: :rotf:  :lol3:  :rotf:  :neener:

Cole, you are NOT NEARLY as funny as you think you are.    :meow: :meow: :meow:
Title: Re: Top Six: Who's voted out?
Post by: puddin on April 26, 2006, 08:23:03 PM
here we gooooooooooooooooooooooooooooo :popcorn:
Kelly & Paris I bet are the lowest
Title: Re: Top Six: Who's voted out?
Post by: puddin on April 26, 2006, 08:25:21 PM
Elliot and Taylor safe .....not surprised !
Title: Re: Top Six: Who's voted out?
Post by: puddin on April 26, 2006, 08:30:13 PM
byeeeeeeeeee Kelly  :bye:
Title: Re: Top Six: Who's voted out?
Post by: PenguinsDance on April 26, 2006, 08:57:05 PM
 :jumpy:   :bliss: :Cdance: :gammy: :hfive: :hyper: :ya3:

 :waves: Kellie!!!
Title: Re: Top Six: Who's voted out?
Post by: Mo on April 26, 2006, 09:01:44 PM
Oh, sorry Pickler!!!!! (so NOT!!!!)  **** dancing around singing "you had a BAD day"****

Good bye and good riddance to Pickler and her not even believable dumb blonde act!   :woohoo:
Title: Re: Top Six: Who's voted out?
Post by: TexasLady on April 27, 2006, 07:46:44 AM
DANG I was right, my little gal is gone. I don't believe she is stupid as claimed by a lot of people, she hasn't had a good education and there is a difference. She's only 19. Not all that mature. I give her great credit. I cannot recall another idol contestant thanking the people behind the scenes. A class act leaving. I hope someone helps her with her career. The camera loves her. Country is her genre.

That said, I'm fed up with Idol, Seacrest dissing Simon, and most of all Paula's odd behavior. It is clear that Chris has been anointed for the next AI. We saw the final two last night, Katherine and Chris. Taylor will most likely make it to 3rd place. I can't wait till next Tuesday.. what will we see for old Chris? A whole rock band on stage with him and special effects?  I think he can sing when he chooses to sing, but most of the time he screams and it isn't appealing to me at all.

Katherine has the potential to become a true star, several times she has shown she could be a super star. Believe in yourself Katherine!

I love Taylor, Elliott and Paris. Paris will be fine, we'll hear from her in the future. Taylor and Elliott, I dunno..

Title: Re: Top Six: Who's voted out?
Post by: Jeffrey Scott on April 27, 2006, 08:19:24 AM
I believe you have it right. We did see the final two last night. I think the next few eliminations will go this way.

Paris
Eliliott
Taylor

and the winner will be Chris.

Again, you are so right about Chris being picked to win.
I'm sure after Wednesday's show, Fox ran in there and told Simon and Randy to retract the 'awful' things they said about Katharine.
Title: Re: Top Six: Who's voted out?
Post by: TexasLady on April 27, 2006, 11:19:23 AM
I believe you have it right. We did see the final two last night. I think the next few eliminations will go this way.

Paris
Eliliott
Taylor

and the winner will be Chris.

I agree Jeff, BTW I love your recaps.  :hearts: :hearts:

Elliott could do with some cosmetic work, but his stylists have been dressing him more appropriately. He has a great voice, maybe he can find a niche in recordings.  ???

Title: Re: Top Six: Who's voted out?
Post by: RudyRules on April 28, 2006, 04:20:52 AM
DANG I was right, my little gal is gone. I don't believe she is stupid as claimed by a lot of people, she hasn't had a good education and there is a difference. She's only 19. Not all that mature. I give her great credit. I cannot recall another idol contestant thanking the people behind the scenes. A class act leaving. I hope someone helps her with her career. The camera loves her. Country is her genre.
Agree, TL.  She's naive, not stupid.  And, she wasn't putting on a "dumb blond act".  She simply doesn't catch on to stuff probably b/c she was overprotected by her family. Perhaps they just stayed close to home due to low income? Dunno, but  Kellie wasn't exposed to the "real world"...for whatever reasons.   Yes, Country is her genre and if she could've sang only Country on AI, she would've gone further.  She's a sweet gal, and I wish her the best.   
Quote
That said, I'm fed up with Idol, Seacrest dissing Simon, and most of all Paula's odd behavior. It is clear that Chris has been anointed for the next AI. We saw the final two last night, Katherine and Chris. Taylor will most likely make it to 3rd place. I can't wait till next Tuesday.. what will we see for old Chris? A whole rock band on stage with him and special effects?   I think he can sing when he chooses to sing, but most of the time he screams and it isn't appealing to me at all.
But aren't all of the idols allowed to have a rock band, guitarists, special effects or whatever to enhance their performance?  Maybe I'M naive, but I don't believe the show is rigged.  Yeah, the judges have their favs, but if they showed partiality to certain ones...gave them special priviledges, they would be in deep uknowhat! 
Quote
Katherine has the potential to become a true star, several times she has shown she could be a super star. Believe in yourself Katherine!
I love Taylor, Elliott and Paris. Paris will be fine, we'll hear from her in the future. Taylor and Elliott, I dunno..
Yes, Kat is so great and I hope she is the next AI.  I'd love to see Taylor in 2nd, but doubt he will.  I've liked some of Chris's performances, but don't think he'll be the next AI.  Same with Elliott.  Of all of them, Elliott has made the biggest improvement.  Paris will most definitely be successful with her charisma and powerhouse voice!

Was it my imagination...or did Taylor appear to be not himself at the Results Show?   He hardly cracked a smile, his lips were persed, he looked tense and stressed.  All the others were smiling, but Taylor had such a serious, straight face and kinda forced a smile now & then.  Aww heck, maybe he just had a bad hair day!? :waves: 


 


Title: Re: Top Six: Who's voted out?
Post by: Cole on April 28, 2006, 05:29:43 AM
What thread has been locked up longer than Prison Break?

 :lol3:
Title: Re: Top Six: Who's voted out?
Post by: Jeffrey Scott on April 28, 2006, 05:55:22 AM
Off Topic!  :flamemad:
Title: Re: Top Six: Who's voted out?
Post by: Trevor on April 29, 2006, 09:35:04 AM
DANG I was right, my little gal is gone. I don't believe she is stupid as claimed by a lot of people, she hasn't had a good education and there is a difference. She's only 19. Not all that mature. I give her great credit. I cannot recall another idol contestant thanking the people behind the scenes. A class act leaving. I hope someone helps her with her career. The camera loves her. Country is her genre.
Agree, TL.  She's naive, not stupid.  And, she wasn't putting on a "dumb blond act".  She simply doesn't catch on to stuff probably b/c she was overprotected by her family. Perhaps they just stayed close to home due to low income? Dunno, but  Kellie wasn't exposed to the "real world"...for whatever reasons.   Yes, Country is her genre and if she could've sang only Country on AI, she would've gone further.  She's a sweet gal, and I wish her the best.   
Quote

I don't think Kellie Pickler was nearly as stupid as people painted her out to be.  I think she was putting on a Jessica Simpson type act and it worked.  Wouldn't be shocked if she still gets some kind of album deal or finds her way into a sitcom.
Title: Re: Top Six: Who's voted out?
Post by: Rob on April 29, 2006, 01:37:47 PM
Kellie was dumb, she was on Leno and asked what a Cameo was. She was spinning the wheel of consolation, and it was a Cameo on a movie, and she had NO idea!!

It was funny, and Leno made fun of her!

Rob
Title: Re: Top Six: Who's voted out?
Post by: Reality Junkee on April 29, 2006, 02:13:39 PM
Rob, I saw her on Leno also and also laughed when she said she didn't know what a cameo was.

 :lol3: :lol3: :lol3: :lol3: :lol3: :lol3:
Title: Re: Top Six: Who's voted out?
Post by: RudyRules on April 29, 2006, 04:22:28 PM
At least Kellie keeps her sense of humor when razzed about being dumb.  Is she pretending her sense of humor?  :snics:   

I've been using the word Naive for her, but after researching my trusty dictionary...she's both Naive AND Dumb!  :rolleyes

Ignorant or stupid = dense = a mind that is virtually impenetrable or incapable of grasping even elementary ideas.

Lacking worldliness & sophistication; inexperienced; lacking critical ability or analytical insight; not subtle or learned; not previously exposed to particular experiences, conditions, or information; innocent; natural, simple, unaffected.

Whatever...wishing her good luck with her life after AI.  Not my Fav contestant, but love her smile, good nature, sweetness.
I feel a bit sorry for her if she isn't isn't pretending, if she honestly lacks knowledge, and is truly unable to grasp things normally.   
 Love n' blessings to her...in either case.  :gj:  Kellie!
Ruday
Title: Re: Top Six: Who's voted out?
Post by: Cole on April 29, 2006, 05:03:38 PM
help me here are we talking about Kellie or Jeffrey  :lol3:
Title: Re: Top Six: Who's voted out?
Post by: Jeffrey Scott on April 30, 2006, 05:59:42 PM
 :lol3:  You are so funny.