Reality Fan Forum - The Amazing Race Spoilers - Big Brother Live Feed Updates - Survivor Spoilers - Reality TV Spoilers - Big Brother Spoilers
Archive => RFF Archived Boards => Survivor 11: Guatemala => Topic started by: silvercrank on October 07, 2005, 11:48:31 AM
-
The tribes need to live in the same camp. How much more drama & tension would there be with 18 individuals living in the same place?!
After a tribe loses in the competition, they do not have to go back to camp and see the other tribe happy and gloating, and this is where survivor loses out. Think how boring it would have been if on BB the nerd herd was secluded in a different section of the house?
-
They tried the 2 tribes/1 camp in S5. It was Bleh! LOL
Rob
-
I don't even remember that...was it for the whole game?
-
No, it was for about 1 show! It wasn't that great, but Shi-Ann screwed herself that day, thinking it was merge, but it was just two tribes living at one camp!
Rob
-
Didn't they do that last season too for the first episode....But I think it would be different if it lasted more than one episode. normally everyone is still on thier best behavior and just feeling everything out...
-
i think once you are on a tribe that should be it.noone should switch,it hurts the integrity of the game,makes it more predictable,and unfair to some of the players(ex.those women that were with judd,now hes with steph and her friends,so now they are gonna get picked off before there can be a merge,just cause of the damn switch,its not fair
-
How is the integrity of the game hurt???? they have been doing switches since S2 and S10 was the first with out one since??? how does it make it more predictable considering Palau didnt have any switches and was by far the most predictable season (except for Amazon and ASS THANKS AGAIN CHILLONE!! ) You know cause Survivor has always been fair; since Paschal pull the rock that is. The words fair and survivor dont belong together.
I think we should all use my posting method, post re-read, think then delete quickly if you really dont make sense. I would have over 1000 post if i didnt delete all the ones that were just well a little off.
-
Another good point If you wanna see a game where there are definate divisons or teams but they all are forced to live together I suggest Big Brother they just finished a great season 6 and got renewed for season 7.
-
i think once you are on a tribe that should be it.none should switch,it hurts the integrity of the game,makes it more predictable,and unfair to some of the players(ex.those women that were with Judd,now hes with Steph and her friends,so now they are gonna get picked off before there can be a merge,just cause of the damn switch,its not fair
Any game that has as much product placement as Survivor can claim no integrity.
Survivor is only predictable when they don't switch or merge. Though last season was great to see a team get their ass beat good, it was very predictable.
How was the tribes fair before the switch? Steph's team had crazy Lydia, useless Brianna and Morgan, Old Gary who won't throw anything as not to give away his football arm, well meaning but outmatched Brian, not too bright Jamie, and woe-is-me Steph. Fair Tribe??!
Besides Margaret does anyone care about those women that were with Judd?