Reality Fan Forum - The Amazing Race Spoilers - Big Brother Live Feed Updates - Survivor Spoilers - Reality TV Spoilers - Big Brother Spoilers

Other Great Reality Shows => Other Reality TV Shows & News => Topic started by: Polaroid on June 23, 2013, 09:16:09 PM

Title: Whodunnit?
Post by: Polaroid on June 23, 2013, 09:16:09 PM
I think we have series similar to The Mole! Interestingly enough, it's airing on ABC, the same channel that aired The Mole. It's basically the same as The Mole, but way creepier. :lol:

The premise (copied from Wikipedia):

The series will follow 13 investigators living in a mansion, Rue Manor, where one of the investigators is the "killer". A "murder" will take place around which the players will base their investigation using CSI technology and establishing pacts among one another. At the end of each episode, each player, in a private video confession, will explain how the murder took place. During dinner, each investigator will receive an envelope. Those who deduced most accurately receive a card saying "Spared", while those doing the worst receive a card saying "Scared" and will be up for elimination. During the night, the "killer" will "murder" one of the "Scared" players, eliminating them from the game, and setting up the "murder" for the next episode. In the finale, the investigator to correctly solve the identity of the "killer" wins $250,000.
Title: Re: Whodunnit?
Post by: Joeyengen on June 23, 2013, 09:41:35 PM
Great show i just finished watching it like 40 mins ago hahahaha :D
Title: Re: Whodunnit?
Post by: realshowfan on June 23, 2013, 09:45:15 PM
Great show i just finished watching it like 40 mins ago hahahaha :D

I'll be sure to give it a try then! New Mole-ish game <3 Maybe this will be the thing that reignites my interest in mysteries. :lol:
Title: Re: Whodunnit?
Post by: Leafsfan on June 23, 2013, 09:53:56 PM
Very interesting premiere :P
Title: Re: Whodunnit?
Post by: Polaroid on June 23, 2013, 10:44:46 PM
I thought that this show was real for the first few minutes... :funny: The deaths seem so realistic!
Title: Re: Whodunnit?
Post by: Leafsfan on June 23, 2013, 10:50:19 PM
I thought that this show was real for the first few minutes... :funny: The deaths seem so realistic!

I wonder how they make it look so real  :funny:
Title: Re: Whodunnit?
Post by: coolio on June 23, 2013, 11:20:32 PM
Watched the premiere as well, and it was great! Glad to see a cleaner, refined, scarier version of the Mole!


EDIT: My 1000 post on RFF dedicated to Whodunnit <3333333
Title: Re: Whodunnit?
Post by: realshowfan on June 23, 2013, 11:25:11 PM
Watched the premiere as well, and it was great! Glad to see a cleaner, refined, scarier version of the Mole!


EDIT: My 1000 post on RFF dedicated to Whodunnit <3333333

Congrats!!! :cheer:
Title: Re: Whodunnit?
Post by: Leafsfan on June 23, 2013, 11:34:45 PM
Watched the premiere as well, and it was great! Glad to see a cleaner, refined, scarier version of the Mole!


EDIT: My 1000 post on RFF dedicated to Whodunnit <3333333

<3333

Congrats  :keeta:
Title: Re: Whodunnit?
Post by: Reilly Queens on June 25, 2013, 12:23:53 AM
Just watched, love the mix of scripted & competition reality show.

It also looks like there is an unaired quiz since I caught this at the end
(http://i1051.photobucket.com/albums/s430/Aero-Hollister/C8E20138-8A71-4E27-B87E-BF82F16242EB-815-000000BBA88339F3.jpg)
Title: Re: Whodunnit?
Post by: realshowfan on June 25, 2013, 12:59:51 AM
Exhilarating and suspenseful <333 I'm just wondering how they got the person in the morgue. Was that the real Sherri and did she breathe or anything? I think she was a decoy/fake player in the game just so they had the opening murder scene.

Who do you guys think is the murderer? My initial guess was Melina just out of observation, but unless she knows how to shed crocodile tears, her crying at dinner kinda gave me second thoughts.

Pretty sure these contestants had to pass the acting test to be on this show. :lol: But I'm wondering how they set up these murders. Do they really 'perform' it with the murderer and the victim really being at the designated places at the specific times (as in Sherri and murderer in the showers, or do they skip all those parts and directly work on giving Sherri the realistic make-up).

Dontae/Dante's Inferno :lol:
Title: Re: Whodunnit?
Post by: Alfwin on June 25, 2013, 01:28:51 AM
My guess for the killer are:

1)Dana
She was the only one that knows that if the spinal cord at the back of the neck is injured, it is fatal. She also said that she is 'done' with Dontae after she found out he told people about the muskat.

2)Adrinna
The person firing the slingshot is left-handed if you rewatched it and Adrinna pulled up her card using her left hand.

3)Geno
He is a bar trivia host. It would made sense to kill Sheri because she broke her champaign glass and it offends Geno. Thus, making him want to kill her.

4)Don
At the beginning, he has an interview about him being a cop and he said 'I want them to think that I am the same as them'. Don could also made himself look unsuspicious by giving himself a scarred card.

5)Ulysses
He, Dana and Dontae made a deal about not telling anybody about the muskat and when he found out, he says that if he is the killer, he would kill Dontae next.

6)Ronnie
When Ulysses, told what he 'found' in the morgue, he asked whether or not that he should just drown Dontae in the pool and technically, that's how Dontae died later in the episode.
Title: Re: Whodunnit?
Post by: Reilly Queens on June 25, 2013, 01:37:58 AM

Do they really 'perform' it with the murderer and the victim really being at the designated places at the specific times (as in Sherri and murderer in the showers, or do they skip all those parts and directly work on giving Sherri the realistic make-up).

Dontae/Dante's Inferno :lol:

I also saw in the credits "portions of this program not affecting the outcome have been edited and or recreated for broadcast"

So I'm assuming he wears a fire suit running out and refilm him falling in with burnt clothes or sth
Title: Re: Whodunnit?
Post by: Reilly Queens on June 25, 2013, 05:30:11 AM
Fwiw..(possible clues not a spoiler)

The killer on Whodunnit?
It’s Ulysses.
Referring to people as mortals? Ulysses was a Greek hero (whatever, close enough)
The Second King? Ulysses was a king of Ithaca.

The killer also killed because she spilt her drink, and Melina is a flight attendant who serves drinks and cleans up after people etc

(http://images.yuku.com/image/gif/535251180fa8640b1e896a6305b3a66b4856b51_r.gif)
Title: Re: Whodunnit?
Post by: realshowfan on June 25, 2013, 01:00:11 PM
Interesting deductions, Kandace! :colors The twitter post is intriguing. I rewatched it and tried to note down the possible hints at the party.

Show content
Cris ~ first person to speak i think, and it was to talk to Sheri, and she also pointed at the iron thing

Dana ~ that 'kids on time out' comment and when they toasted, she didn't look so eager

Adrianna ~ accurately guessed Ronnie and Don's occupations, as if she knew them all along & gave that welcome speech. no one but the murder knew that killing was involved at that moment, so it'd be easy for them to miss that

Don ~ that 'i wanna be like them' comment

Melina ~ when the butler showed up she used the phrase 'dead man walking', like she had the impression death was involved when they didn't know that it was about murder yet

Ulysses ~ stood next to Sheri at the back when she dropped her glass. he said something about it but i could not make the words out. Ronnie also said something

And about Adrianna and the slingshot, at the room where she theorizes how the murder went down, she acted out that she was using a slingshot. Does anyone remember which hand she used? She is my fave player and for a first eppy a lot of fingers were pointed at her as the murderer, but it's still possible.
Title: Re: Whodunnit?
Post by: Alfwin on June 25, 2013, 09:23:27 PM
I rewatched it again and it shows Adrinna using her right hand.

I also have another theory that Adrinna is the killer and that is she suspected Dontae of being the killer which I thought was very weird because you could not see Adrinna being very close to Dontae and she did not specify her reasons in any of her confessions.

The same could be applied to Melinda(?) saying Cris is the killer.

This could be proved accurate by the next episode if Adrinna suspected the next person to be killed.

But I feel the editing is showing Adrinna to be the killer, thus, I don't think think the editing crew will make the killer so obvious.
Title: Re: Whodunnit?
Post by: SuperTux on June 25, 2013, 11:08:08 PM
Where can I watch it? Thanx
Title: Re: Whodunnit?
Post by: David on June 26, 2013, 05:24:20 AM
Where can I watch it? Thanx

THIS.

If someone ever found some links, PM me privately. Thanxxx
Title: Re: Whodunnit?
Post by: SuperTux on June 26, 2013, 11:06:31 PM
I guess the murderer is Geno.
Title: Re: Whodunnit?
Post by: Leafsfan on June 30, 2013, 09:17:11 PM
Great second episode. Third looks more intriguing as well.
Title: Re: Whodunnit?
Post by: Reilly Queens on July 01, 2013, 08:10:56 AM
Episode 2 <33

-Lindsey: I wanna throw my flag in the fireplace
-Adrianna: No don't its gonna explode *backs away*
-Lindsey: I think we throw it in

Dana being scorned by Ulysess:
(http://o.aolcdn.com/hss/storage/fss/6d5046fe00fafc14becde401f1f58e24)

Adrianna's rejection comment arc <3
Ep1 "Okay well I'm settin my plate down because i WILL sit in the shade"
Ep2 "I will leave, but you don't have to be so rude about it"

Kam is bad.

Adrianna :sadtorch

My suspects are 1) Ulysess 2) Lindsey 3) Dana

Ulysess- Greek mortal clues etc
Lindsey- lots of holy references, shes a pastors daughter.
Dana- Seemed fishy, her or Melina defo for the #3 slot.
Title: Re: Whodunnit?
Post by: Reilly Queens on July 01, 2013, 08:20:29 AM
fwiw
(http://i.imgur.com/iTp7vxd.png)
The person Ulysess suspects is 2/2 for going home..
Title: Re: Whodunnit?
Post by: Alfwin on July 01, 2013, 08:30:40 AM
I noticed that during the broadcast of how Dontae was killed, the pajamas was tied by RED ribbons. When the fire alarm rang, everybody got out and guess who have red ribbons tied to her hair: Sasha and Dana.

I believed Dana to be the killer since by giving Ulysses the first impression blah blah. It could mean that she is impressed by how he can jump ship so quickly or since she is supposedly be hating Ulysses, it would be weird to be impressed by Ulysses and throw attention off her.

But when I think about it, I think everybody got red ribbons so maybe Dana and Sasha just coincidentally tied that to their hair.

Title: Re: Whodunnit?
Post by: realshowfan on July 01, 2013, 11:23:21 AM
Adrianna  :'(  But I felt so bad for Dana that I wanted her to stay even though I wanted Adrianna. But Dana's been speaking threats many times so far.

Lindsey and Cris are my top suspects. These people are seeing something in Cris that I feel the show isn't showing us, at least not explicitly.
Title: Re: Whodunnit?
Post by: Polaroid on July 01, 2013, 03:44:18 PM
I felt so bad for Dana... I was almost sure that she was going to get killed off! I thought that Adrianna was the killer, but I guess not.
Title: Re: Whodunnit?
Post by: coolio on July 01, 2013, 05:30:02 PM
I'm so sad Adrianna was sent home! I thought for sure Dana was gone when she said the door knob was an accelerant.

My number 1 suspect right now is Lindsay, since she has missed the clue twice now, and still stayed alive. It also could be Melina, because if all that crying is on cue, she would be an amazing killer.
Title: Re: Whodunnit?
Post by: coolio on July 07, 2013, 11:30:45 PM
Ok, after this episode, the only I can do now at this show is  :res:. I mean, the next victim is killed by a cougar! Could they not think of a better way to kill someone? Also, the people of this show are trying to make it Survivor or Big Brother. They try to not hurt others before helping themselves, hence the alliance war this episode. Right now, I'll still watch the show to end because of its interesting concept, but I hope the deaths become a little more realistic in future episodes.
Title: Re: Whodunnit?
Post by: Air on July 07, 2013, 11:31:53 PM
I mean, the next victim is killed by a cougar!

Sarah Roza is on the prowl.
Title: Re: Whodunnit?
Post by: realshowfan on July 08, 2013, 03:29:17 AM
Episode was okay, though I might have to rewatch for any killer clues.
Title: Re: Whodunnit?
Post by: Glamazon Racer on July 08, 2013, 11:09:02 AM
Loving this show so far! <3 Although I was cheering for Adrianna so that's a shame. :(

The next murder looks plain weird... :ascared

I suspect Geno for some reason, although I kinda want it to be a girl like Lindsay or Cris to catch everyone off guard.

Dana bottomgoddessing <3
Title: Re: Whodunnit?
Post by: Alfwin on July 08, 2013, 11:28:57 AM
I have a feeling the killer is Dana.

Dana because she missed so many things and I just don't find it fair that Ron was killed instead of her because it looks like Don at least did something while Dana is just waiting around for information.
Title: Re: Whodunnit?
Post by: Glamazon Racer on July 08, 2013, 11:36:30 AM
I have a feeling the killer is Dana.

Dana because she missed so many things and I just don't find it fair that Ron was killed instead of her because it looks like Don at least did something while Dana is just waiting around for information.

I had  the same thought actually, but then a part of me thinks that her emotions looked really real when she was Scared the first time.
Title: Re: Whodunnit?
Post by: Alfwin on July 08, 2013, 11:42:01 AM
I have a feeling the killer is Dana.

Dana because she missed so many things and I just don't find it fair that Ron was killed instead of her because it looks like Don at least did something while Dana is just waiting around for information.

I had  the same thought actually, but then a part of me thinks that her emotions looked really real when she was Scared the first time.
Melina had like the exact same reaction to every death, every opening of envelopes. My suspects for now are Dana, Ulysses and Geno. Cris's reaction to her Spared card in the latest episode, in which she sweared was too real. My initial suspect was also Lindsey but Geno mention how Adrinna and Dontae was with Lindsey and afterwards were killed which just show me that editing is making us think Lindsey is the killer.
Title: Re: Whodunnit?
Post by: Reilly Queens on July 08, 2013, 07:57:18 PM
My Top 3 Suspects:
1. Ulysess(still pretty utr with red herrings, the mortals idrk)
2. Melina(No one suspects her and she's always making gasps at everything, but it could be the scripts or sth)
3. Dana(Just cause she pointed out that sometimes the person with the scare card might not be the worst/2nd worst scorer and she could know that. Also her in general today like mentioned was off)
Title: Re: Whodunnit?
Post by: anhgau2007 on July 09, 2013, 10:04:55 AM
Where can I find HD links of this show?
Title: Re: Whodunnit?
Post by: Polaroid on July 14, 2013, 09:00:24 PM
I am shocked... :ascared
Title: Re: Whodunnit?
Post by: realshowfan on July 15, 2013, 12:24:48 PM
My top suspects
Show content
Lindsey and Cris (and Melina for third)
are still in.

I really wonder what they see in Cris that led some of them to believe she is the murderer. For Kam/Geno/Adrianna, they made it clear how ppl thought of them as the killer.

Anyway, loved the eppy. <333 Sad about who went home and honestly hoped it was the other one instead. I cannot wait for the next eppy.
Title: Re: Whodunnit?
Post by: Glamazon Racer on July 15, 2013, 11:14:31 PM
I'm shocked too. I thought
Show content
Ulysses might be the killer OR would make it far in the competition
. But of the two Scared Cards, the one I hoped would go, did. :P

I think that
Show content
Geno might be the killer OR is going to make it deep in the competition. He's one of my favourites, along with Dana, Melina and Lindsey.
Title: Re: Whodunnit?
Post by: Polaroid on July 16, 2013, 01:33:30 AM
I really like Dana and Melina... Dana's medical knowledge is really amazing. Definitely helped her. :)
Title: Re: Whodunnit?
Post by: Glamazon Racer on July 16, 2013, 10:10:56 AM
I really like Dana and Melina... Dana's medical knowledge is really amazing. Definitely helped her. :)

Yeah, that was really cool! And they're two of my favourites especially after Adrianna's departure.
Title: Re: Whodunnit?
Post by: SuperTux on July 16, 2013, 11:38:23 PM
Why wasn't the cougar killed by the cyanide?

P.S. When the killer called Giles at dinner, all contestants alive by then claimed on the phone that s/he was the killer except one person:
Show content
Geno
who didn't say anything like "I'm
Show content
Geno
and I'm the killer blablabla..."
Title: Re: Whodunnit?
Post by: Polaroid on July 21, 2013, 09:14:37 PM
WHAT JUST HAPPENED. :ascared I love how there's the added dimension of the alliances. Makes it so much more interesting. I'm totally on team Lindsey/Kam/Cris. :)

I think the killer is
Show content
Lindsey
.
Title: Re: Whodunnit?
Post by: realshowfan on July 22, 2013, 12:22:15 PM
WHAT JUST HAPPENED. :ascared I love how there's the added dimension of the alliances. Makes it so much more interesting. I'm totally on team Lindsey/Kam/Cris. :)

I think the killer is
Show content
Lindsey
.

I'm sad at who got eliminated. :'(
Show content
Still banking on Lindsey or Cris to be the killer, with Melina as the third (and my initial prime suspect).
This episode had more sabotage edits than the last few. Or at least they were more evident. Still can't find any hidden clues in the eppies. They could be really minute. :crazy:

And I notice how as the murders go on these players seem more and more neutral with the thought of impending death.  :lol: But they also seem to become more sarcastic and negative-thinking. :(
Title: Re: Whodunnit?
Post by: paldog123456 on July 22, 2013, 06:39:49 PM
I am not sure if it was just me or not, but it was actually quite creepy when they had the dead
Show content
Dana and Sasha
propped up on the piano all dolled-up in scary make-up. The other murders prior to this point were not overly creepy, but this next one actually looks terrifying. :lol:
Title: Re: Whodunnit?
Post by: realshowfan on July 22, 2013, 07:05:54 PM
You're not the only one, Paldog. I found it quite chilling, especially with the organ.

So far, the least impressive murders were imo Don and Ulysses. I mean,
Show content
how on Earth can the killer manage to smash that floorboard against Ulysses amongst the commotion? That bit was just mediocre.
Title: Re: Whodunnit?
Post by: Glamazon Racer on July 22, 2013, 10:10:49 PM
It was an interesting episode with lots of great strategy. I loved
Show content
the double murder <3
.

My bet for the killer is
Show content
Ronnie
for some reason, although I can also see
Show content
anyone on Team Kam
as the killer, ???
Title: Re: Whodunnit?
Post by: Polaroid on July 22, 2013, 11:40:04 PM
I agree, RSF. Those two murders were just plain pathetic. I don't like how Ulysses was killed... Too much chance and luck required for everything to work. Plus it's just kind of ridiculous. :lol: Can anyone tell me why he ended up naked too? :funny:
Title: Re: Whodunnit?
Post by: Nobita on July 23, 2013, 05:17:12 AM
"Red meets black, you're OK, Jack. Red meets yellow, you're a dead fellow."

"I hate this thing. It's satanic. Flames are coming out of the side of my face." :lol:
Title: Re: Whodunnit?
Post by: Reilly Queens on July 23, 2013, 05:47:43 AM
At least they died elegant <3

I also think the murders are random like that so they have to investigate to discover it.
Title: Re: Whodunnit?
Post by: Glamazon Racer on July 23, 2013, 10:43:16 AM
I agree that the Ulysses murder was probably the weakest. I quite liked Don's though tbh. My favourite one is Sheri's though lol. :lol:
Title: Re: Whodunnit?
Post by: RachelLeVega on July 23, 2013, 11:42:40 AM
The lion was actually real lol.
Lol, the cougar looked confused in the regular filmed version when the camera pointed to it.

I was watching missed episodes on ABC and all I have to say is, wow. The cinematography and "reactions" of the murder scenes were stunning! :colors Especially the "murders" with realistic plaster and make-up. LOVE the make-up artists on this show! What really upsets me is how Whodunnit is turning into a mini-version of Big Brother with Team Kam and Team Ronnie. :res: I watched to see how everyone recreates the accuracy of the murders, not people trying to put others down by undisclosing vital information. I give it four stars for now.

I still think Giles is the killer. :funny:
Title: Re: Whodunnit?
Post by: mtskier on July 27, 2013, 06:20:26 AM
From day one I guessed Melina or Melissa (not sure of her name) because she acted like she was acting as her reactions looked staged. Also she has been staying under the radar though on the first episode they showed her a lot.  I am pretty certain she is the mole.
Title: Re: Whodunnit?
Post by: Glamazon Racer on July 27, 2013, 09:14:13 AM
From day one I guessed Melina or Melissa (not sure of her name) because she acted like she was acting as her reactions looked staged. Also she has been staying under the radar though on the first episode they showed her a lot.  I am pretty certain she is the mole.

Welcome to RFF mtskier! :waves:

Your prediction could very well be true! ;)

(And it's Melina BTW :))
Title: Re: Whodunnit?
Post by: RudyRules on July 28, 2013, 01:40:37 PM
I think we have series similar to The Mole! Interestingly enough, it's airing on ABC, the same channel that aired The Mole. It's basically the same as The Mole, but way creepier. :lol:

The premise (copied from Wikipedia):

The series will follow 13 investigators living in a mansion, Rue Manor, where one of the investigators is the "killer". A "murder" will take place around which the players will base their investigation using CSI technology and establishing pacts among one another. At the end of each episode, each player, in a private video confession, will explain how the murder took place. During dinner, each investigator will receive an envelope. Those who deduced most accurately receive a card saying "Spared", while those doing the worst receive a card saying "Scared" and will be up for elimination. During the night, the "killer" will "murder" one of the "Scared" players, eliminating them from the game, and setting up the "murder" for the next episode. In the finale, the investigator to correctly solve the identity of the "killer" wins $250,000.
Wow, I hadn't heard about this show until now!  I'm a big Mole fan, but not sure I'd like this one. :hides Sounds purdy creepy.  Might chk it out tho just for the hecuvit! ??   ???
Title: Re: Whodunnit?
Post by: Reilly Queens on July 28, 2013, 08:03:44 PM
Dana died so elegant <3
Title: Re: Whodunnit?
Post by: Polaroid on July 28, 2013, 09:09:02 PM
Dana and Sasha had such creepy murders. I think scariest too... well, that's until the latest murder. Melina screaming when Giles joined the party was so funny. :funny:

I want
Show content
Melina
to win, but I'm afraid that
Show content
she's the killer because she hasn't been scared or the strongest performer yet.

My guess for killer is
Show content
still Lindsey.
Title: Re: Whodunnit?
Post by: realshowfan on July 29, 2013, 09:31:13 AM
Sasha and Dana's murder scene was indeed the creepiest one thus far. This whole murder was the creepiest thus far. I really really got the heebie-jeebies watching Dana's scene from start to end. That was the most torturous kill so far, and to someone like Dana made it plain cruel.

Show content
I have to say Cris is very impressive with her clue performance.

Now we're down to five! Cris, Lindsey and Melina still in it! My bet is that either those three make it to the Final Three (with one being the killer), or Lindsey replaced by Kam.
Title: Re: Whodunnit?
Post by: Glamazon Racer on July 29, 2013, 12:09:05 PM
Certainly a very interesting episode. My favourite murder so far, I think! :P

For the killer, I'm thinking
Show content
Cris
now, because
Show content
she always seems one step ahead with those investigations, but maybe that's just down to good detective work...
but
Show content
Lindsey
is also suspicious. To be honest though, I could really see any of them being the killer.

I am very fascinated to see
Show content
who Kam will suspect as the killer next week, considering he's been accusing Geno in every single episode
.

I'm really into the show now - can't wait until next week's episode! :) I like everyone remaining - some more than others - so for the most part it is really fun watching the show.
Title: Re: Whodunnit?
Post by: Polaroid on August 04, 2013, 09:08:57 PM
That episode was crazy... I couldn't believe that
Show content
Ronnie and Melina couldn't solve the riddle! AGH I wanted both of them to live because Cris and Kam are just big nasty liars.
However, I'm glad that
Show content
Melina
is still alive.

I feel like the killer
Show content
has to be someone on team Kam.
My guess for killer is
Show content
now Kam because it seems like he has a lot of control for whether or not the information is given... or maybe it's Cris. I don't think it's Lindsey anymore. I didn't realize this, but she always sounds really unsure of herself and shaky when she's stating her case...

I'm so excited for the next episode.
Show content
I want Melina to solve the riddle and maybe all 3 of them squirm, hehe.
Title: Re: Whodunnit?
Post by: realshowfan on August 05, 2013, 08:12:34 AM
This episode was great <3 I love how they're really making the things harder to solve now!

Show content
I'm so happy that Melina made it instead of Ronnie, because I don't want to have to rethink everything all over again. :lol: Still banking on Cris, Lindsey and Melina for F3 including one of them being the Killer (then watch me jinx myself and that Kam wins/is the Killer :lol: ).

As for the next episode,
Show content
GO MELINA UNDERDOG! :hearts: :conf: Or Killer  :snicker:  But I definitely hope the edit of the preview is not misleading and that Melina is really playing it tough and independently now. If she's the Killer, now would be the best time to win that Clue-finding game, because if Cris is the Killer I think Cris has done that (win two clues in a row in order to give Team Kam the upper hand so that people won't be suspicious of her by saying 'she doesn't have that vital info, how is she Spared?' etc.

If I have to choose, I'd say Lindsey isn't the Killer out of the three, and that she was just the perfect scapegoat for the producers to put the spotlight on her because she was in that swinging position.
Title: Re: Whodunnit?
Post by: Glamazon Racer on August 05, 2013, 01:03:54 PM
It sure was a great episode! Particularly with
Show content
Lindsey
having one area to explore by themselves, as is naturally the case with only 5 left.

THe riddle portion was very interesting but unfortunately
Show content
Ronnie and Melina are not good with word scrambles!
.

I'm still very very very firmly behind
Show content
Cris
as the killer. I've been leaning between
Show content
Cris and Lindsey
for some time now, but
Show content
Cris
seems to fit the bill much better in my opinion.

I really can't wait to see the remainder of this game unfold! It's so fascinating!
Title: Re: Whodunnit?
Post by: Glamazon Racer on August 05, 2013, 01:06:42 PM
Also,
Show content
it was the first time Melina was accused as the killer
. I was very much anxious to see who
Show content
Kam would accuse, having accused Geno all season, and he opted for Melina which is interesting
.

Meanwhile,
Show content
Ronnie died having received zero accusations that he is the killer - the only other person to do so was Don apparently.
.
Title: Re: Whodunnit?
Post by: Leafsfan on August 06, 2013, 11:07:02 AM
Show content
Melina gets the riddle next week its clearly indicated in the preview.

Show content
I think the killer is Melina.
Title: Re: Whodunnit?
Post by: paldog123456 on August 11, 2013, 09:08:44 PM
If only
Show content
Melina
had solved that riddle. :'(

I think the Killer is
Show content
Cris
.
Title: Re: Whodunnit?
Post by: coolio on August 11, 2013, 09:13:02 PM
Even though it isn't clearly stated, I think it's obvious
Show content
Melina was killed.
Title: Re: Whodunnit?
Post by: Polaroid on August 11, 2013, 10:48:34 PM
Show content
WHYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYY. :'( SHE FOUGHT SO HARD.
Title: Re: Whodunnit?
Post by: realshowfan on August 12, 2013, 07:33:39 AM
Show content
NOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO!!!!!!!!!!!!!! :'( :'( :'(

But wait, that means her emotions and sarcasms/somber utterances (especially regarding Giles  :lol: ) were true. o_O

Man! I wanted her to be the Killer or the Winner! A little part of me dearly wishes the editing was sososo good that they convinced us that Melina was the one dead, even though they showed Lindsey's back as she ran with Kam outside in the finale preview...

Well, anyway, I'm excited for the finale! I really hope there will be a season two! Now, I think
Show content
Cris
is the Killer and
Show content
Kam
will win. I think, for Killer clues,
Show content
the paintings of a girl around Rue Manor is Cris. It's been twice at least that she's mentioned about her dad being a cop, teaching her how to use guns etc.

I'm excited for the zombies... I think.  :lol:
Title: Re: Whodunnit?
Post by: WinTar on August 12, 2013, 09:16:05 AM
Show content
I don't think that the disappearance of Melina means she was the one killed. ???
It may just be to confuse us and yes, we still don't know who was the one killed between Lindsey & Melina.
Title: Re: Whodunnit?
Post by: Glamazon Racer on August 12, 2013, 11:49:46 PM
OMG what an amazing episode. <33333
Show content
Melina
was so fierce this episode!

And the ending was so intense!
Show content
No idea who will be killed - I'm not sure Melina's disappearance means she's dead. I just hope Melina survives (and Giles :P).

Very convinced that the killer is
Show content
Cris
. Have been saying it for some time now, I've been convinced it was
Show content
Cris
ever since
Show content
Geno's
death, although I had my suspicions earlier.

I love this show! There just has to be a second season! :hearts:
Title: Re: Whodunnit?
Post by: coolio on August 14, 2013, 04:13:48 PM
Show content
I don't think that the disappearance of Melina means she was the one killed. ???
It may just be to confuse us and yes, we still don't know who was the one killed between Lindsey & Melina.
The thing is
Show content
though, Lindsay was clearly seen in the preview as competing in the puzzle along with Kam and Cris.
Title: Re: Whodunnit?
Post by: Glamazon Racer on August 15, 2013, 12:10:12 AM
Show content
I don't think that the disappearance of Melina means she was the one killed. ???
It may just be to confuse us and yes, we still don't know who was the one killed between Lindsey & Melina.
The thing is
Show content
though, Lindsay was clearly seen in the preview as competing in the puzzle along with Kam and Cris.

Maybe
Show content
Giles is the one that died and all four are still alive solving his death. :P
Title: Re: Whodunnit?
Post by: coolio on August 18, 2013, 09:26:48 AM
It's Finale Night!
Winner/Killer predictions?
Show content
Cris/Lindsay for me
Title: Re: Whodunnit?
Post by: Reilly Queens on August 18, 2013, 09:37:33 AM
Heart/Brain

Heart:
Winner: Lindsay
Killer: Cris
RUp: Kam

Brain:
Winner: Kam
Killer: Lindsay
RUp: Cris
Title: Re: Whodunnit?
Post by: Glamazon Racer on August 18, 2013, 10:15:36 AM
Mine are:


Show content
Heart:
Winner: Melina (somehow alive ???)
Killer: Cris
Runner-Up: Kam

Brain:
Winner: Cris
Killer: Lindsey
Runner-Up: Kam

Gut:
Winner: Lindsey
Killer: Kam
Runner-Up: Cris

Heart/brain/gut are all having different Killer predictions lol. :lol: :P
Title: Re: Whodunnit?
Post by: Polaroid on August 18, 2013, 05:48:22 PM
Everything (:lol:):

Winner: Kam
Killer: Cris
Runner-Up: Lindsey

Except I want Melina to win but I don't think that'll be happening. :lol:
Title: Re: Whodunnit?
Post by: Reilly Queens on August 18, 2013, 09:00:43 PM
Show content
Cris as the mole <333
Title: Re: Whodunnit?
Post by: WinTar on August 18, 2013, 11:25:24 PM
Everything (:lol:):

Winner: Kam
Killer: Cris
Runner-Up: Lindsey

Except I want Melina to win but I don't think that'll be happening. :lol:
Show content
Such spot on predictions! :lol:
Title: Re: Whodunnit?
Post by: Glamazon Racer on August 19, 2013, 04:06:16 AM
Show content
OMG CRIS <33333333333333333333333333333

Kinda weird but after seeing constant images of those suits of armour throughout the series, a few weeks ago I was beginning to speculate that the killer would rig one of them up to shoot somebody! :lol3: I wish they did that earlier on though - would've been fun to investigate. :P

Congrats to Kam! Would've preferred Lindsey to win, but I just loved the whole cast!
Title: Re: Whodunnit?
Post by: Polaroid on August 19, 2013, 04:29:04 AM
Show content
I found it so weird seeing the dead people not... dead. :lol: I think it's crazy how Lindsey thought Cris was the killer from the beginning... and yet she lost to someone who never even accused Cris of being the killer. Kind of disappointing and unfortunate for Lindsey.
Title: Re: Whodunnit?
Post by: Glamazon Racer on August 19, 2013, 05:14:38 AM
Show content
I also really loved the random cops that came to arrest Cris. That was hilarious. <3

And I quite agree with Polaroid - weird how Lindsey accused Cris every time and lost to someone who never did so. :lol:
Title: Re: Whodunnit?
Post by: SuperTux on August 19, 2013, 06:38:56 AM
I think it's more reasonable to call the show "Howdunnit" not "Whodunnit."

The winner didn't pick out the murderer until the very last episode.

Title: Re: Whodunnit?
Post by: realshowfan on August 19, 2013, 08:11:47 AM
I think it's more reasonable to call the show "Howdunnit" not "Whodunnit."

The winner didn't pick out the murderer until the very last episode.

You are right. There really is no point in having the Killer be amongst the group if the Killer didn't have to put hints out there and the answer for who the people think is the Killer was useless in tallying the score.

imo this finale was anything but unpredictable, except for the policemen.  :funny:

Show content
Yay at getting prediction right <33 But I based it off on what I thought were hints throughout the game, but now I guess a random guess would've resulted to a reasonable accusation. :lol:  :groan:

I'm so happy for Kam! And Lindsey's death was hilarious, I don't know if this sounds sadistic but I found her face funny when she got 'hit' by the arrow. lol

So what WAS the clue at the foyer at the beginning??!
Show content
That her dad was a cop? Or maybe after rewatching it, when everyone was at the sofa area chatting, with Kam's confessional VO, Cris didn't seem to be there. That she proposed the toast to explore the house? Or was that Twitter post completely unrelated?!

I want season 2!!!
Title: Re: Whodunnit?
Post by: WinTar on August 19, 2013, 09:16:28 AM
Show content
The foyer clue was that she knows how to use guns and also about she rides horses and some stuff like that. I don't know, but she said this in her Q&A she did after the finale in Twitter. ;)

About the finale, I didn't like that the challenge determined the winner, but it was very entertaining to watch. I agree with you guys that the accusations of who the Killer is should at least be a factor on who the winner should be. Lindsey should've won though, IMO. :(
Title: Re: Whodunnit?
Post by: Glamazon Racer on August 19, 2013, 11:34:34 AM
Show content
It is very bizarre. Making the accusations each week seemed to serve no purpose... :(

But regardless, I REALLY want a Season 2! This is the only show on TV that combines my two favourite genres - reality and crime/procedural. :P
Title: Re: Whodunnit?
Post by: Cocoa on August 19, 2013, 02:35:08 PM
it was so absurd, campy, outrageous, and hilarious.. and that's the reason why I love it! :lol: I'd watch a Season 2!

I really thought Melina was the killer because of her over-the-top acting :lol:
Title: Re: Whodunnit?
Post by: Leafsfan on August 20, 2013, 04:35:45 PM
What if Lyndsay solved the riddled before Kris then what :lol:
Title: Re: Whodunnit?
Post by: coolio on August 20, 2013, 07:11:57 PM
What if Lyndsay solved the riddled before Kris then what :lol:
Lindsay probably still would have gotten the clue to go to the library.
Title: Re: Whodunnit?
Post by: hithere86 on September 02, 2013, 12:45:54 PM
Entertaining.  The deaths were the best bit.  Hope it's renewed.
Title: Re: Whodunnit?
Post by: paldog123456 on September 05, 2013, 03:48:52 PM
What if Lyndsay solved the riddled before Kris then what :lol:
Lindsay probably still would have gotten the clue to go to the library.

They revealed in a later interview that all 3 finalists completed the final challenge at different times so no copying and waiting for clue stations would occur. This means that Lindsay would have still gone to the library and met the knight. :lol:
Title: Re: Whodunnit?
Post by: RealityFan68 on May 19, 2014, 12:08:49 PM
Is this show coming back for a Season 2??  I can't find an answer anywhere!  :tantrum
Title: Re: Whodunnit?
Post by: Glamazon Racer on May 21, 2014, 11:47:05 AM
Just saw this off Wikipedia:

"Although never officially cancelled, when ABC announced their summer schedule Whodunnit failed to appear, thus leaving viewers to the assumption of a cancellation."

Hopefully that's not the case, but it certainly doesn't look good at least for this summer... :(
Title: Re: Whodunnit?
Post by: RealityFan68 on May 21, 2014, 10:09:15 PM
Just saw this off Wikipedia:

"Although never officially cancelled, when ABC announced their summer schedule Whodunnit failed to appear, thus leaving viewers to the assumption of a cancellation."

Hopefully that's not the case, but it certainly doesn't look good at least for this summer... :(


Oh that sucks, that news! :tantrum :tantrum :tantrum
Title: Re: Whodunnit?
Post by: Glamazon Racer on May 22, 2014, 02:27:20 AM
Yeah. :(
Title: Re: Whodunnit?
Post by: Polaroid on May 22, 2014, 02:55:08 AM
Wouldn't surprise me if it was cancelled, but I would have loved to see another season. There was a lot of potential and with improvements, it would be great. :(
Title: Re: Whodunnit?
Post by: gamerfan09 on May 22, 2014, 03:34:15 AM
I'm still holding on hope. What if ABC turns it into a regular and not summer show as a surprise in the future? :P

This show was definitely going to be "The Mole" of the 2010s, and I would like at least one or two more seasons! :P
Title: Re: Whodunnit?
Post by: Glamazon Racer on May 22, 2014, 03:51:35 AM
I don't know if it would do well in a regular schedule with a lot more competition, but it was certainly a great summer show - hopefully they are just taking a break and revisit it at some point!
Title: Re: Whodunnit?
Post by: SuperTux on May 22, 2014, 07:41:18 AM
Just saw this off Wikipedia:

"Although never officially cancelled, when ABC announced their summer schedule Whodunnit failed to appear, thus leaving viewers to the assumption of a cancellation."

Hopefully that's not the case, but it certainly doesn't look good at least for this summer... :(

But there is a casting hall for Whodunnit 2014 on ABC official page. Here: http://www.castingcallhub.com/whodunnit-abc/
Title: Re: Whodunnit?
Post by: Glamazon Racer on May 22, 2014, 10:12:41 AM
Just saw this off Wikipedia:

"Although never officially cancelled, when ABC announced their summer schedule Whodunnit failed to appear, thus leaving viewers to the assumption of a cancellation."

Hopefully that's not the case, but it certainly doesn't look good at least for this summer... :(

But there is a casting hall for Whodunnit 2014 on ABC official page. Here: http://www.castingcallhub.com/whodunnit-abc/

Well let's hope! :)
Title: Re: Whodunnit?
Post by: paradoxinee on May 22, 2014, 03:27:05 PM
I hope that if the show has season 2, guessing who the murder is will be an important factor to decide who win. I love the first season. But the fact Kam won over Lindsay was just suck.
Title: Re: Whodunnit?
Post by: RealityFan68 on May 23, 2014, 12:18:03 PM
I hope that if the show has season 2, guessing who the murder is will be an important factor to decide who win. I love the first season. But the fact Kam won over Lindsay was just suck.

Totally Agree with you!  Kam was way too cocky!

The improvements they need to make are related to how the audience looked at the show.  So many of us saw clues where there weren't any such as the Iron Maiden, Kam and Melina's names and meaning.  They need to make it more cohesive with clues and audience participation through watching the show, not just how someone got it.  they need to put some of their creativity out there and takes us on a wild ride!
Title: Re: Whodunnit?
Post by: Glamazon Racer on May 24, 2014, 10:12:15 PM
I suppose Kam got more quiz answers and stuff right but had the killer chosen incorrectly, but it would be nice if that played a bigger role.
Title: Re: Whodunnit?
Post by: paradoxinee on May 26, 2014, 07:11:34 PM
I suppose Kam got more quiz answers and stuff right but had the killer chosen incorrectly, but it would be nice if that played a bigger role.

As I remember, the last episode, they just played a game about everything happened and until then Kam was still wrong about the killer. He was just faster then the other two.
Title: Re: Whodunnit?
Post by: Glamazon Racer on May 27, 2014, 03:07:30 AM
Yep - he also won the advnatage and had one less station to go to during the game, which was really big in hindsight.
Title: Re: Whodunnit?
Post by: Platrium on November 29, 2015, 07:41:12 AM
I watched the 1st and only season over a year ago, and I'm still hoping for a 2nd season until today.